Reality of FDI, beyond politics

bhai Vikas aapki saari baat sahi... par ek baat to batao...

ye jo link kal aapne yahan share kiya tha "FYI: http://www.ndtv.com/video/player/pri...tory/247634?hp"

is video ke starting mai ek IIM ke prof. ne kuch doubts bataye the... or kuch sawal pooche the...

unke jawab... na to shaane shakeel ne diye... oe na sharma ji ne... or vardhan ji ne bhi kuch nahi bola...

ek bar point-wise unke jawab yahan likh do, ya kisi se likhwa do... to mai bhi aapke saath FDI jindabaad ke naare lagana suru kar dounga...

ek baat or meri samajh mai nahi aai... ye kaisa economist hai jo economics ki kaman sambhalte ki bahar ke paiso pe nazare daalni suru kar deta hai... or desh diwalia hone ki kagar pe pahunch jata hai??? kal bhi ye badi besharmi se bol ruhe the... "koi bhi hume karja dene ko taiyar nahi tha"... inke raaj mai aisi naubat kyon aa jati hai???

doosri taraf atal ji ki sarkar thi... jinke raj mai FDI to door ki baat thi.. US ne business ristriction tak laga di thi... or un sab ke bawajood... India ko karja lene ki naubat nahi aai... uska ulta... India ne apna poorana karja kam kar diya tha???

ye humare economist PM (1991 ke FM) aisa koun sa karishma kar dete hain???
 
http://www.ndtv.com/video/player/prime-time/video-story/247634?hp


ye le bhai, dekh le Ravish ko hi

ज्यादा तो नही जानता इस विदेशी मुद्रा निवेश के बारे मे, कही ये पठा तो सोचने पर जरूर मजबूर हुआ कि क्या सच मे कोई फायदा होगा किसी का या फिर जनता को बेवूफ बना दिया जाएगाl

Post by ravishndtv एक किराने वाले की कहानी:

ध्यान से पढ़ें। किराना दुकानदार से मिलकर आ रहा हूं।उनकी जानकारी पर हैरान हूं। जो कहा वो लिख रहा हूं। उसने एक मिसाल दी। तीन चार साल पहले जब आशीर्वाद आटा आया तो थोक में गेहूं 11.50 रुपये प्रति किलो गेहूं मिल रहा था। उसी दाम पर हम आटा चक्की वाले आपको 130 रुपये प्रति दस किलो बेच रहे थे। तब हमारा 140 रुपये प्रति दस किलो था। चूंकी आशीर्वाद के पास पूंजी थी तो कम में बेचा और बाज़ार पर छा गया। लेकिन आज आशीर्वाद दस किलो आटा 240 रुपये का बेचता है और हम 180 रुपये का। थोक में गेहूं 15.50 रुपये प्रति किलो है। तो किसान को कहां ज़्यादा मिला। उपभोक्ता तो ज़्यादा दाम पर ही ख़रीद रहा है। इसलिए किसान के भले की बात पल्ले नहीं पड़ रही है। इतने सालों में दस किलो ग्राम आटे का दाम हमारी चक्की पर 40 रुपये बढ़ा और आशीर्वाद ने 110 रुपये बढ़ाये। इसने जमे जमाए शक्तिभोग की कमर भी तोड़ दी। उसी तरह से टाटा ने मूंग दाल लांच किया है। हाई क्वालिटी की है जो बाज़ार में 80 रुपये प्रति किलो में मिल रही थी । इससे खुदरा मूंग दाल वाले ग़ायब हो गए और अब टाटा की नई पैकेट 100 रुपये प्रति किलो की आ रही है। उसने कहा कि बड़ी कंपनियों के पास घाटा सहने की शक्ति है। जब पड़ोस में मोर का सुपर स्टोर खुला तो हम बर्बाद हो रहे थे लेकिन मंदी आ गई तो लोग दाम का हिसाब लगाने लगे। तब हमारा बिजनेस पिक अप करने लगा लेकिन तभी एक दूसरा मल्टी स्टोर ईजी डे में आ गया। हम पर फिर दबाव बढ़ गया। हम खत्म नहीं हो जायेंगे मगर ज़रूरत क्या है। यह क्यों कहा जा रहा है कि उपभोक्ता और किसान को फायदा होगा। जहां ज़रूरत है वहां निवेश करो। मेट्रो में निवेश का किसी ने विरोध किया। यह भी सही है कि मेट्रो के आने से कारों की बिक्री कम नहीं हुई लेकिन किसी की पूंजी की ताकत से हम कब तक लड़ेंगे। वालमार्ट जहां पर ताकत से खुलेगा वहां हम बर्बाद हो जायेंगे। अभी जो स्टोर खुलते हैं वो ज्यादा दिन नहीं टिक पा रहे हैं। इसलिए हम डूबते उतराते रहते हैं।

एक दुकानदार अपनी समझ से बोले जा रहा था। पूछा कि आपको जानकारी कैसे मिलती है। कहा कि टीवी पर बकवास चलता है हम पेपर ध्यान से पढ़ते हैं
 
Bhai maine thread ki shuruat mein hi likhi thi ki yaha BJP Vs. Congress debate nahi muddo ki baat hogi.

