There is a lot of information on this thread on the subject of the Maurya , thanks mostly to the dedicated and comprehensive efforts of Dr. Rajpal Singh.
I would like to see his example followed by other Academics and aspiring Academicians- those studying, or teaching or planning to teach History.
The information we have so far, is a based on scholars, who have made a study of the linguistic sources, be they in Sanskrit, Pali, Hindi, English , Greek, Latin Arabic etc. Arguably, to name just a few , many of these scholars, Majumdar, Sircar, Rajendra Lal Mitra, R.P. Chanda, Wilson, Keith, were high order intellectuals, who had achieved high academic status in their times.
A weakness however, has been the colouring of the study of the Indian history sources, by Aryan Invasion theory, thanks to which the dates thrown up by the Indians Sources( Vedic/Puranic sources) are summarily rejected.
This 18th/19th century thinking still dominates Indian Academicia. Ancient civilizations are not new. The Egyptian /Mesopotamian civilizations dating is accepted back to 4,000 BCE or more . Research is also pointing to the ancient civilizations of South America and the Mediterranean for similar dates.
It becomes a puzzle why only the civilization in the Indian subcontinent is downgraded, and any achievements of this civilization is ascribed to invaders who supposedly invaded in 1,500 BCE or so. The answer for those interested is not hard to find, as the Aryan Invasion theory was a political construct of 19th century Europeans.
The damage has been done.
A cursory review of current discussions on History will show that most of the discussioné arguments are with Western scholars, in attempts to get them to think in terms of overturning this theory and to get some reasonable vesrions of history and chronological dates into order.
Added to this is the lack of confidence in Indian researchers, and the need in them to get approval from their western counterparts. Those who do not are relegated to the dustbin. Wikipedia is a cse in point with its emphasis on published sources, with no critical review.Junk is accepted because some one ( usually an English speaking westerner ) has published someting somewhere. A mob rule. ) The Wiki Jat pages are a good example.
There is little or no energy left to actually to do any primary forward looking thinking or research.
Another weakness is that the standard historians do not take into account the scientific sources. Radio -carbon dating is generally as far as they go.
The reason for that is simple, most historians are not comfortable with the sciences- mathematics, algebra, quadratics equations and the like, and write their accounts of history around these topics, as they do not have the academic skills needed.
Another weakness in the Indian outlook is the heavy influence of religion and the inability of historians to rise above it.
It did not help that the historical texts- the vedas, took on a religious hue, and religion became the prime lens through which these corpuses of knowledge were looked .
If these texts are looked as rationally and scientifically, they will be reduced to a body of knowledge , an encyclopedia, containing knowledge of the sciences, mathematics, astronomy, architecture, engineering, medicine, history, and yes, religion and spirituality.
In later times , ritual became the prime purpose, the be all and end all.
This was not the case always and initially the purpose of the yagya or series of Yagyas were to track and do the Yayga in accordance with the movement of the Sun, Moon, and stars, to establish a calendar for the agricultural needs, the overpoweringly dominant factor in the them society.
In subsequent times this purpose was lost.
A fog of mumbo jumbo , superstition, astrology, religious hokum pokum, bias took over.
To make sense of Indian history, this fog has to be cut through.
The chronology and history of the Maurya family has to be examined with the same approach.
Ravi Chaudhary