ravichaudhary
New member
Good topic and good discussion between Ravi and Dr Rajpal Singh. Does anybody know the prakrit for Chandra Gupta, which is what most people used that time. It is the Greek form (Sandakottus or Sandrakottus) of his prakrit name which we read in history books. This is my view.
Naveen
This is not a debate.
It is simply an attempt to get people to take a critical look at historical matters and to question what accounts were written in the past.
One major weakness of Indian history is the maxim that has been ingrained in the Indian psyche- That “ Indians have no sense of history”.
Somehow this does not make all the sense that it is supposed to.
The attempts at writing Indian history by western historians( and their indian students) has meant the ignoring of Indian history written by Indians, and more importantly ignoring the indigenous chronology and timelines.
The entire foundatation and chronology of Indian History is based on the dates of shri Maurya. Historians borrow freely from Puranic time lines, when it suits them, but ignore the data when it does not.
This has the effect that the period between the Harappa civilization circa 2500 BCE and the Maurya period( Conventional dating 324 BCE) being a total blank.
Something that is quite impossible.
If one is to start afresh, taking into account the vast amount of historical data at our disposal today, we would write a very different account of the indian subcontinent today, than what was written by some untrained colonial would be historians.
A key to the western accounts is the synchronization of the dates of Mr. Maurya with the invasion of Alexander.
Alexander’s supposed invasion does not find any reference in Indian accounts, Mr. Maurya is not mentioned in Greek accounts, and nor for that matter is Ashoka.
The omission of the latter is most troubling.
Here is an all powerful Emperor,governing a vast empire from Assam to South India to central Asia, who is supposed to have interacted with Greek kings, and sent embassies to them, spreading the Buddhist religion. Surely he cannot escape detailed accounts about him in the Greek Chronicles.( unless all the accounts were burnt, when the Library of Alexandria burnt down)
If accounts of Megastenes Indika survive , one would expect some notice of Ashoka in the extensive Greek accounts.
Yet we find absolutely no reference to him in the Greek accounts, which accounts our native Indian historians accept as the gospel truth.
This is odd, to say the least.
The parallel to those seeking to write an account of the History is, that Jat history is notable for the absence of accounts of the Jats.
To seek the history of our people, means peeling away the veils that cover it.
We can start by dating the Maurya family correctly.
Last edited: