Naxalism

Status
Not open for further replies.
Rupi Bhai I am just trying to connect the dots from what you have to say.

Do you even know what is hawala?

Let me explain it briefly. People make dirty money in India and then transfer it to a foreign country using illegitimate means. There the money is converted most probably in US dollars and is returned to its owners in India for some goods or services sold. These goods or services may have never been provided in the first place. When the money makes its way back to India, it is trax-free as income from foreign trade is not taxed by the government.

Now let me give you a few facts. Hawala has lost its shine. As Indian markets have opened up, hawala operators have nearly been wiped out as there are several legitimate means to transfer money out of India, right under the government's nose. Hawala money ussually used to be politicians' dirty money that was recycled into clean money by their associates through hawala. The most famous example is the Bofors case of the 80s.

Rupi yaar! where do you see a connection between Hawala and Naxalism. These Naxals are supposed to be victims of the system. How is an average businessman who was cleaning his dirty money responsible for the Naxalites' suffering. What do I need to say to put it in your mind that Naxalism is a result of the failure of the government? So why are you holding the corporations responsible for it.

Do you really think that the Ambanis, Krishnamurthy, Tatas Birlas and numerous other entreprenuers are exploiting people who become Naxals? Give me one example of an ex-employee of a corporation who quiot because he or she was exploited and become a Naxal.

I really do not see any connection between your arguments.

Privatization has created hundreds of thousands of opportunities. I can bet on it that majority of particiapants on jatland.com alone have some jobn created by the "new economy." If things keep going the way they are going and government get's out of our lives completely, things will improve for an average farmer too. Privatization will bring relief to our rural parts. Not Naxalism.
 
post ney ek bey dubara paadh

dahiyarules said:
Rupi Bhai I am just trying to connect the dots from what you have to say.

Do you even know what is hawala?

thanx for telling me,,, bhai



Rupi yaar! where do you see a connection between Hawala and Naxalism.

bhai ,,, i dint make any connection between hawala nd naxalism,,,,,u were saying peole r rich bcoz they work hard,, dats y i wrote dat all rich dont work hard,,,,,, sm of them r into hawala........even sm politician r doin hawala jobs...........
Do you really think that the Ambanis, Krishnamurthy, Tatas Birlas and numerous other entreprenuers are exploiting people who become Naxals?

in my post i dint mention ambanis ,sharukh aur tata.........i was talkin `bout rich n loaded people like landords,,higher class who exploit the poor....

I really do not see any connection between your arguments.

indeed,, ur correct bro,,,,,my arguments have no such connection bcoz as such i dint try reflect any connection between hawala n naxals.....:)

bhai sumit,,,,,,my question to u....

Is protecting ones encroached rights not justifiable ??????? just imagine the pathetic state of the deprived section.....small land holders ,,peasants,, lower class workers etc..etc.......there is nobdy to settle down their problems,,,,,,,,no roads,,, no police stations no medical aid,,,and r totally
cut off from basic needs........and on top of dat they have lots of KHOON CHUSN AALEY.........................................:cool: :rolleyes: .............. no sense of security at all nd dats y they r compelled to pick GUNS,,eb nu bata ,,,arms thana galat baat sey key ???.........,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,Sumit bro ,,,, wear their boots for a while ,,,,,aur fer deekh BANDOOKH thana kiyna galat sey...........????..........

well if i were exploited this way i would`ve done d same...........:mad: :mad: ,,,,, wot bout u ????:confused:
 
Rups....chhorey tanne tai yo Atul Jhajhria ka eshtyle pakadd liya....kati point 2 point jawab de diya....bhaddak meetdi iski akk na?;)

well if i were exploited this way i would`ve done d same...........:mad: :mad: ,,,,, wot bout u ????:confused:[/QUOTE]
 
panward said:
In his article in Sunday's HT, Karan Thapar gives a glimpse of how immense the problem is:
http://www.hindustantimes.com/news/181_1675896,00300002.htm


Bhai tu yu phottu baddal de na tei hum behonss ho jyangge....mere yaar ke deedde se kadhh rhya sei........Not on yaar......yu tanne dhhundhhya kitt tein...........Jat isse tei na huya krein bhai. It really looks ugliest possible...isstein aachha tei koe gobbar karti mheinss chipka de merre yaar. Sorry to point out but this is not on.
 
bhai ,,, i dint make any connection between hawala nd naxalism,,,,,u were saying peole r rich bcoz they work hard,, dats y i wrote dat all rich dont work hard,,,,,, sm of them r into hawala........even sm politician r doin hawala jobs...........

Yaar Rupi! what do I need to tell you that Hawala is not a money making business enterprise. No one becomes rich by doing Hawala. The Hawal Industry is highly decentralized. There are no big fishes.

Rupi your ideas are very screwed up. You really need to look into your ideas all over again. I am sure that you have never studied Economics in your life. Thats is why you buy into all these conspiracy theories.

Look yaar! you really do not have to work hard to become rich. I work more hours than many millionaires, but I am still broke. You have to work smartly to become rich. Identify business opportunities and capitalize on them to make money.




Do you really think that the Ambanis, Krishnamurthy, Tatas Birlas and numerous other entreprenuers are exploiting people who become Naxals?

in my post i dint mention ambanis ,sharukh aur tata.........i was talkin `bout rich n loaded people like landords,,higher class who exploit the poor....


Rupi Yaar! times have changed. We do not live in an Agriculture focused economy anymore. Just yesterday I was listening to Senator Edward Kennedy on Larry King Live. He spoke on length about Indias growing importance in Global economy. This year alone we will graduate 350,000 engineers compared to 72,000 in the US, half of which are foreign students. IBM and other hi-technology companies are setting up reasearch and development centers in India.

Things have changed a lot. People need to move on. Agriculture is becoming more mechanized every year which means fewer hands are needed on the field. On the top of that, becuase of the Hindu common law, land is divided among several children in the household. Sometimes the land-holding is too small for one family to survive. But people are finding a solution to this problem. People are moving to Urban centers of India and looking for alternative jobs. My father did so. I am sure there are hundreds of Jatland.com mebers alone, who moved to the city or their parents did so. People won't be livcing at the mercy of the landlord for long. It is a free market out there. Once the business is gone, the Landlords will be gone too.


I really do not see any connection between your arguments.

indeed,, ur correct bro,,,,,my arguments have no such connection bcoz as such i dint try reflect any connection between hawala n naxals.....:)


You mentioned it clearly that people are getting richer doing hawala and the poor are gettng poorer. Read your own posts. Don't change your tone now. hehehe



bhai sumit,,,,,,my question to u....

Is protecting ones encroached rights not justifiable ??????? just imagine the pathetic state of the deprived section.....small land holders ,,peasants,, lower class workers etc..etc.......there is nobdy to settle down their problems,,,,,,,,no roads,,, no police stations no medical aid,,,and r totally
cut off from basic needs........and on top of dat they have lots of KHOON CHUSN AALEY.........................................:cool: :rolleyes: .............. no sense of security at all nd dats y they r compelled to pick GUNS,,eb nu bata ,,,arms thana galat baat sey key ???.........,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,Sumit bro ,,,, wear their boots for a while ,,,,,aur fer deekh BANDOOKH thana kiyna galat sey...........????..........

well if i were exploited this way i would`ve done d same...........:mad: :mad: ,,,,, wot bout u ????:confused:[/QUOTE]

Dekh Rupi Yaar! there are lot of oppressed people in the society. Violence never leads to fair results, as someone pays the price with their life which is too high of a price to be paid. There a lot of people dying in this crazy "people fighting people sitution."

On the top of it all these people are thugs. I want to tell you about a friend of mine. He is from karimnagar in Andhra. It is the hotbed of Naxalism. His father is a well respected trader in Karimnagar. he pays the Naxals lakhs of rupees every year. The money is not collected as tax money, but as "protection money." You have read about it here and there and seen it on TV. I am giving you a first hand account. When I asked him what does his family think about it. He says that that they do not mind it as long as long everyone in thier family is safe.

You are talking about no police and no medical aid for these people. But what about those who actually have police protection and medical aid, like my friends family. He actually owns a hospital in karimnagar. These naxals kill you if you seek protection from the police and blow up hospitals.

I fully support the Medha Pathkar and the "Narmada Bachao Andolan" guys. Arent those guys oppressed. But they are still in their senses. They are protesting peacefully, and they have won the sympathy of more people than the naxals have. People like me voluntarily contribute money to the "narmada Bachao fund." These guys could also have gone around with a gun and asking for "protection money."

Only those who know that their cause is fair and justified fight for their cause peacefully and keep patience. Because deep within their hearts they know that they are right, and truth always wins. It is the universal truth. This is one factor that sets us Indians apart from the rest of the world. Whether it was Gandhi or Medha Pathkar, people with a just cause find steength in their convictions rahtern than in guns.

Rupi let me tell you something about communists. They will go to any length to get what they went. You talk about the Chinese Cultural Revolution and the Bolshevik Revolution. Do you know how many people died in these massacres. They call them revolution, but they were actually blood baths. Millions were killed in these massacres. All those who had a problem with the communist ideology were shot and thrown in mass graves. Is this how lightly you take human life, that you will go to any length to praise the bloodiest human action in recent and past history.

The fact is that communism did not survive even a hundred years. What these naxals are fighting for is unrealistic. Even if they get what they want, we will be headed for further trouble not very long from now. There can never be equality in society. We all are different people with different capabilities. So how can we all be equal. If we all were equally gifted then we all would have discovered how to make an atom bomb and fly rockets to the moon. There will always be differences in the society. The smart ones will always live better than the least smart ones. If you force the smart ones and the least smart ones to similar standards this society will stop progressing. Probably you companys owner wont have founded your company. And you wont have been on this job. Mayb e if there were no job prospects you wont have studied and gone to college. Maybe you were still living in you ancestral home in the village. But hold on. Thats not the end of it. Maybe your parents would have killed you soon after you were born because you wont have been able to take care of them when you grew up snce there were no prospects. Do not tell me that deep within your heart even you ocnsider smarter than many other people. Is there s peon in your office? Lets practice some equality and pay you the same salary that your peon gets. Would you accept it? No. I am sure you wont. there you go. You know yourself that there cannot be equality in this society.

Having respect for others is something totally different. And by that I mean we must respect our differences and admire others special capabilities that we are not gifted with. And we must accept the same in return.
 
Posterboy...

Not for nothing, Dahiya Ji, I got the coveted award of the ugliest jatlander and you want me change that! Not done

Par ise change kar ke bhi ke hoga. Dusre photu to ees tai bi bhunde hai.

And, allow me to say -- with great pain too -- that you seem have taken a cue from a fellow jatlander -- He-Who-Shall-Not-Be Named -- and are doubting whether I am jat at all. I think i have to attend the coming Delhi Jat Meet and show some certificates to prove my identity.

Anyways, I will change the photu.

With regards from:
-Daksh

devdahiya said:
Bhai tu yu phottu baddal de na tei hum behonss ho jyangge....mere yaar ke deedde se kadhh rhya sei........Not on yaar......yu tanne dhhundhhya kitt tein...........Jat isse tei na huya krein bhai. It really looks ugliest possible...isstein aachha tei koe gobbar karti mheinss chipka de merre yaar. Sorry to point out but this is not on.
 
Coming to the topic proper: Naxalism thrives on political patrionage as both enjoy the fruits ie Naxalists and the White Kurta......Otherwise it can be wiped out in a week......?
 
Poster boy II..

....Ar Deedde kaadh nee raha tha, Dahiya ji, likad giye the . Photographer Mahila thee .

Ek ghatnaa yaad aagee. Ek baar ek ladka apni maa ke jaa kai bujhjhan lagya, ''Maa, Maa! Gaam main sab mujhe Ch**ya kahain''.
Maa bolli, ''Bette teri to sikal hi asi.''

Moral: Better or worse, this the only face I have got. I can change the photo but not the man in question.

I have got my looks from my father. He is a plastic surgeon -- Groucho Marx.

Post Scriptum: The post has nothing to do with Naxalism. Quotes have been altered slightly. Use objectionable words in the para one is regretted.
 
Last edited:
panward said:
Ek ghatnaa yaad aagee. Ek baar ek ladka apni maa ke jaa kai bujhjhan lagya, ''Maa, Maa! Gaam main sab mujhe Ch**ya kahain''.
Maa bolli, ''Bette teri to sikal hi asi.''

Moral: Better or worse, this the only face I have got. I can change the photo but not the man in question.

I have got my looks from my father. He is a plastic surgeon -- Groucho Marx.

Post Scriptum: The post has nothing to do with Naxalism. Quotes have been altered slightly. Use objectionable words in the para one is regretted.


Unwarranted word that dear.....You could have avoided that.Anyways FREEDOM........Carry on!
 
panward said:
Not for nothing, Dahiya Ji, I got the coveted award of the ugliest jatlander and you want me change that! Not done

Par ise change kar ke bhi ke hoga. Dusre photu to ees tai bi bhunde hai.

And, allow me to say -- with great pain too -- that you seem have taken a cue from a fellow jatlander -- He-Who-Shall-Not-Be Named -- and are doubting whether I am jat at all. I think i have to attend the coming Delhi Jat Meet and show some certificates to prove my identity.

Anyways, I will change the photu.

With regards from:
-Daksh


You are the best judge of your SELF and i am sure you know it well as to what you are doing with your self.Hope God knows too.Keep going.....!
 
panward said:
....Ar Deedde kaadh nee raha tha, Dahiya ji, likad giye the . Photographer Mahila thee .

Ek ghatnaa yaad aagee. Ek baar ek ladka apni maa ke jaa kai bujhjhan lagya, ''Maa, Maa! Gaam main sab mujhe Ch**ya kahain''.
Maa bolli, ''Bette teri to sikal hi asi.''

Moral: Better or worse, this the only face I have got. I can change the photo but not the man in question.

I have got my looks from my father. He is a plastic surgeon -- Groucho Marx.

