History and Historians on Jat Mauryan Empire[ founded by Chandragupta in c 323 BC]

The Indo-Aryan Races-A Study of The Origin of Indo-Aryan People and Institutions by Ramaprasad Chanda, First published 1916, Reprinted 1976 Indological Book Corporation, New Delhi contains a point wise criticism of the theory propounded by D B Spooner in his second paper on the Zorastrian Period of Indian History about the Maurya dynasty. Dr. Chanda has in the Chapter: "Indo Aryans and Iranians" pp. 220-241 takes pains to quote Dr. A C Huddon , H. Risley, Dr. D R Bhandarkar, Patanjali; Epigraphica Indica, and Satapatha Brahmana and several other sources and arrived at the conclusion that:

1. The pottery with the Persian altar emblazoned on it and the Persipolitan and grouping of the Maurya palaces disclosed by the excavation of the site of Patliputra should perhaps be attributed to the Persian architects and artizens employed by the Mauryas and not to the natives of Magadha whose ancestors are supposed to have come from Iran in the prehistoric period. The style of high-class architecture cannot be recognised as an evidence of the ethnic origin of the native population among whom the buildings are erected.
To be contd.
 
2. Dr. Chanda further takes on Dr. Spooner's theory and states as under:

The well known Sanskrit Drama Prabodhcandrodaya was written in the rein of King Kirtivarman Chandel of Kalinjar and was performed about A D 1065 {See, V.A. Smith, Early History of India, 3rd Ed., pp. 392-93.}. The statement contained in this work that "Magadha is mostly inhabited by the Mlecchas (Mlecchapraya)" cannot be accepted as evidence of Pre-historic Iranian immigration.

To be contd./3
 
The Indo-Aryan Races-A Study of The Origin of Indo-Aryan People and Institutions by Ramaprasad Chanda, First published 1916, Reprinted 1976 Indological Book Corporation, New Delhi contains a point wise criticism of the theory propounded by D B Spooner in his second paper on the Zorastrian Period of Indian History about the Maurya dynasty. Dr. Chanda has in the Chapter: "Indo Aryans and Iranians" pp. 220-241 takes pains to quote Dr. A C Huddon , H. Risley, Dr. D R Bhandarkar, Patanjali; Epigraphica Indica, and Satapatha Brahmana and several other sources and arrived at the conclusion that:

1. The pottery with the Persian altar emblazoned on it and the Persipolitan and grouping of the Maurya palaces disclosed by the excavation of the site of Patliputra should perhaps be attributed to the Persian architects and artizens employed by the Mauryas and not to the natives of Magadha whose ancestors are supposed to have come from Iran in the prehistoric period. The style of high-class architecture cannot be recognised as an evidence of the ethnic origin of the native population among whom the buildings are erected.
To be contd.
 
Expressing his dissension from Dr. Spooner's view, Ram Prasad Chanda says that the "Classification of the Aryan languages of Northern India into two groups was never regarded, as beyond explanaation. One explaination was suggested by D. Hoernle, the author of this classification, and has been adopted by Sir George Grierson in a paper published entitled Origin of the Bengalis published in East and West (Bombay) of 1907. Dr. H C. Haddon, writes in The Races of Man (pp. 60-61):A zone of relatively broad-headed people extends from the great grazing country of the Western Punjab through the Decca to the Coorgs. Risley supports the view that this may be the track of Scythians, who found their progress east blocked by the Indo-Aryans and so turned south, and mingled with the Dravidian population, and became the ancestors of the Marathas and Canarese."

Mr. Chanda goes on to add that "But evidence seems to be lacking that the Scytheians penetrated far into the Deccan, and apart from brancycephaly there is little to associate these peoples with Scytheians. It seems to quite possible that these branchycephals are the members of the Alpine race from the highlands of South-west Asia in prehistoric times." ...ibid, pp.140-41.

To be contd..
 
Of course. I know a little about Spooner's work regarding Maurya and the Persian connection. Good to know his findings were rejected by other scholars. I think one must keep in mind that Orientalism was prevalent among 19th and 20th western scholars and probably clouded Spooners work also. It impacted some of the Indian historians as well later in the 20th century. Thank you for sharing your findings.

Kindly share your study on the topic please. A little bits would make a big one project.

Thanks
 
The fifthpoint raised by Mr. R P Chanda for criticism of the point of view of Dr.Spooner regarding foreign origin of the Maurya dynasty runs as under:<o:p></o:p>
“Thepresence of Sakadwipi Brahamans in Bihar throws no light on the ethnic originof the bulk of the population of Bihar. The Sakadwipi Brahmans are also knownas Bhojaka or Maga Brahamans, the last designation being considered asidentical with Magus and on that ground the Maga Brahmans are recognized bysome scholars as the modern representatives of the Persian Magi who migrated toIndia in the past. The legend of the coming of the Magi is narrated inBhavisyapuran (137)” and the legend of transportation of the Magas by Samba isreferred to in the Govindpur stone inscription of the poet Gangadhara ‘datedSaka 1059, corresponding to AD 1137-38.<o:p></o:p>
Mr. Chandaavers that “this legend is probably based on tradition that the Magas were offorein origion—evidently related to the race of Jarasastra or Zarathushtra—andinaugurated the Saura cult in India. Inthe Vishnupuran II.4.69-70 Magha [variant Mrgah], Magadhag, Manasah andMandagaha are given as the names of the Brahmans, Ksatriyas, Vaisyas and Sudrasrespectively of Sakadvipa. In a palm - leaf Manuscript of the MahabharatainBengali character in the collection of the Varendra Research Society, in theBhsmapavavan [II, 35-38] we read” :………………the English translation is…………..”There[in Sakadvipa] are four holy countries praised by men—Maga, Masaka, Manasa andMandaga. Maga [contains] numerous Brahamans devoted to their duties. In Masakathere are Rajanyas pious and munificent, O King. O Maharaja, Manasas earn theirbred by performing the duties of the Vaisya….the Mandagas are ever piousSudras.”<o:p></o:p>
He, further,produces another evidence to contradict Spooner’s view by saying: “In theBombay edition of the Mahabharata and in the new edition based on the SouthIndian MSS. [printed in Bombay] we have Mangah, and in other editions Mrgah,instead of Maga. Magadha of the Vishnupurana is evidently a misreading forMasaka of the Mahabharata and so the Magadha cannot be connected withSakadvipa. Butas the Magas are not mentioned in any of the earlier texts,though the Magadhas and the Magadgadesiyabrahmanabandhus are, the time of thecoming of the Magi cannot be pushed very far back.<o:p></o:p>
<o:p> </o:p>
To becontd…/6<o:p></o:p>
 
Concluding remarks on the origin of Mauryas
;
To support his thesis, R P Chanda quotes more authorities. He by takes a quotation from ’The Indian Antiquary, XVI, p. 162’, of Weber, who says: “The Magas go back toan old mission of the Mithra-cult, the members of which, after their arrival inIndia[about the first two centuries A.D.], were incorporated in the Brahmancaste.” Sir RG Bhandarkar also writes:“On the coins of Kanishka there occurs a figure with the name Miiro=Mihir[Persian Mihr=Mithra] by its side…the cult, therefore, must have penetrated toIndia about the time of that Kushana prince, and the Multan[ Skt. Mulasthana]temple, which was its original set, must have been constructed about the sametime. Cited from Vaisnavism, etc, p. 154}”


R. P. Chandaconcludes his discussion on the issue by adding, though pottery with thePersian emblazoned on it is said to have been unearthed at the site ofPatliputra, there is nothing peculiarly Persian in the religion of Magadha inthe Maurya period as known from the Kautiliya Arthasastra, the edicts of Asokaand other sources.”

In this way, the learned author has demolished the views of Spooner assigning foreign origin and proved his point with the help of sources cited from literature, numismatic and archaeology. This discussion leaves little scope for doubting the Indian origin of the Mauryan dynasty founded by Chandragupta. Even now, if some one has any argument to offer against this view he/she is welcome to share with us his findings.
<o:p></o:p>

<o:p></o:p>
<o:p> </o:p>
 
Last edited:
Friends,

It is requested that whosoever has concrete information on the sources reflecting Chronology of the Maurya Rulers [Mauryan dynasty] so that a final view could be made out of this discussion on the issue of the thread.

Your valuable hints would go a long way in deciding the issue.

Thanking you all.
 
There is a lot of information on this thread on the subject of the Maurya , thanks mostly to the dedicated and comprehensive efforts of Dr. Rajpal Singh.

I would like to see his example followed by other Academics and aspiring Academicians- those studying, or teaching or planning to teach History.

The information we have so far, is a based on scholars, who have made a study of the linguistic sources, be they in Sanskrit, Pali, Hindi, English , Greek, Latin Arabic etc. Arguably, to name just a few , many of these scholars, Majumdar, Sircar, Rajendra Lal Mitra, R.P. Chanda, Wilson, Keith, were high order intellectuals, who had achieved high academic status in their times.

A weakness however, has been the colouring of the study of the Indian history sources, by Aryan Invasion theory, thanks to which the dates thrown up by the Indians Sources( Vedic/Puranic sources) are summarily rejected.

This 18th/19th century thinking still dominates Indian Academicia. Ancient civilizations are not new. The Egyptian /Mesopotamian civilizations dating is accepted back to 4,000 BCE or more . Research is also pointing to the ancient civilizations of South America and the Mediterranean for similar dates.

It becomes a puzzle why only the civilization in the Indian subcontinent is downgraded, and any achievements of this civilization is ascribed to invaders who supposedly invaded in 1,500 BCE or so. The answer for those interested is not hard to find, as the Aryan Invasion theory was a political construct of 19th century Europeans.

The damage has been done.

A cursory review of current discussions on History will show that most of the discussioné arguments are with Western scholars, in attempts to get them to think in terms of overturning this theory and to get some reasonable vesrions of history and chronological dates into order.

Added to this is the lack of confidence in Indian researchers, and the need in them to get approval from their western counterparts. Those who do not are relegated to the dustbin. Wikipedia is a cse in point with its emphasis on published sources, with no critical review.Junk is accepted because some one ( usually an English speaking westerner ) has published someting somewhere. A mob rule. ) The Wiki Jat pages are a good example.

There is little or no energy left to actually to do any primary forward looking thinking or research.

Another weakness is that the standard historians do not take into account the scientific sources. Radio -carbon dating is generally as far as they go.

The reason for that is simple, most historians are not comfortable with the sciences- mathematics, algebra, quadratics equations and the like, and write their accounts of history around these topics, as they do not have the academic skills needed.

Another weakness in the Indian outlook is the heavy influence of religion and the inability of historians to rise above it.

It did not help that the historical texts- the vedas, took on a religious hue, and religion became the prime lens through which these corpuses of knowledge were looked .

If these texts are looked as rationally and scientifically, they will be reduced to a body of knowledge , an encyclopedia, containing knowledge of the sciences, mathematics, astronomy, architecture, engineering, medicine, history, and yes, religion and spirituality.

In later times , ritual became the prime purpose, the be all and end all.

This was not the case always and initially the purpose of the yagya or series of Yagyas were to track and do the Yayga in accordance with the movement of the Sun, Moon, and stars, to establish a calendar for the agricultural needs, the overpoweringly dominant factor in the them society.

In subsequent times this purpose was lost.

A fog of mumbo jumbo , superstition, astrology, religious hokum pokum, bias took over.

To make sense of Indian history, this fog has to be cut through.

The chronology and history of the Maurya family has to be examined with the same approach.

Ravi Chaudhary
 
Last edited:
If I were to attempt a summary it would be something like this.
Conventional historians

1) Identify Chandra gupt Maurya with Sandrocottus of Alexander times.

