Khap Panchayat and Indian Judicial System

Best post!!!

If this post represents the words/thoughts/mentality/attitude/culture of a khap panchayat, if this is how a spokesperson of a Khap panchayat behaves, then this is the most convincing post AGAINST the Khaps.
You know what is the building block of panchayats are
1. Social Responsibility
2. Harmony
3. Bhai Chara

Lekin nangad(Nude) samaj cant understand that. And Killing killing kya laga rakhi hai. Haan agar panchayat Killing order de deti hai toh kya ho gaya. Ache kaam karne walo ko toh nahi de rahee?
toh Afjal ko Nobel Award dila do shanti ka. Woh bombay wala bhai court mein maje le raha hai. Hum bewkoofon ki tarah news padh rahe hai. and asking for Humanity.

In sab neh toh nangad badha diye samaj mein. Aur yeh sab hamako hi tang karenge.

Aur yeh eve teasing,rape, frauds increasing day by day. why we know our judicial system. and saath dene ke liye hum jaise hai. Kyon unko apne saath bitha lo. Ghar par invite karo Rapist ko?

Aur agar koi puche toh rapist ne kya jurm kar diya. Natural hai. where is the nature law ki both of the partner should be agree.

All these laws developed from this Panchayat sytem. Ab nangad banana hai toh mast hai. Sab panchayat band karwa dena. Aur Why family matters should be solved with in family inko bhi court me le jana.
 
Last edited:
Khap panchayats are not same as panchayats. Villege panchayats are part of Govt and Khap panchayats are not.
Khap panchayats are just social organization based on Gott and casts.

I very well know this Sir. I just put out a thought on the involvement of women in panchayats and not Khap Panchayats(Plz go through my post again. 2 hi line h jyada nahi h, time nahi lagega ek bar fir najar marne me). Aur Khap panchayat me aurton ko saamil karne ki himmat nahi h in logo me. Ye to panchayat me hi shamil nahi karte.. Koi aurat sarpanch ban ja se to 95% cases me uska gharaala sare decision leve h. Wa to niri sign/gutha tekan tai ho se.
Je khap panchayat me aa gi to inki Chaudher pe aa banegi, ar ya baat sahen koni hove inpe.
Aur ye Khap panchayat kuch na karti samaj ne aage lyaan tai. Nire ghar paaden tai rah rhi se. YE khaap panchayat Bode aadmi pe e sher hoya kare. Kise thade ken aankh tha ke nahi dekh sakti.Aadmi maaren ka haq kise ne nahi h. I agree Gotr-vivah galat h, par uski saja Marna nahi h.

With due respect to you maine sirf Anil ki baat ka jwab diya tha, jo usne kaha tha ki MORE WOMEN PARTICIPATION chaiye!

PS :No offence to anyone.

Regards
Deepak
 
Last edited:
Sir ji
Isme panchayat kahan se aa gayee?

Bhai Rakesh, That's why I have put this link. Such decisions are personal ones.

jitender hooda bhai aagar is manaraam ki jagah aapa hote to kya karte???? is dipak ne gunthi pahrate k ?

Bhai Rakke, could you please tell me who is the culprit in that affair if that was there?
Only BOY?
Only Girl?
BOTH? (If BOTH then werent the girl's parents responsible somewhere for her upbringing?)

Yes, I may have supported the same in case of RAPE. But not in this case where both are involved with some indirect share of the families.
 
More bad press...

Sensationalization continues. There are 4 articles related to Khaps today on TOI's website. While I have no sympathy for the functioning of Khaps, I hate the way media is making a mockery of the issue by writing whatever crap they can imagine.

This was the worst one.
http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/...lls-for-wayward-girls/articleshow/4984365.cms

ROHTAK: Less than 100 km from Delhi, smooth roads take you to Sanghi, the village where Haryana chief minister Bhupinder Singh Hooda was born. There

Young girls are generally at the receiving end of khap 'justice'. (TOI Photo)​
are pucca houses, cobbled streets, well-fed cattle, neat schools and sprawling green fields. It’s easy to be impressed by the colleges and professional institutes that dot the area.