Post Scriptum: The post has nothing to do with Naxalism. Quotes have been altered slightly. Use objectionable words in the para one is regretted.



Good example to prove your point...Bang on regardless!
 
Yaar Rupi! what do I need to tell you that Hawala is not a money making business enterprise. No one becomes rich by doing Hawala. The Hawal Industry is highly decentralized. There are no big fishes.
o bhai sumit,,,,, manney yu HAWALA sirf ek chottey sey example khaterr thaya thaa ,,,,,,iska itna bada kyu issue bana diya???:p anyways thanx a lot for telling me bout hawala...........:)

Rupi your ideas are very screwed up. You really need to look into your ideas all over again. I am sure that you have never studied Economics in your life. Thats is why you buy into all these conspiracy theories.

haan yaar ,, ur right,,,,,,i have never studied eco.....but we r here to discuss naxalism not economics,,,,,,, I`LL takey economics classes from u sm other day......:p





Rupi Yaar! times have changed. We do not live in an Agriculture focused economy anymore. Just yesterday I was listening to Senator Edward Kennedy on Larry King Live. He spoke on length about Indias growing importance in Global economy. This year alone we will graduate 350,000 engineers compared to 72,000 in the US, half of which are foreign students. IBM and other hi-technology companies are setting up reasearch and development centers in India.
bhai sumit ,,,,, these things look good only in black and white,,,,,,,,,yaar wot they have to do wid growing economy????:confused: ,,,,,,,,poor people`s economy is just confined to their bellies..... when a mother can sell her ward for just 50 bucks,,,, how significant is the coming of development for her......,,,,,,,,,,,,,, draw the curtain ,,, be practical,,,,,,, and lets see the real situation.......


I really do not see any connection between your arguments.

indeed,, ur correct bro,,,,,my arguments have no such connection bcoz as such i dint try reflect any connection between hawala n naxals.....:)


You mentioned it clearly that people are getting richer doing hawala and the poor are gettng poorer. Read your own posts. Don't change your tone now. hehehe
bro ,,, thanx for dat mild laughter,,,,,,,:p yaar i dint mention dat people r gettin richer doin hawala,.,,,,.:eek: bhai ,,,,,,, i wrote >>>>>>>>>>""" rich people r growing richer amassing huge benifits exploiting the masses in the remote ares.........................


Rupi let me tell you something about communists. They will go to any length to get what they went. You talk about the Chinese Cultural Revolution and the Bolshevik Revolution. Do you know how many people died in these massacres. They call them revolution, but they were actually blood baths. Millions were killed in these massacres. All those who had a problem with the communist ideology were shot and thrown in mass graves. Is this how lightly you take human life, that you will go to any length to praise the bloodiest human action in recent and past history.

bro,,,massacre breeds massacres ....throw sm light on the facts,,,,,we cant overlook the sufferings of naxals,,,,,wot went wrong with naxals dat they picked arms...,,..Naxals don't kill anybody working for the benefit of the villagers. The target of the Naxals are most of the time, security personel or someone who is in direct conflict with them ( like the killing in Begal of the communist leader). They as such don't target innocent civilians..... There are any number of incidents where terrorists have targetted innocent civilians like the numerous car bomb attacks but i doubt if you can recount even 2 or 3 such attacks by naxals where innocent civilians have been targeted,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, i give u a recent example,,,,,,, few days back ,,,, a train was stopped in U.P by naxals,,,,,, they just wanted to protest against killing of their mates.......no passenger was harmed at all........

The fact is that communism did not survive even a hundred years. What these naxals are fighting for is unrealistic. Even if they get what they want, we will be headed for further trouble not very long from now. There can never be equality in society. We all are different people with different capabilities. So how can we all be equal. If we all were equally gifted then we all would have discovered how to make an atom bomb and fly rockets to the moon. There will always be differences in the society. The smart ones will always live better than the least smart ones. If you force the smart ones and the least smart ones to similar standards this society will stop progressing. Probably you companys owner wont have founded your company. And you wont have been on this job. Mayb e if there were no job prospects you wont have studied and gone to college. Maybe you were still living in you ancestral home in the village. But hold on. Thats not the end of it. Maybe your parents would have killed you soon after you were born because you wont have been able to take care of them when you grew up snce there were no prospects. Do not tell me that deep within your heart even you ocnsider smarter than many other people. Is there s peon in your office? Lets practice some equality and pay you the same salary that your peon gets. Would you accept it? No. I am sure you wont. there you go. You know yourself that there cannot be equality in this society.