2) The dating is therefore is circa 325 BC.

3) All chronology of Indian history is based on this. This is the sheet anchor of Indian History .

4) Puranic chronology is deemed fantastic, and junk.

A growing circle of opposition to this views holds

1) Puranic accounts do not know Alexander or his invasion.

2) Indian( Puranic) chronology is based on the Kali era -3102 BCE.

3) In the Puranic chronology the Mauryas are dated circa 1600 BCE or so. Buddha is dated 1800 BCE or so etc etc

4) The period of the Alexander is occupied by the 2nd Gupts.

Ravi Chaudhary
 
Kindly share your study on the topic please. A little bits would make a big one project.

Thanks

Dr Singh,

My understanding of this debate is much less than what you have presented above, quoting Dr Chanda. All I know is that the Director of ASI at that time, John Marshall, was skeptical of Spooner's conclusions, even though his digs at Kumrahar were considered noteworthy.

I did a little online search and found some further conclusions, which might help here. First is by K P Jayaswal who was a contemporary of Spooner and criticized Spooners conclusions. Second was a later conclusion by Wheeler and even he was skeptical of Spooners conclusions.

Dr Chanda's findings provide good conclusions so thanks again for sharing them here.
 
Dr Singh,

My understanding of this debate is much less than what you have presented above, quoting Dr Chanda. All I know is that the Director of ASI at that time, John Marshall, was skeptical of Spooner's conclusions, even though his digs at Kumrahar were considered noteworthy.

I did a little online search and found some further conclusions, which might help here. First is by K P Jayaswal who was a contemporary of Spooner and criticized Spooners conclusions. Second was a later conclusion by Wheeler and even he was skeptical of Spooners conclusions.

Dr Chanda's findings provide good conclusions so thanks again for sharing them here.

Friend,

It is so nice of you to have posted the information and to learn through it that Dr. K P Jayaswal and Dr. John Marshall also support the line that R P Chanda adopted to repudiate the findings of Spooner on the Mauryas. I shall try to find out the fuller details on the issue and then revert back to share the same with the Jatland.

Though I am putting unnecessary burden on you yet permit me to ask you if you could share some [original or secondary source based] information on the chronology of the Maurya Dynasty founded by Chandragupta.

Thanks.
 
If I were to attempt a summary it would be something like this.
Conventional historians

1) Identify Chandra gupt Maurya with Sandrocottus of Alexander times.

2) The dating is therefore is circa 325 BC.

3) All chronology of Indian history is based on this. This is the sheet anchor of Indian History .

4) Puranic chronology is deemed fantastic, and junk.

A growing circle of opposition to this views holds

1) Puranic accounts do not know Alexander or his invasion.

2) Indian( Puranic) chronology is based on the Kali era -3102 BCE.

3) In the Puranic chronology the Mauryas are dated circa 1600 BCE or so. Buddha is dated 1800 BCE or so etc etc

4) The period of the Alexander is occupied by the 2nd Gupts.

Ravi Chaudhary

Chaudhary Sahib,

You have very aptly provided two alternate routes to scholars to tread for finding out the real dates/times of the Indian Historical events and personages.

I am open to accept newest challenge to explore the Indian point of view to re-write, at least the Mauryan History. But I am aware of my limitations. Hence, need of seeking guidance from other fellow scholars.

I am just curious to know from any of the scholars across the world to suggest us if one selects the Indian classical literature to depend upon setting the chronology of say the Maurya dynasty, which Purana/Puranas or any other classical literary writing could be taken as base to co-relate/reject the other available sources like archaeological, numismatic and literary sources already used by other scholars of the first school of thought.

Thanks and regards
 
There is a lot of information on this thread on the subject of the Maurya , thanks mostly to the dedicated and comprehensive efforts of Dr. Rajpal Singh.

I would like to see his example followed by other Academics and aspiring Academicians- those studying, or teaching or planning to teach History.