But Sanghi, like most villages in this prosperous belt, has dark secrets to keep. Here, rape is casual, murder-by-pesticide of teenage daughters acceptable and it is routine to dispose of their bodies by burning them in cattle-carts. Here, young women are routinely threatened, abused and killed. Standard khap operating procedure?

In Sanghi, flush with development, khap rule has been the norm. The village women want the status quo to be maintained, uncertain of a life without khap decrees. “With mobile phones and television, milna-julna (interaction between the sexes) is too much. What can parents do except kill a daughter who disobeys?” says a local teacher defensively.

Girls who survive their mother’s womb are brought up as daughters of the village. Not just Sanghi’s daughters, but of 12 neighbouring villages, says a khap member. All 12 villages form the Khidwali Bara khap, a Jat territorial unit. It decrees that boys and girls within these 12 villages cannot marry. Interestingly, the entire onus of ‘siblinghood’ rests on the girl. She is the keeper of village honour. Exceptions may be made for a boy, if the khap decides, but a girl is never allowed to bend the rules. “If a girl married in her community’s villages, she will be in purdah in her own house. How can we allow that?” asks middle-aged Bedo.

The 10 to 15 men who rule a khap derive their power from being fatwa-issuing ‘samajik karyakarta’ (social workers). They settle disputes out of court, play matchmaker and assert their control by frowning on relationships between girls and boys.

In keeping with khap rules, older villagers do their best to keep the sexes apart. Last year, the senior secondary government school was forced to become single-sex with girls attending in the morning and boys in the afternoon. But such measures have limited impact, say villagers. “Yeh mobile sabko bigaad rahein hain,” says Bedo. “Kabhi kuan pe milenge, khet mein, kabhi ghar mein (The cellphone is corrupting the young who keep looking for ways to meet),” complains Ompati, a 50-plus housewife.

Intimacy is not a khap-level issue. Relationships are kosher so long as they’re casual flings, but dreams of marriage can spell death for the girl.

Vidya, who teaches at a government school in Sanghi, says she has had students who died in mysterious circumstances. “We are only told so-and-so is dead,” she says. The physical trainer in her school adds, “Kaaran koi nai batata (No one gives reasons).” On average, 10 to 12 healthy girls die every year, locals reckon, but there are no reliable figures.

Generally, it’s the parents or father-brother duos who kill ‘wayward’ girls. A sympathetic mother may plead with a daughter to take the goli herself. A protesting daughter may be force-fed a pesticide pill, the preferred mode. The other route is death by hanging, all the better to ‘show’ it as suicide. No police, no complaint, no records. “Yahan izzatdar woh hain jo ladki ko marte hain (Those who kill their girls are respected here),” says another teacher.

If a couple runs away, the women in their families run the risk of being raped, gang-raped, and boycotted. At times, khaps also ‘fine’ the families lakhs of rupees. For the locals, that is par for the course. “What else can be done?” asks an old woman.

Fearing their daughters would go astray, many parents marry them off early. In the government senior secondary school, two Class IX students just got married, some others are engaged. The married ones stay with their parents and aren’t allowed to speak to their husbands, also at school in other villages. “His name is Sonu and he’s in plus 2,” says Poonam of the youth she married in July. They hope to meet during vacations.

For their part, the “keepers of honour” have unquestioning faith in the khap. The only dirty word for the women here is ‘adhikar’. “Adhikar ke upeksha se ghar toot te hain (Asking for rights leads to broken homes),” says schoolteacher Kanta. But there is change, she insists. Her family can at last visit her. That’s adhikar enough for her.
In the last 10 years, the khap’s influence as the moral police has only grown. But Sanghi sleeps easy. Even when its daughters are being put to sleep.
*************

The other links:
http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/...choose-their-partners/articleshow/4984378.cms
http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/...-just-50km-from-Delhi/articleshow/4984351.cms
http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/...yats-seek-legal-claws/articleshow/4984423.cms
 
I put a comment (reproduced below) addressed to the journalist on the above link, criticising her piece. While there are 52 comments on the link associated with Tikait, many of them highly critical of Tikait (rightly so in my opinion), my comment has not been published yet. Let's see how much TOI believes in freedom of speech and expression. This was my letter:

Dear Ms Sengupta,

Do you call this journalism? I think you may as well have published the story in "Rochak Kahaniyan". From what you have written, it is apparent that rape and murders are "casual" and "routine" (The quoted words used by you in the same context) in the Jat belt. Indluging in rape and murder seems to be the favorite hobby of these villagers. Did you actually visit the village? Guess when they can't spare their own women, an outsider like you (an emanicipated, "modern" woman) would have been just too likely to get raped/murdered. No? I think you should write (sorry, invent!) these stories from the confines of your comfortable office. Since what you have to write is already pretty much pre-decided, why bother with the risk of visiting? You can get the customary photo from the archives.

While there is no honour in killing (and there is no denying that there have been honour killings), the reality is far from what you are trying to present here. So many cases of rapes, murders, hangings, pesticide pills; and you couldn't mention ONE SPECIFIC CASE? Rather than the "routine" death of the "10-12" females, what seems more mysterious to me is their very existence- if they existed in real, I wonder how a talented journalist like you couldn't delve deeper into ONE SPECIFIC CASE?

People like you, who want to sensationalize everything without understanding anything, are a part of the problem. No social evil (and honour killings for whatever reason are a social evil) has ever been rooted out by painting a negative picture of the people who believe in it. In your case, you don't even understand the difference between social custom and social evil. When you are befuddled by the "complicated logic" (Quoting your friend Divya A from a piece she has done on Dharana) of a social custom, you call it social evil. You effortlessly switch from one to the other using your vivid imagination to fill in the huge gaps of logic. Shame on you and your colleagues who are sensationalizing a sensitive topic to win your own little rat races.

With warm regards,
Kapil Dalal
 
Sensationalization continues. There are 4 articles related to Khaps today on TOI's website. While I have no sympathy for the functioning of Khaps, I hate the way media is making a mockery of the issue by writing whatever crap they can imagine.

This was the worst one.
http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/...lls-for-wayward-girls/articleshow/4984365.cms

These articles were crap at its best. reporter had no clue what (s)he is talking about. :(
Here at Jatland, some members are arguing about the role of panchayats in honor killing, TOI has gone one step ahead: Women are ordered to be gang raped !! :mad:
Worst thing is: they are highlighting the JAT. :mad:

after reading the full report, i was literally shocked. Anyone who is not from NCR region will precept that Haryana/UP/NCR are worse than Afghanistan!!

This pathetic report claim that women are treated badly, like a live-stock in JAt belt. True, there are girl-foetcide and some prejudices against girl (and it is not just haryana or up, it is through out the country) BUT to this extent :(
i wonder if reporter bothered to see how many graduates girl are there even in villages!!

No wonder, even some Jatland memebrs are clueless about the role/decisions of panchayats and the ground realities. Now i know, for sure, why some members are so opposed to panchayats.
 
Sensationalization continues. There are 4 articles related to Khaps today on TOI's website. While I have no sympathy for the functioning of Khaps, I hate the way media is making a mockery of the issue by writing whatever crap they can imagine.
I have similar thoughts about this smear job on khaps done by ToI. What these jokers have done is, pre-judged that khaps are 'evil', 'medieval' and 'backward' and proceeded to do a write up with this prejudiced view. If one uses their clever style of argument and reasoning even our judicial system would come out as outdated, evil and archaic but this kind of vitriol is reserved for us, 'medieval fools'. It is infuriating and blood boils reading this cr*p.

Kapil, rarely does ToI publishes letters critical of itself, so bro, don't your hold your breath on this one. Another thing, freedom of speech and expression is what we, backward fools, have to give to our 'modern' messiahs and it is these ToI buggers who'll trample freedom of speech and expression at the first chance they get (moderate comments which are not to their liking or not publish letters which go against their articles). Is their some sort of watchdog/ombudsman for these media clowns where one can complain? No point in writing to these pathetic fools. There has to be some sort of neutrality/objectivity which is obvoiusly not ToI's strong suit when they paint khaps as some sort of mafia who orders rapes/executions/abductions with out giving any evidence.
 
No wonder, even some Jatland memebrs are clueless about the role/decisions of panchayats and the ground realities. Now i know, for sure, why some members are so opposed to panchayats.

Sunil, while I agree that these articles are crap, it would be wrong to assume that members speaking against the role/decisions of panchayats are unaware of the ground realities or are talking crap themselves. Media is obviously sensationalizing the issue and printing rubbish. But it is a fact that honour killings have taken place. What justifies that?

It is debatable what role Khaps have played in the same, but there is no denying that they have a role to play given the authority they command/exercise on social issues. How can they turn a blind eye when someone is dishing out his justice in their jurisdiction? They may not have ordered the killings but they have been passive supporters of the same. Their case on social customs would have been much stronger had they condemned the killings and taken action against the killers.
 
But Sanghi, like most villages in this prosperous belt, has dark secrets to keep. Here, rape is casual, murder-by-pesticide of teenage daughters acceptable and it is routine to dispose of their bodies by burning them in cattle-carts. Here, young women are routinely threatened, abused and killed. Standard khap operating procedure?
Nandita Sengupta - who wrote this - looks like a Barkha Dutt wannabe. Complete with shrillness, shrieks, in-objectivity, generalizations, lazy fact-less writing. Indian journalism has such a long way to go - the sad part is they have not even started on that path.
Here is some dirt on her courtesy google - I am sure you can find more.
http://sporadicblogger.wordpress.com/2007/07/27/ht-platform-nandita-sengupta/

“With mobile phones and television, milna-julna (interaction between the sexes) is too much. What can parents do except kill a daughter who disobeys?” says a local teacher defensively.

Non sequitur in a darkly comical way.
 
Nandita Sengupta - who wrote this - looks like a Barkha Dutt wannabe. Complete with shrillness, shrieks, in-objectivity, generalizations, lazy fact-less writing. Indian journalism has such a long way to go - the sad part is they have not even started on that path.
Here is some dirt on her courtesy google - I am sure you can find more.
http://sporadicblogger.wordpress.com/2007/07/27/ht-platform-nandita-sengupta/



Non sequitur in a darkly comical way.

Bhai, yeh link to block ho gaya meri company ke server pe. Can you please copy paste the dirt?[FONT=Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif]
[/FONT]
 
At your service Sir! :)


Bhai, yeh link to block ho gaya meri company ke server pe. Can you please copy paste the dirt?


Posted by sporadicblogger in Life, Reviews/Rants, contemporary.
trackback
Sex Education begins at home, she says. The lady feels that sex education in schools should be ‘put on hold for the moment’
Sample her gems-
‘In December 2004, two teenagers showed us why introducing sex education in Indian schools is asking for trouble’. She was, ofcourse, referring to the infamous MMS case. Note the keywords: teenagers, INDIAN SCHOOLS, trouble…
She follows that up by contradicting herself by stating in the last sentence of the rubbish piece that- ‘In school, ’sex education’ with all its overwhelming relevance (????!!!) is best left alone. …The same way that teaching youngsters about religion does not lead to fundamentalism, telling them about sex does not lead to irresponsible behaviour(my italics).’
The woman is daft. I wonder how she got herself published in the edit page. She tries to make a case but her ‘arguments’ are pathetic at best. At one point she attempts to be a great debater and says that ‘Sadly, the aguments for sex education (her italics) are even more hackneyed than those against it-the opponents at least known for thei dogmatic approach’. Er, yeah. Right. Ofcourse, she doesn’t go on to show HOW the arguments are ’sadly’ more hackneyed. She tries, though. Here, THIS is why she believes it is more ‘hackneyed’-
‘The ‘progressive’ (she puts the word within ‘ ‘) reasoning behind talking about sex is to make minors aware of AIDS so that they can be cautious about their sexual behaviour. It is an unfortunate generation for which sex and talking about sex will be associated with a disease and its entailing burden’.
This sentence astounded me. I mean, what does the idiot want? The world to bury its head under the sand and look the other way? Because, well,er,*cough cough*, AIDS is a burgeoning threat in todays world!! Lets not talk about safe sex because the young shouldn’t forever associate it with yucky disease...
Stupid woman.
Sex education in schools is a must. Most parents feel uncomfortable discussion sex and sexuality with their children. There are children as old as 14-15 (and this is only in my experience…I’m sure the figures an be more horrifying) who do not know what a condom is, who do not know how one becomes pregnant, and that oral sex can transmit the virus.
The point is children WILL find out about dirty dirty sex. (They aren’t blind, and we must credit them with the bare minimum of intelligence. ) Shouldn’t they then be given the correct information about it?
This strange author(her, not me) can choose to live in her own blessed world, but the point is, yes, it would be GREAT if sex education started at home, but in all likelihood, this won’t happen soon. And EVEN if it did, it needs to be supplemented at school. After all, just because they are Parents, it does not mean they have all the information.
 
all this crap is not only propogate through media but also through satellite channels. there is one serial called ' naa aana is des laado' it shows jats always pressurise their bahus and daughters and owmen in thier houses always living under threat and injustice.

mere khyal se ladkiyan ki sabs ejyaada durgatee toh rajput karte hain.. aise case sabse jyaada rajasthan main milenge rajput communities main jahan ladki ko pada hote hi jeher mila doodh de dete the..

I think female ka status itna kharab nahe ehai jaaton main jitna yeh media show karta hai..
 
It is just a media crap. Media is presenting khap panchayat like Taliban of India. In TOI article reporter is using word Honor Killing....how a killing can be honor? It's rubbish. When media will realize their social responsibility?
 
Not even an iota of truth in the news!!!!!

The reports in the news are definitely wrong. Women are very well respected in our community.I have not heard of any girl being killed by poisoning or any other way. They may die of sudden stomach aches, mysterious fevers that result in a quick death and a quicker funeral.
Even if girl/couple are being killed, all this is minor collateral damage in maintaining our superior gene pool and culture.Do Khaps allow deviants to this? Only in exceptional cases like, when an unsuitable boy fails to get an equally unsuitable bride within the community, then that boy is ok to buy a bride for himself from nepal/bihar etc etc.
 
Last edited:
The reports in the news are definitely wrong. Women are very well respected in our community.I have not heard of any girl being killed by poisoning or any other way. They may die of sudden stomach aches, mysterious fevers that result in a quick death and a quicker funeral.
Even if girl/couple are being killed, all this is minor collateral damage in maintaining our superior gene pool and culture.Do Khaps allow deviants to this? Only in exceptional cases like, when an unsuitable boy fails to get an equally unsuitable bride within the community, then that boy is ok to buy a bride for himself from nepal/bihar etc etc.

Are you saying article is correct or kya aap aur kuch kah rahe haeen?:confused:
 
Sunil, while I agree that these articles are crap, it would be wrong to assume that members speaking against the role/decisions of panchayats are unaware of the ground realities or are talking crap themselves. Media is obviously sensationalizing the issue and printing rubbish.

Agreed. i am not a blind supporter of these Khaps either. After reading few posts in this thread, i got the impression that some members believe that panchayats are a rotten system meant only for ordering honor killing (directly or indirectly) nothing else; no other credentials,!! But truth is panchayats do play constructive roles in many issues (petty fights to monetary issues to huge land disputes). Nobody takes note of that. We should give them their due credit.
'What else panchayats can/should do' is already discussed in thread and i agree with that. Khap panchayats should evolve with time BUT then this responsibilty lies on the youth, they should take some initiative.. i am sure Panchayat will (atleast) listen to their ideas.


But it is a fact that honour killings have taken place. What justifies that?
It is debatable what role Khaps have played in the same, but there is no denying that they have a role to play given the authority they command/exercise on social issues. How can they turn a blind eye when someone is dishing out his justice in their jurisdiction? They may not have ordered the killings but they have been passive supporters of the same. Their case on social customs would have been much stronger had they condemned the killings and taken action against the killers.

Partly agree. Let us not forget, there are many (i would say majority of) incidents where honor killing takes place without anybody else (other than the family) knowing it.. Padosiyon ko bhi agle din pata chalta hai. in many cases even the exact reason of the killing remains a mystery. :)

Do you really think, its only the fear of Panchayats that responsible for honor killing??
i don't think so... it is generally parents and/or sibling who do it for their so called 'honor' in society!! If panchayats are the culprit of not condemning these killings so is every other single fabric of society.. Friends, relatives... no??