ur right dat we r all different people wid different capabilities............... but dude,,,,before dat we all r human beings.......and justice to all is indispensible,,,,.,, reins of capabilities r in ones hand...........its not an inborn stuff.......right to equality is the fundamental right of every citizen,,, whether he is a krorpati aur mazdoor..........this is the main cause for their struggle........................... aur bhai,,,,,, koi manas ,, peon laag rahya sey,,,, to apni capabilities key hisaab tey laag rahaya hai,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, lakin peon ney salary to milni chahiyey,,,,,,,yaar aarey too loog usney peon bhi laa rahey sein aur salary bhi na detey :rolleyes: :rolleyes: ,,,,,

The poor have a cause to fight in India.I think the problem of Naxalites when it started had a lot of public support at the grassroot level. People at those level rarely received any help from the government and immediately took to Naxalites as Desi Robinhoods..
I dont deny the goodness of Gandhi, but he wouldnt have succeeded if he didnt have followers who sacrificed their life and life style for the Cause.
How many would do that today?
bhai sumit ,,,,, u dint answer my question,,,,,,,,,, IF U WERE exploited this way,,,,,,,wot woud have u done?????
 
Last edited:
Here is a list of recent incidents of Maoist violence in which innocents were targetted:

http://news.indiamart.com/news-analysis/naxal-violence-25-ki-11836.html

http://www.ww4report.com/node/1863

http://www.ipcs.org/Terrorism.jsp

Want to look at more detailed data of Naxal violence during a given period:

http://www.asthabharati.org/Dia_Apr05/naxal_violence_data.htm

Want to look at official stats:

http://www.indiastat.com/india/ShowData.asp?secid=94&ptid=6&level=2



Now Rupi bhai tell me, what world do you live in. What really made you think that Naxals do not target the innocent. You did not even answer to my point where I told you about how my friends dad gives "protection money" to Naxals in Andhra. He is a trader and his family pretty much supplies for all the needed labor. He does not oppress "poor people." So, why him?

Violence always claims innocent lives. Even the precision guided bombs used by the US military cause innocent deaths. And we are talking communists who have no morals.

I have not even highlighted the scale of Communist violence in Nepal. You will wet your pants if you were to read about it.

If they do not commit violence against you, does not mean that they are nice people. They commit violence against someone somewhere who family loves them just like your family loves you.

What injustice are you talking about? Highlight more on that. Talking of Injustice, I think the people protesting the Narmada Dam are the ones who were denied justice. They were forced off their private properties wihtout any fair compensation. I think the victims of the 1984 Bhopal gas tragedy were denied justice as they still wait for their compensation money more than 2 decades on.

Injustice is everywhere. But justice is never denied by private citizens. Justice is denied by government courts. But these Naxals victimize private citizens for whatever their problems are. Isnt it the situation where these naxals are actually causing further injustice.

You can blabber-mouth all you want. If you really felt convicted enough about the naxal cause you wont be doing this job that you do, but instead you would have been out there fighting with them. You are doing this job because it fulfills your proirities more than your convictions do. Admit it.
 
men r born free but still they r in chains {naxals} !!!

dahiyarules said:
Here is a list of recent incidents of Maoist violence in which innocents were targetted:

http://news.indiamart.com/news-analysis/naxal-violence-25-ki-11836.html

http://www.ww4report.com/node/1863

http://www.ipcs.org/Terrorism.jsp

Want to look at more detailed data of Naxal violence during a given period:

http://www.asthabharati.org/Dia_Apr05/naxal_violence_data.htm

Want to look at official stats:

http://www.indiastat.com/india/ShowData.asp?secid=94&ptid=6&level=2

bhai sumit,,,,,,,thanx for the links,,,,,,but i would`ve appriciated ur point of view more if u had sent me the statistics of the killed maoists too............masscares are just the outcomes .........send me some links which highlight the sufferings of the deprived.........for instance ,,,,, sites which show ,,,unki zammen kaisi dabgayi gayii,,,,,,how their girls were raped,,,,,how they were humiliated ,,,,, etc etc etc.......... if u can:)


Now Rupi bhai tell me, what world do you live in. What really made you think that Naxals do not target the innocent. You did not even answer to my point where I told you about how my friends dad gives "protection money" to Naxals in Andhra. He is a trader and his family pretty much supplies for all the needed labor. He does not oppress "poor people." So, why him?
well sumit,,,freedom movement mein jo angreej maarey gayey woo bhi innocent theyy,,,,,but they were merely puppets in the hands of generals,,,,,,and the killing of thoose innocent angrejs was unavoidable...........to gain our precious INDEPENDENCE............ our dedicated freedom fighters like bhagat ,, rajguru ,,sukhdev,,bismill,,,who fought for the freedom,,,, were not wrong in their actions......................... I clearly remember the statement """"""""" bBISMIL KA SANDES HAI KE LAHORE JAANE WALI TRAIN KO HUM KAKROI KE PASS LUTENGEY AUR UNHI PAISOON SEY HATHIYAAR KHAREEDENGEY """"""""""":) ,,,, bhai sumit,,,,,,i agree dat ur frn`s dad is being somewot troubled but the money from him is not being used for the luxury of naxals,,,,,, but for their justified revolt........... ;)