Aap ka FDI ke mudde par jo niji nazariya hai wo batao, rajniti se pare.


doosri taraf atal ji ki sarkar thi... jinke raj mai FDI to door ki baat thi.. US ne business ristriction tak laga di thi... or un sab ke bawajood... India ko karja lene ki naubat nahi aai... uska ulta... India ne apna poorana karja kam kar diya tha???

ye humare economist PM (1991 ke FM) aisa koun sa karishma kar dete hain???
 

I know very well about NDTV and its agenda. NDTV is the last thing I would like to believe. Bhrakha-Radia tape case is still fresh in public memory. Ravish is only a face here. Agenda is always set by bosses. My post is not related to Ravish. I am least interested in defending him. Remember: What is written is more important than who writes it. This is the very basic which media has forgotten , so, facing huge credibility crisis.
 
Last edited:
bhai kisi bhi business model mai yahi hota hai... different stages pe different type ke break even aate hain...

ek running cost (expense jayada-return kam) ka break-even point... starting mai customer ko accha product, saste main beecho or staring mai accha raw material bhi costly rehta hai... fir raw material pe bargain karo... thoda sa quality ke saath compromise karo... or apne product ki quantity thodi ki kam kar ke uski cost badha do...

fir capital cost ka break-even point... running cost ka break-even aate hi... capex ko recover karna targe tho jata hai... ab bade cuts suru hote hain... starting mai employee salary bhi,compititors se jayada hoti hai... but kuch saal incremt na dene se... and no of employee kam kar ke ye cost over the time balance ho jati hai... vendors (kisan in this case) mai compitition karwa ke raw material sasta mai uthana... na beechne wale ke pass option choodna or na purchase karne wale ke pass... or bhi bahot sari aisi oochi harkatein kar ke apne paise banana... yahi rehta hai in sabka business model...

उसने कहा कि बड़ी कंपनियों के पास घाटा सहने की शक्ति है।
 
Last edited:
Media is opinionated but not the the extend people blame.

SOme of my very good friends work with NDTV and a couple of them are at decision making levels so it is not what everyone thinks :)
I know very well about NDTV and its agenda. NDTV is the last thing I would like to believe. Bhrakha-Radia tape case is still fresh in public memory. Ravish is only a face here. Agenda is always set by bosses. My post is not related to Ravish. I am least interested in defending him. Remember: What is written is more important than who writes it. This is the very basic which media has forgotten , so, facing huge credibility crisis.
 
1. Bhai maine apna niji najaria bhi bata diya, abhi tak mili information ke hisaab se... vo badal bhi jayega agar kuch sawalo ke jawab mil jaye to... kyon ki ho sakta hai ki mugjhe aadhi jankari ko or mai FDI ke bare meri galat soch ho....

2. ye political issue hi hai... ek ke raj mai karja lena pade or doosre ka raj karja chuka de... is ke bare mai vichar-vimarsh karne mai kya harz hai????

3. Selective Reading : agar aapko political issues pe baat nahi karni thi to aapko mere post ki, vo do lines quote karne ke bajai... upar ki 5 lines ke jawab de dene chahiye the... aap ne abhi tak, last 5-6 din se kisi sawal ka jawab nahi diya hai... bas apne key-board ko punishment dene mai lage hue ho... atleast mere in sawalo ke jawab to de do jo aapke shared (ndtv link) video mai hi pooche gaye or wahan par bhi jawab nahi mile...


Bhai maine thread ki shuruat mein hi likhi thi ki yaha BJP Vs. Congress debate nahi muddo ki baat hogi.

Aap ka FDI ke mudde par jo niji nazariya hai wo batao, rajniti se pare.



Bbhai Vikas aapki saari baat sahi... par ek baat to batao...

ye jo link kal aapne yahan share kiya tha "FYI: http://www.ndtv.com/video/player/pri...tory/247634?hp"

is video ke starting mai ek IIM ke prof. ne kuch doubts bataye the... or kuch sawal pooche the...

unke jawab... na to shaane shakeel ne diye... oe na sharma ji ne... or vardhan ji ne bhi kuch nahi bola...

ek bar point-wise unke jawab yahan likh do, ya kisi se likhwa do... to mai bhi aapke saath FDI jindabaad ke naare lagana suru kar dounga...
 