Believe it or not, Panchayats or Khap panchayats are mostly involved in issues that causes friction between two large set of ppl (pana, villages, clan etc.). Again the whole question is, should we cease our tradition of not marrying into 'bhaai-chara' and all?? if one think it should continue, then there is no other way but the social-boycott of such couples!!

they have been passive supporters of the same (honor killing).


The reasons for such killings is either incestuous or same village affair. period.
Can panchayats say it is okey to be in such relationships?? will u say so??

Kapil, what will u suggest to stop honor killing??

Should panchayats do the counselling of all adolescent in villages??

should they start asking the postmortem reports of any adolescent/adult died in village to ascertain if this was a honor killing? :)

Again don't take me wrong, m not a supporter of honor killing but to put blame on panchayat is wrong. Role of panchayat is also limited.

If u ask me: parents are the sole culprit here, they are responsible for their son/daughter' wrong doings, and then they kill 'them' to keep their 'honor' intact.

Another thing: Lets us assume that some how panchayats start 'actively' condemning the 'honor killing. Will it stop??
I don't think it will stop. i even doubt if the number will come down just because panchayats say it is wrong.
There are death penalty and other punishments for murder, rap etc in Indian penal code, but still these things are happening. (i know lame excuse but Truth is lame at times).

More than panchayats it is the individuals who are responsible for such acts, they need to 'grow up' and take care of their wards!!
 
Even CM son said something like this: ki these honor killings were private local matter.
Ho rahe hongi aise ghatnayeen aur yeh panchayat waale chupa rahe haeen honge.
But this writer is a bengali and she is exaggerating and bengali do not like jats and that is what I have heard. so we must not overlook the ethnicity of the writer in question. let us do a write up on kolkatta black hole or find something of that sort in bengali psyche.
Sen=bengali surname
ADD gupta a north Indian Baniya to Sen and it becomes = Sengupta!
Thus Sengupta=Bengali Baniya!
 
Even CM son said something like this: ki these honor killings were private local matter.
Ho rahe hongi aise ghatnayeen aur yeh panchayat waale chupa rahe haeen honge.
But this writer is a bengali and she is exaggerating and bengali do not like jats and that is what I have heard. so we must not overlook the ethnicity of the writer in question. let us do a write up on kolkatta black hole or find something of that sort in bengali psyche.
Sen=bengali surname
ADD gupta a north Indian Baniya to Sen and it becomes = Sengupta!
Thus Sengupta=Bengali Baniya!

Mr. Kharab

I hope I do not offend you.


Your well intentioned but hot headed response , is what we wish to avoid.

We wish to engage with the Senguptas and Neha Dixits of the world, and expose them, make them accountable for what they write.

We cannot do that by joining them in mud slinging.

If you wish to help, help organize responses, using facts and logic.

We wish to organize media committees, organize our well wishers in the media. we have plenty of Jats in th media. it is time we encourage them to come forward under one banner.

No one will support killing. There is No honour in it.

We have to find a way that satisfies the community tradition, and also lets the tradition adapt to changing times.

I do not have any obvious solutions, no magic bullets.

We all have to contribute, men , women, old and young.

Take care


Ravi Chaudhary
 
It is debatable what role Khaps have played in the same, but there is no denying that they have a role to play given the authority they command/exercise on social issues. How can they turn a blind eye when someone is dishing out his justice in their jurisdiction? They may not have ordered the killings but they have been passive supporters of the same. Their case on social customs would have been much stronger had they condemned the killings and taken action against the killers.

So we all are, isnt?

I wish to inform you that
Narender Kharb, Retd Chief Justice Tewatia Ji, SS Rana, Mehar Singh Dahiya, Ravi Ji (By his paper), Comandt Hawa Singh Sangwan Ji, Bharti Sindhu etc. have made an effort to bridge the gap between Media, Khaps and Intellects on 30th August at SurajMal Institute delhi. I will only say at the moment that it was a great initiative altogether.