I have not even highlighted the scale of Communist violence in Nepal. You will wet your pants if you were to read about it.

dude,,,,im glad to know dat there is still something left,,,, now which can wet my pants :p :pbhai ek aapni haryanvi mein kahaawat sey,,,,,,,,,,, PEHLAM GODDI AALEY BALAK KI SOOCH KARLEY ,,, PEAT AALEY KI FER SOCHIYEY................;) y ru takin nepal as an example,,,,,india mein hi bhaut kuch sey likhaan khaterr,,,,,,,,........:)


You can blabber-mouth all you want. If you really felt convicted enough about the naxal cause you wont be doing this job that you do, but instead you would have been out there fighting with them. You are doing this job because it fulfills your proirities more than your convictions do. Admit it.

thanx for the freedom of blabbering :p ,,,,,,,,, dude i was eagerly waiting for ur statement dat { bhai issa nd sey to tu aarey kyu bethya sey ,,,,, jaakey kuch kar naxliyaan khaterr,,,,,},,,
bro,,,,,,, u dont u join S.T.F n get hold of those naxals who trouble ur frn`s dad ............ aur bhai,,,,,, tu chahey maaney ya na manney,,,,,,,,,i really find their actions very well justified ,,,,,, but if u still have sm doubts regarding my feelings,,,,,,,, yu KHATKA daab key dekh ley

http://www.jatland.com/forums/showthread.php?t=12634



my dear bro,,,,,, im still waiting for my answer to the question which i had put up to u.............................
i have no intensions of hurting anybody,,, so just chiill pill like yuorself.....as u usual do. hehe
 
downtoearth said:
dahiyarules said:
Here is a list of recent incidents of Maoist violence in which innocents were targetted:

http://news.indiamart.com/news-analysis/naxal-violence-25-ki-11836.html

http://www.ww4report.com/node/1863

http://www.ipcs.org/Terrorism.jsp

Want to look at more detailed data of Naxal violence during a given period:

http://www.asthabharati.org/Dia_Apr05/naxal_violence_data.htm

Want to look at official stats:

http://www.indiastat.com/india/ShowData.asp?secid=94&ptid=6&level=2

bhai sumit,,,,,,,thanx for the links,,,,,,but i would`ve appriciated ur point of view more if u had sent me the statistics of the killed maoists too............masscares are just the outcomes .........send me some links which highlight the sufferings of the deprived.........for instance ,,,,, sites which show ,,,unki zammen kaisi dabgayi gayii,,,,,,how their girls were raped,,,,,how they were humiliated ,,,,, etc etc etc.......... if u can:)

Rupi Bhai! Now you are running around in circles with no objective in view. YOU ASKED ME FOR 2-3 INCIDENTS WHERE NAXALS KILLED CIVILIANS. I GAVE YOU MORE THAN THAT. NOW YOU ARE ASKING ME TO GIVE YOU THE DATA OF NAXALS KILLED. THAT IS UPTO YOU. I DO NOT GIVE A CRAP ABOUT DEAD COMMUNISTS. THE ONLY GOOD COMMUNIST IS A DEAD COMMUNIST. SO YOU CAN GO AND FIND IT OUT YOURSELF.

The issue was about dead civilians. I proved you wrong on that one. so stick to the main issue and admit that you have lost the moral argument.



Now Rupi bhai tell me, what world do you live in. What really made you think that Naxals do not target the innocent. You did not even answer to my point where I told you about how my friends dad gives "protection money" to Naxals in Andhra. He is a trader and his family pretty much supplies for all the needed labor. He does not oppress "poor people." So, why him?
well sumit,,,freedom movement mein jo angreej maarey gayey woo bhi innocent theyy,,,,,but they were merely puppets in the hands of generals,,,,,,and the killing of thoose innocent angrejs was unavoidable...........to gain our precious INDEPENDENCE............ our dedicated freedom fighters like bhagat ,, rajguru ,,sukhdev,,bismill,,,who fought for the freedom,,,, were not wrong in their actions......................... I clearly remember the statement """"""""" bBISMIL KA SANDES HAI KE LAHORE JAANE WALI TRAIN KO HUM KAKROI KE PASS LUTENGEY AUR UNHI PAISOON SEY HATHIYAAR KHAREEDENGEY """"""""""":) ,,,, bhai sumit,,,,,,i agree dat ur frn`s dad is being somewot troubled but the money from him is not being used for the luxury of naxals,,,,,, but for their justified revolt........... ;)

What precious independence are you talking about when humans are still fighting human post-indidependence. You yourself admit that there is so much injustice and inequality. I really do not think independence even means anything to us. The only people who benefitted were the ones who were transferred the reins to power in New Delhi.