The information we have so far, is a based on scholars, who have made a study of the linguistic sources, be they in Sanskrit, Pali, Hindi, English , Greek, Latin Arabic etc. Arguably, to name just a few , many of these scholars, Majumdar, Sircar, Rajendra Lal Mitra, R.P. Chanda, Wilson, Keith, were high order intellectuals, who had achieved high academic status in their times.

A weakness however, has been the colouring of the study of the Indian history sources, by Aryan Invasion theory, thanks to which the dates thrown up by the Indians Sources( Vedic/Puranic sources) are summarily rejected.

This 18th/19th century thinking still dominates Indian Academicia. Ancient civilizations are not new. The Egyptian /Mesopotamian civilizations dating is accepted back to 4,000 BCE or more . Research is also pointing to the ancient civilizations of South America and the Mediterranean for similar dates.

It becomes a puzzle why only the civilization in the Indian subcontinent is downgraded, and any achievements of this civilization is ascribed to invaders who supposedly invaded in 1,500 BCE or so. The answer for those interested is not hard to find, as the Aryan Invasion theory was a political construct of 19th century Europeans.

The damage has been done.

A cursory review of current discussions on History will show that most of the discussioné arguments are with Western scholars, in attempts to get them to think in terms of overturning this theory and to get some reasonable vesrions of history and chronological dates into order.

Added to this is the lack of confidence in Indian researchers, and the need in them to get approval from their western counterparts. Those who do not are relegated to the dustbin. Wikipedia is a cse in point with its emphasis on published sources, with no critical review.Junk is accepted because some one ( usually an English speaking westerner ) has published someting somewhere. A mob rule. ) The Wiki Jat pages are a good example.

There is little or no energy left to actually to do any primary forward looking thinking or research.

Another weakness is that the standard historians do not take into account the scientific sources. Radio -carbon dating is generally as far as they go.

The reason for that is simple, most historians are not comfortable with the sciences- mathematics, algebra, quadratics equations and the like, and write their accounts of history around these topics, as they do not have the academic skills needed.

Another weakness in the Indian outlook is the heavy influence of religion and the inability of historians to rise above it.

It did not help that the historical texts- the vedas, took on a religious hue, and religion became the prime lens through which these corpuses of knowledge were looked .

If these texts are looked as rationally and scientifically, they will be reduced to a body of knowledge , an encyclopedia, containing knowledge of the sciences, mathematics, astronomy, architecture, engineering, medicine, history, and yes, religion and spirituality.

In later times , ritual became the prime purpose, the be all and end all.

This was not the case always and initially the purpose of the yagya or series of Yagyas were to track and do the Yayga in accordance with the movement of the Sun, Moon, and stars, to establish a calendar for the agricultural needs, the overpoweringly dominant factor in the them society.

In subsequent times this purpose was lost.

A fog of mumbo jumbo , superstition, astrology, religious hokum pokum, bias took over.

To make sense of Indian history, this fog has to be cut through.

The chronology and history of the Maurya family has to be examined with the same approach.

Ravi Chaudhary

It would be a great leap forward if somebody armed with knowledge of examining the archaeological remains which are available in abundance of Indian ancient historical and pre-historical periods, could extend helping hand to untangle the knot of Indian Chronological sequence especially the chronology of the Maurya Dynasty founded by Chandragupta Maurya.
 
Does proper analysis of the available data on the first urbanisation of India during the Harappan (earlier known as Indus Valley Civilisation) hold key to setting of proper chronological order of Indian History?

If yes, then, it would be very useful information if somebody could throw light on the progress of efforts to study the pictorial writings on the seals/sealing found from the sites of Harappan Civilization.

I am curious to know if in this age of Science and Technology, some break through in deciphering them with the help of advanced computer systems might have been attempted to set the chronological order of Indian history somewhere/by somebody or not.

Learned views and comments of the scholars are eagerly awaited!
 
Last edited:
Does proper analysis of the available data on the first urbanisation of India during the Harappan (earlier known as Indus Valley Civilisation) hold key to setting of proper chronological order of Indian History?