Media is opinionated but not the the extend people blame.

SOme of my very good friends work with NDTV and a couple of them are at decision making levels so it is not what everyone thinks :)

Media is not the topic here, otherwise, I would have written a long reply. People are not just blaming. They are exposing blunt lies and political leaning of these crooks day and night on social media with facts. Carry on with the topic. I don't have expertise to comment on FDI in retail. Its very contentious issue. Still; personally, I don't support it, though, I may be wrong.
 
Last edited:
All Large store of Tata and Reliance Mart are in profit and no one is in loss. There are as much expert as any big retail chain and moreover 70% of their product are Indian which help to flourish the Indian Industry. All Big Bajar store is in profit. If they were in loss then we unable to see more then 2000 store of Big Bajar in India promoted by Mr. Kishor Biyani. Only the small store like Reliance Fresh and Subiksha and some more small store has got unsucessfull. None of the Big store has impacted at all and more and more are opening by passing each year.

These Big stores are getting thousand of customers on daily basis and Kirana store losing the customer on other side.

The comparison of Dhaba and McDee is absurd because the food menu of both is different. The person who like to eat roti will still visit the Dhaba. A burger can't become the alternative of Roti in Indian context.

But these Multi brand store will sale the same product like which local Kirana store sale in their shop.
So one is indeed going to lose their business.

Nobody is still stopping Tatas or Ambanis. Point is, none of them have been profitable till now for a simple reason, they lack expertise to manage the system.
Secondly, the article speaks about how kirana stores will not go anywhere for the ease and comfort they give. Have you seen local dhabas go away because of McD?
 
You are giving the reference of Govt claim. People don't have faith on Govt decision that's why Majority of people opposing the FDI in retail.

Comparison with 1991 again absurd. In 1991 Govt has opened up the various sector from govt control. Here Govt is not opening any sector from the govt control. Here Govt allowing FDI in retail. In retail sector more then 5 crore people directly get the employment.

Without addressing the concern of this large section Govt allowing FDI in this sector just to please their foreign masters.

 
Indeed Indian companies will also go for profit. But you are missing the base difference.

All Indian companies are sourcing their 70% product line from India itself. Which help manufacturing industries to grow more and consequently it create more employment.

On the other hand Govt has just put a restriction on foreign retailers to source 30% of product from India. They are free to outsource 70% product from outside of India. They will import the item in bulk from China, Chile or any other country from where they will get the item at lowest price.

Consequently, Indian manufacturing industry will also impact and along side the local store unable to compete with such low price who source their product from India only mostly.

Why only foriegn players, you think Indian companies dont do so? Ambanis or Tatas or Birlas play fair game and create value for society instead of share holders?
 
Last edited:
Sahi baat hai unhe agar china se sastamaal milega to woh usko yaha behengey..aur ab ho bhi yahi raha hai. Yeh to kuch dalal hai sarkar ke jo isko pracharit kar rahe hai.
 
On behalf of a desijat... FDI pe apni niji raye do... keep politics out of it... :)

aapke post mai underline kiye words/lines topic ke saath match nahi kar ruhe hain... :)

yahan pe ye mat batao... ki Govt kya kar ruhi hai... sirf ye batao ki aapke hisab se FDI ke kya fayede hain or kya nuksaan hai... ha ha ha ha... kya wahiyat condition hai... jo ho ruha hai us pe comment karo, jo kar ruha hai uspe comment mat karo...

You are giving the reference of Govt claim. People don't have faith on Govt decision that's why Majority of people opposing the FDI in retail.

Comparison with 1991 again absurd. In 1991 Govt has opened up the various sector from govt control. Here Govt is not opening any sector from the govt control. Here Govt allowing FDI in retail. In retail sector more then 5 crore people directly get the employment.

Without addressing the concern of this large section Govt allowing FDI in this sector just to please their foreign masters.
 
1. Do you think the salaried class pay their tax fairly? If Yes, then you are just dreaming.

2. Are you expecting the store like Walmart are going to absorb these shopkeeper? No, Not at all. They will hire semi skilled Metric or intermediate pass and graduate only. And these shopkeeper need to shut their business after some time. So what plan govt have for these shopkeeper????




That is good if these Non Tax payer shopkeeper converted to Tax payer employees. I think it is positive
 
There is not protectionism in retail. Big Indian retail chain already exist.

Govt have to take the decision in the interest of India not in the interest of foreign masters.

FDI in retail: A step in the right direction!

Indians should not be mislead by conspiracy of protectionism. We had this protectionism for years but no good happened in the country. Licence Raj, rigid labour laws and monster bureaucracy(where No accountability exists) let down the economy and kept millions of Indians away from jobs. I think more substantial reforms are needed in order to strengthen the economy!
 