If you think robbing people and using that money for something else is justified why dont you willingly give your monthly salary to the naxals.

There is a a difference between my friends dad giveing protection money to the naxals and Bismil and others robbing the Government treasury. My father works hard for his money. The government just steals money from other people. So basiclly Bismil Stole money from thugs, in the first place.



I have not even highlighted the scale of Communist violence in Nepal. You will wet your pants if you were to read about it.

dude,,,,im glad to know dat there is still something left,,,, now which can wet my pants :p :pbhai ek aapni haryanvi mein kahaawat sey,,,,,,,,,,, PEHLAM GODDI AALEY BALAK KI SOOCH KARLEY ,,, PEAT AALEY KI FER SOCHIYEY................;) y ru takin nepal as an example,,,,,india mein hi bhaut kuch sey likhaan khaterr,,,,,,,,........:)

Innocense does not change with political boundaries. The fact is communists kill innocent people here in India and elsewhere. You loose the moral argument again

You can blabber-mouth all you want. If you really felt convicted enough about the naxal cause you wont be doing this job that you do, but instead you would have been out there fighting with them. You are doing this job because it fulfills your proirities more than your convictions do. Admit it.

thanx for the freedom of blabbering :p ,,,,,,,,, dude i was eagerly waiting for ur statement dat { bhai issa nd sey to tu aarey kyu bethya sey ,,,,, jaakey kuch kar naxliyaan khaterr,,,,,},,,
bro,,,,,,, u dont u join S.T.F n get hold of those naxals who trouble ur frn`s dad ............ aur bhai,,,,,, tu chahey maaney ya na manney,,,,,,,,,i really find their actions very well justified ,,,,,, but if u still have sm doubts regarding my feelings,,,,,,,, yu KHATKA daab key dekh ley

The fact is that I do not support either the naxals or the government. But since you kiss a$$ naxals so much you have a higher incentive to quit your job and join their ranks.


http://www.jatland.com/forums/showthread.php?t=12634



my dear bro,,,,,, im still waiting for my answer to the question which i had put up to u.............................
i have no intensions of hurting anybody,,, so just chiill pill like yuorself.....as u usual do. hehe

The point is not taking a chill pill. You are spreading bull$hit propoaganda on this forum. I see that most of the people on this website have their priorities and opnions totally $crewed up. You opinions are evil. There is a saying in Icelandic: Tu ne cede malis." It means never give in to evil. I am a swonr enemy of communism which is a very evil philosophy. And I am not going to stand up to evil as long as I have to.

Talking of freedom of "blabbering." You will loose it the day the communists take over. They did it elsewhere they took power. So why wont they do it to you too. Other things that they will do are:

Take away your and your familiys' properties and redistribute.

Your job will be gone. No private enterprise. You might end up working on a state farm or a steel plant.

You will serve six months a year in the military.

Your Kids will nve have the luxury of good education.

You will loose your liberty to travel. No passports. You will be confined to a steel cage called India.

No newspaper, TV or internet. So you ownt be on jatland anymore.

and on and on.

So instead asking me to take a chill pill I want you to reananluze your positions.

 
Naxalism is nothing but a pseudo socialism and these naxalists are in hand in glow with the vested interests with hardly any welfare of poors/oppressed on their agenda.They are holding the progress of the nation to ransom.It is a cult with selfish roots.Sooner we get rid of them,better it will be for this nation/planet.They blow rail tracks,kill people,loot...whatever comes their way and then ask people to call them dhartiputtras.......idiotic!
 
Last edited:
Extraneous justifications!!!

Nothin can be rejected outrightly and at one go. If on the one side naxalites are being blamed for causing destruction, on the other our respectable politicians play their significant roles very smartly causing chaos in the society.....hope no body might have forgotten Gujarat riots....those brutal murders require no justification i guess.....So, no use talkin bout killings and brutalities......there r hell lot of examples.....

Stop supporting or rejecting anything at the first instance.....each one of us have our own solid reasons for the same.....and above all we are really good at justifying our beliefs coz everything has its pros and cons.

People who talk bout less govt. or privatisation should try to see beyond that coz even consequences of the same can be extremely severe....we are not talkin bout US or Canada here........ITS INDIA guys, where people still die of hunger. What wud one prefer.....dying of hunger or raising one's voice for survival????

Dont u talk bout means to get the same.....different ppl have different ways.....the only difference is of the visibility.....in some its apparent in others its not......but results are the same......dead bodies of some are way to other's liberation...be it a fight for survival....votes.....business.....money....power etc etc....i am not tryin to justify anybody's means here.......all i want to say is that everybody is sailing in the same boat......