If yes, then, it would be very useful information if somebody could throw light on the progress of efforts to study the pictorial writings on the seals/sealing found from the sites of Harappan Civilization.

I am curious to know if in this age of Science and Technology, some break through in deciphering them with the help of advanced computer systems might have been attempted to set the chronological order of Indian history somewhere/by somebody or not.

Learned views and comments of the scholars are eagerly awaited!



There is a saying about the use of computers- GIGO i.e Garbage in -Garbage out.

Computers are useful only for routine programmable tasks. They cannot not provide an insight.


The Harrapan civilization, as it is sometimes called, is a vital piece of the history of this nation.

Unfortunately Historians have so far divorced it from the culture and history, claiming it was a dead civilization with a dead unknown language and the culture , civilization, and languages of this nation were all imported.

Ravi Chaudhary
 
Last edited:
Kalhan’s work ‘ Rajarangini’ is quite informative.

Copies are now available online :
http://books.google.ca/books/about/Kalhana_s_Rajatarangini.html?id=4rcwLQDFh-EC&redir_esc=y

The relevant paragraphs are Book 1 , 48-59.

Per the book: Verse:

48/49 : Gonanda 1 and his successors ruled in Kaliyug for 2268 years. Some writers wrongly take Bharat war to b
e at juncture of Kali and Dwapara yugs

51: 653 years into Kali era, Kurus and Pandavs were on the earth.


52: At the present ( Kalhan’s time) , in the twenty fourth year of the Laukika [era], 1070 years of Saka era ( 78CE) have passed.

55: Per Brihatsamhita ( Varahamihir), Great Bear is moving from one Nakshatra to another- (Magha to Aslesh).

56: 2526 years before Saka( Shalivana era 78 CE),i.e. Kali 653, Yudhistra ruled the earth, and the Great Bear( Sapth Rishi) was in the nakshatra ‘magha’.

59: Gonanda 1, was a contemporary of Krishna, fought in the Bharat war, and was killed in it.

Note:
2526-78= 2448 BCE.

Per Varahmihir this is Yudhitrstra ‘s time, his era.

Kalhan is simply following the dating given in the Brihatsamhita.

In summary:

The Kali era is known to Kalhan. He places the Yudhisthras’s date at Kali 653 or 2448 BCE.

Kalhana knows the Laukika era well, which starts at Kali 25 (3102-25 = 3077 BCE), upon the death of Yudhisthra. Stein in his book, pp58, tells us, that his mentor Prof. Buhler, proved that the Laukika era started on Kali 2, i.e 3076-3075 BC. Book 8, versa 341, 480 prove that

Kalhana follows the Laukika era ldentically.

Knowing the Mahabharat well , as Kalhana does, it is a puzzle why he would state that Yudhistra was alive in Kali 653, or 2448 BC, when he is supposed to have died in Kali 25, the start of the Laukika era, which is also known as the Yudhistra era.

The Laukika era was widely used in Kashmir and various hill regions until recent times.

It is possible that errors crept in when the Rajatrangini mansucript was rewritten/copied from the Sharada script to the Devnagari script.

Ravi Chaudhary
 
Last edited:
On Use of Puranas as a Source of Ancient Indian History:

The date of the compilation of the Puranic literature is not certain and it cannot be stated definitely as to when they assumed their present shape. The earliest Puranas must have been very old and additions must have taken place at different times. The Puranas start with the rulers who trace their origin from the Sun and the Moon. They describe the various kings who ruled in the Madhya Desh. They fill the gap from the end of the epic age to the rise of Buddha. They give the names of the Puru Kings of Hastinapur and the Ikshavku kings of Kosala. They give the details about the Sisunaga kings and Nanda kings. It has been shown that the Vishnu Purana is very reliable as regards the Mauryan dynasty and the Matsya Purana is reliable as regards te Andhra and Saisunaga dynasties. The Vayu Purana describes the rule of the Guptas. In addition to it, at the end of the list of kings, certain Puranas give a series of dynastiess of low and barbarian origin such as Abhiras, Gardabhas, Sakas, Yavanass, Tusaras, Hunas and so on.