Bahi Vikash nai khud govt ki statement ka link diya...ab govt ka naam to lena padyga rebuke kartay huay....

On behalf of a desijat... FDI pe apni niji raye do... keep politics out of it... :)

aapke post mai underline kiye words/lines topic ke saath match nahi kar ruhe hain... :)

yahan pe ye mat batao... ki Govt kya kar ruhi hai... sirf ye batao ki aapke hisab se FDI ke kya fayede hain or kya nuksaan hai... ha ha ha ha... kya wahiyat condition hai... jo ho ruha hai us pe comment karo, jo kar ruha hai uspe comment mat karo...
 
I cant agree with you more...

Do main sector hain... Service Sector (includes BPO, IT and Softwares) and Menufacturing Sector...

Service mai china apni badi fauj khadi kar ruha... or dheere-2 india ko pichadne ki kosish kar ruha hai... or iske result thode din mai nazar bhi aane lag jayange...
Menufacturing mai to india and china ka abhi bhi koi comparison nahi hai... or bachi-khuchi kasar FDI la kar ye sarkar poori kar degi...

inko lagta hai ki FDI se india ki economy grow hogi or GDP improve hogi... GDP bahar se paisa lene se improve nahi hoti... ye domestice production increase karne se improve hogi... jab hum import kam karein or export jayada karein... FDI se to import or jayada hona suru hoga to ye GDP mai kaise help karega... mere to samajh se bahar ki baat hai... aapki samajh mai kuch aata ho to thodi light maaro...

matlad ye ki india ko gheer ke lengae...

Indeed Indian companies will also go for profit. But you are missing the base difference.

All Indian companies are sourcing their 70% product line from India itself. Which help manufacturing industries to grow more and consequently it create more employment.

On the other hand Govt has just put a restriction on foreign retailers to source 30% of product from India. They are free to outsource 70% product from outside of India. They will import the item in bulk from China, Chile or any other country from where they will get the item at lowest price.

Consequently, Indian manufacturing industry will also impact and along side the local story unable to compete with such low price who source their product from India only mostly.
 
Last edited:
Bhai aap thoda dhayan lagao aur dimaag lagao aur pata lagao protectionism ka meaning. Hopefully aapko answer mil jayega... history utha ke dekho,,aur padho,, 1970 mei China ne kya kiya,, 1991 mei India ne kya kiya.. 1990 se pehle India mei kya hota tha.. Ye topic bada hai.. ispe aap pehle thoda apna time nikal kar padhna,, kyon desh ki tarakki ruki hui hai.. Kyon India ki ease doing of business mei rating poor hai.. Pher hum is vishay par aur charcha karenge!

There is not protectionism in retail. Big Indian retail chain already exist.

Govt have to take the decision in the interest of India not in the interest of foreign masters.
 
Last edited:
I'm well aware of the situation before 1991 and well aware about Licence Raj or the Permit Raj.

For your help you have to read about Licence Raj or the Permit Raj and develop a basic understanding How the abolition of Licence Raj or the Permit Raj is different from allowing FDI in retail.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Licence_Raj

Abolition of Licence Raj was meant for the removal of restriction on private player before setting up any business.

Private player were allowed to collaborate with foreign companies. So that Indian companies get the latest technologies and help the manufacturing sector and which have created lots of employment.
Here read the word collaboration carefully. Like Maruti and Suzuki collaborated with each other. Sector like Telecom and Power has opened up for private players after 1991.

Now compare the situation with FDI in retail. The retail sector was never restricted for private participation. In Retail sector private player already exist in big numbers and FII has also invested in those companies as well. So there was no protectionism in retail sector

Now instead of encouraging the Private player to collaborate with foreign player to get the latest technology and system. Govt giving the free hand to foreign player to become the master in India in retail sector. These foreign retail chain allows to import 70% of their item from outside of India. Such companies not only kill the existing small retailers but will also destroy the manufacturing sector which already struggling to sustain.

So your comparison before 1991 situation in retail sector is just an hogwash!

Bhai aap thoda dhayan lagao aur dimaag lagao aur pata lagao protectionism ka meaning. Hopefully aapko answer mil jayega... history utha ke dekho,,aur padho,, 1970 mei China ne kya kiya,, 1991 mei India ne kya kiya.. 1990 se pehle India mei kya hota tha.. Ye topic bada hai.. ispe aap pehle thoda apna time nikal kar padhna,, kyon desh ki tarakki ruki hui hai.. Kyon India ki ease doing of business mei rating poor hai.. Pher hum is vishay par aur charcha karenge!
 
Last edited:
Back
Top