Its better to introspect oneself thoroughly first rather than tellin ppl that their priorities and opinions are totally screwed up!!!
 
Last edited by a moderator:
dikshasingh81 said:
Nothin can be rejected outrightly and at one go. If on the one side naxalites are being blamed for causing destruction, on the other our respectable politicians play their significant roles very smartly causing chaos in the society.....hope no body might have forgotten Gujarat riots....those brutal murders require no justification i guess.....So, no use talkin bout killings and brutalities......there r hell lot of examples.....

Stop supporting or rejecting anything at the first instance.....each one of us have our own solid reasons for the same.....and above all we are really good at justifying our beliefs coz everything has its pros and cons.

People who talk bout less govt. or privatisation should try to see beyond that coz even consequences of the same can be extremely severe....we are not talkin bout US or Canada here........ITS INDIA guys, where people still die of hunger. What wud one prefer.....dying of hunger or raising one's voice for survival????

Dont u talk bout means to get the same.....different ppl have different ways.....the only difference is of the visibility.....in some its apparent in others its not......but results are the same......dead bodies of some are way to other's liberation...be it a fight for survival....votes.....business.....money....power etc etc....i am not tryin to justify anybody's means here.......all i want to say is that everybody is sailing in the same boat......

Its better to introspect oneself thoroughly first rather than tellin ppl that their priorities and opinions are totally screwed up!!!



But a position is better than an ambiguous stalemate.Nothing can be made out from your post.Please clarify your position a little more.
 
Nothin can be rejected outrightly and at one go. If on the one side naxalites are being blamed for causing destruction, on the other our respectable politicians play their significant roles very smartly causing chaos in the society.....hope no body might have forgotten Gujarat riots....those brutal murders require no justification i guess.....So, no use talkin bout killings and brutalities......there r hell lot of examples.....

I have mademy position clear. I HATE GOVERNMENT FROM THE BOTTOM OF MY HEART. Both the Naxals and the government are a threat to the welfare of our nation.

From what you have said above, you seem to dislike government too, as you agree that politicians are petty beings who create problems in our society for their own selfish ends. Welcome aboard the "Anti-Government Boat." :-)


Stop supporting or rejecting anything at the first instance.....each one of us have our own solid reasons for the same.....and above all we are really good at justifying our beliefs coz everything has its pros and cons.

I love to outrightly accept anything that is voluntary, and reject anything that is non-voluntary. The similarity between the Naxals and the government is that they both make citizens pay non-voluntary. It is known as taxation for the government and extortion for the Naxals.

You may challenge any of my opinions and I will surely amaze you the amount of backup information I have support my faith.


People who talk bout less govt. or privatisation should try to see beyond that coz even consequences of the same can be extremely severe....we are not talkin bout US or Canada here........ITS INDIA guys, where people still die of hunger. What wud one prefer.....dying of hunger or raising one's voice for survival????

Now you are being a hypocrite. You admitted above that politicians are selfish beings. How can you trust our lives with these petty beings. The reason India was laid back for over 40 years after independence was because of hardcore government contorl of the economy. The reason our economy is booming is becuase government is slwoly moving out of our lives and the economy. Free markets lead to prosperity. There is no doubt about it. Western Europe, East Asia and North America And Australasia are good examples.

Politicians who travel in bulletproof airconditioned convoys with a 100 black cat commandos are the one who would be least concerned about starving people. I am sure that if they reduce 10 commandos or one car from their convoy, there would be fewer straving people in India.

The reason people are poor is because of lack of oppportunities. Freemarkets create opportunities.


Dont u talk bout means to get the same.....different ppl have different ways.....the only difference is of the visibility.....in some its apparent in others its not......but results are the same......dead bodies of some are way to other's liberation...be it a fight for survival....votes.....business.....money....power etc etc....i am not tryin to justify anybody's means here.......all i want to say is that everybody is sailing in the same boat......

Its better to introspect oneself thoroughly first rather than tellin ppl that their priorities and opinions are totally screwed up!!!

That was a very good point you made. People are different. But socialism treats every one as same. There is no such thing as equality. Every one has different capabilities.

I totally denounce any ideology that leads to violence. Communism has, is and will lead to violence, becuase it that sour pill that is not easy to drown for "liberty loving people." Communism is a threat to individual liberty and goes agains the natural law of human rights, that includes: right to live, right to prosper, right to learn and the right to liberty.

Where I am today is after a lot o introspection. I have traveled around the world and I have spoken to pioneers of their respective fields. My position is that LIFE and LIBERTY are the essential ingredients for a successful human civilization. Anything that threatens LIFE and LIBERTY should be undesirable.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top