Dr. Winternitz considered the Puranas as valuable to the historian and to the antiquarian as source of political history on account of their genealogies. But in this regard, Dr. Altekar points out that in the dynastic lists, the Puranas themselves do not say that each successor in the list was a son or a relative of his predecessor. In many cases, they only say that so and so came after so and so, without indicating any relationship between them.

It seems that many a scholar almost ignore altogether the great value of the information contained in Indian classical literature even though the same has already been collated by the efforts of the orientalist scholars . They seem to suffer the old prejudice against the Puranas dating [chronological order of various dynasties] from the time of Lord Macaulay.

It is high time, as Shri Ravi Chaudhary has pointed out several times earlier in this very discussion, that scholars give up their prejudice against the Indian historical sources and give them a due place as a source of ancient Indian History.

P.L. Bhargava, India in the Vedic Age, pp. 15-16 while writing on the importance of Puranas as a source of Indian history repudiates Dr. Keith's scathing criticism of Puranas as the source of only religious and social issues, recommends to re-visit Puranas with open mind and use it for tracing history also in them.

It is clearly known that there are certain serious shortcomings have crept in the Puranic dating and genealogical account. This has led to mixing up of history with fables, folk-lore, details based on hearsay are not even corroborated from other Puranas or other reliable sources; rather at some places,the various Puranas give conflicting accounts.

In spite of this limitation, a lot of information is available in the Puranas which many scholars have done good research to elaborate their findings on the basis of Puranas. As we know a large number of articles and research papers have been written on the Puranas. Pargiter has also written Ancient Indian Historical Tradition and the Dynasties of the Kali Age. It is for the individual scholar to sort out the issues involved by taking a cue from the Puranas and continue efforts towards collating the same with other sources like other literary, archaeological, numismatics etc.

NB: To be continued to examine Buddhist and Jain sources
 
Last edited:
Actually all I am trying to do is see is the Maurya chronology is correct.

To do that, the Puranic chronology must also be examined.

It is irrelevant who Pargiter, McCaulay etc were or were not, and what their views were.

What is important is to examine the data they collected and see is there is any vailidity there.

Kalhan is given the status of a great Indian historian. That is also besides the point.

What is the validity of his work?

Hence the questioing of the statement ascribed to him, that Yudistra was alive in Kali 653, when accodring to the Puranic chronology and the Laukika era, Yudhitra expires on Kali +25 years, on 3077 BCE, 600+ years earlier.

That would be quite a big, elementary, basic, mistake for a historian like him, the accuracy of wwose work is obvious in the rest of the manuscript

or

then there must be an error in this portion the manuscript.

Only one of the above two scenarios can be valid.

With Kalhan out the way, the Puranic chronology takes on more substance.


Note: It is not important that there was a Mahabharat war in 3139 BCE, or that Krishan Bhagwan expire in 3102 BCE , thereby allowing the degraded kali era to ensue.

The current era(CE) or christian era(AD) is ascribed to the birth of Jesus Christ, who is supposedly born on December 25,( CE - 6 days), and whose historicity is also questioned. It is simply enough that an era of reckoning started both in 0 CE, and Kali 0 ( 3102 BCE) and both the eras are used even today.

At this point we would do well to ignore, wholesale, the views of orientalist and start afresh.

Ravi Chaudhary
 
Last edited:
Chaudhary Sahib,

I have checked from Kalhan's Rajtarangini Skt. text with Hindi translation edition published by Chokambha Publishers recently and found the same chronology as posted by you in your earlier post. Moreover, it is a very late composition in verse form though claimed as based on old Indian literary sources.

Therefore, it is agreed that not much reliance can be placed on Kalhan's version as regards Maurya History is concerned. For example, regarding Ashok and Jaluka, Kalhan's narration does not corroborate either the Puranas or Buddhist/Jain chronicles or the inscriptional evidence.

Thanks and regards
 
Last edited:
Back
Top