It is true that most of the reports in media are 'invented' as per Kapil Dalal. But we can counter them by providing logical details. I dont think anybody is stopping us to get the real details of Khaps history and functioning posted in newspapers. Like in yesterdays TOI they have mentioned these Khaps were started in 14th century. We can get a paper ready with Khaps history, start, their functioning, their acheivements, resist they provided to mugals and british, involvement of ladies they had (36 thousand ladies were present in a panchayat during HarshVardhna's time - Ravi ji may provide full details), when ladies participation declined (due to the threat to their asmita from moguls), Present scenerio and points of revival.

Present day also 80% of the panchayats have not been reported in media and that is the reason that they are painted with wrong colors. If all of the cases are under media coverage the modern society will also praise their efforts. This can be acheived if we make Khaps/villagers/media close to each other. Here I think we people can play an important role.

I willnot deny that there are lots and lots of improvement scope there but overall they are doing a lot good works even today. Will compile and post an answer to Kapil and Anju's query - what good they are doing or have done recently, soon.
 
Last edited:
Dear fellow members,
It was Koyal,my 11 yr old daughter, who announced yesterday morning: Aaj to Khaps ke baare mein bahut aaya hua hai newspaper mein!
She was referring to the TOI links Kapil has given. She did not give me the newspaper till she read all that was written about Jats and Khaps on Page 1, 11 and the complete page 15.Seems TOI had dedicated yesterday's edition to Jats.
At the end she just said: Why should these people interfere with our customs and traditions?(probably because she is aware of the Gotra system which Bengalis and Mallus fail to understand.)

Coming to the article. I knew it was coming since the day I attended the Seminar organised By Col MS Dahiya(retd), at Maharaja Surajmal Institute, Janakpuri,ND on 30Aug'09.
One of the journalists' present there had told that TOI is soon coming out with a Big Story on Khaps.
What is driving their so much interest in this, I fail to understand.:confused:

Like everyone here, I too was curious about these Khaps and went to attend the Khap Panchayat at Jhajjar on 2 Aug while the Dharana Issue was at its peak( it was solved in the next Sarv Khap Panchayat on 9 Aug).
Though there was no other woman present except for one covering the event, I was never made to feel out of place.
The Khap Heads command respect because of their wise words and the experience they carry which is reflected in their speech.
Then suddenly I too was invited to speak. Do you not see the change taking place in Khaps? Else why would they want to hear the views of a woman?
My experience was overall very good.

And between all this discussion on serious issue an appeal was made to all to not go without having food! Simple food- roti-sabji,dal-chawal,raita and halwa.The warmth with which it was served would cool down tempers of anyone.
It is with this level head that decisions are taken and that too after hearing the views of all. Not in haste to just finish off the burden of cases but also not taking years as it often happens in the courts.
At least I am not against the Khaps.

These days there are a lot of Lok Adalats being conducted by the Courts. The government is encouraging these.
Recently, the Delhi Legal Services and Delhi Police has come up with lots of ads on Radio about Mediation Centres where family disputes are solved/both parties counselled/ court procedures avoided to solve matters peacefully and without burdening the courts.
Have the Khaps not been doing the same work since times immemorial?

There were various examples given during the Seminar at Surajmal Ins. by representatives of some Khaps where a number of cases were solved. One where as many as 20-25 murders had taken place between families and Khaps had succeeded in bringing peace. I think it was Jharonth.(Mr Narender Kharb and Mr Jitender Hooda would be able to give the exact details.)

Probably the Khaps are not media-savvy and do not know Image-Building concepts. I had requested them to invite the media whenever they were solving some matters so that they do not come to light only when some odd couple is murdered and the Khaps projected as Taliban issuing Fatwas.

Life is different in rural areas.All urban thoughts and systems should not be forced on them. Not that people are not ready for change.But it should suit them.
The younger generation with exposure to the outside world should give them ideas to keep pace with changes happening outside.
It is heartening to see people like Kapil,Sid,Anjoo,Meera,Sunil,Anil and many others here concerned about such issues pertaining to our community and society as whole.

regards,
bharti.
 
Back
Top