Reality of FDI, beyond politics

एफडीआई एक बहस का मुद्दा?
प्यारे जाट भाईयों व बहनो,
मेरा निजी तौर पर यह मानना है कि जब सन् 1991 में उदार आर्थिक नीति को अपनाया गया, तो भी एक बहस का मुद्दा था, लेकिन अभी उसके परिणाम हमारे सामने हैं कि इस व्यवस्था से गरीब अधिक गरीब और अमीर अधिक अमीर होता चला गया, लेकिन साथ-साथ देश की आर्थिक स्थिति भी सुदृढ़ होती चली गई। अभी चाहे कोई भी सरकार आए, उसको यह आर्थिक सुधार अपनाने ही होंगे, क्योंकि अभी ऐसी व्यवस्था स्थापित हो चुकी है। लेकिन अफसोस की बात यह है कि किसानों की स्थिति दिन प्रतिदिन बिगड़ती चली गई क्योंकि उसकी लागत बढ़ती रही और फसल की कीमतों में इजाफ नहीं हुआ। हमारा मुख्य विषय व चिंता हमारा ग्रामीण जाट किसान है, जो हमारे समाज की रीढ़ है और हमारी जड़ें भी। अभी मेरा यह सोचना है कि यदि एफडीआई लागू होती है तो शायद किसान को फायदा हो क्योंकि अभी तक मंडियों की मोनोपोली रही है, जहां किसान अपनी फसल बेचने के लिए मजबूर है। आज किसान मजदूर से भी ज्यादा शोषित समाज है, जिसकी आवाज उठाने वाला और कोई नहीं है। मेरा यह मानना है कि एफडीआई लागू होने से फसलों के खरीददार बढ़ेंगे और जितने भी खरीददार बढ़ेंगे, हमें उम्मीद है कि फसल के दाम भी बढ़ेंगे, जिससे जाट किसानों को राहत मिलने की आशा है। कृपया इस विषय पर आप अपने विचार एक सप्ताह में अवश्य स्पष्ट करें ताकि हम किसी नतीजे पर पहुंच सकें। आपका अपना हवासिंह सांगवान।
 
एफडीआई एक बहस का मुद्दा?
प्यारे जाट भाईयों व बहनो,
.........

ये कहना जरा मुश्किल है की किसानो का खास फायदा हो पायेगा या नहीं...

क्यूँ रिटेल फॉर्मेट अभी भी है मार्केट में जहाँ देसी प्लयेर मौजूद हैं..(रेलैंस फ्रेश, मोर इत्यादि) .. परन्तु वहां अम्रीका के संतरे, फिजी/न्यू ज़ीलैण्ड के सब.. चाइना के pear इत्यादि....

जब बड़े खिलाडी आएंगे (वाल्ल्मार्ट , Carrefour इत्यादि) तो वो माल ग्लोबली खरीदेंगे जहाँ से भी उन्हें सस्ता पड़ेगा..क्यूंकि वो volume में बल्क buying करेंगे...

They have robust, efficient supply chain (demand planning, supply network planning, backward & forward integration) network, distribution, warehousing, transport jisme desi player bohot peechay hain unse..

So, they'll have less landed cost, even if they import.
Cheaper destinations like China, will be the real benificiary. Though govt. can take steps to increase custom duties (Protective Duties, Anti Dumping Duty , Safeguard Duty, to protect domestic producers and make this landed price go higher so as to protect domestic industry...

It all depends how govt will formaulate & regulate this... It could be a boon, could be a curse.

It would bring the competition for desi players to tighten up their seat belts & impove their old business model. Later govt can reduce the FDI%, and then our desi players can reap the benifits.

Overall, it'll be good for consumers. Better Price, Availibility, Quaility.

If we remember, the days of liscence raj. Had it been the same era/govt mindest. we would have been waiting for months to get out maruti 800 (or few less options)/telephone connections. PV Narsimha transformed the nation way back in early 90's, opening the indians gates for FDI, at a time, when india was on verge of bankruptcy. Don't forget the econimics side, we need better currency valuation viz dollars, forex reserves, balance of payments etc (to name a few jargons)

I FULLY SUPPORT THIS DECISION...:applause:
 
Last edited:
एफडीआई एक बहस का मुद्दा?
प्यारे जाट भाईयों व बहनो,
मेरा निजी तौर पर यह मानना है कि जब सन् 1991 में उदार आर्थिक नीति को अपनाया गया, तो भी एक बहस का मुद्दा था, लेकिन अभी उसके परिणाम हमारे सामने हैं कि इस व्यवस्था से गरीब अधिक गरीब और अमीर अधिक अमीर होता चला गया, लेकिन साथ-साथ देश की आर्थिक स्थिति भी सुदृढ़ होती चली गई। अभी चाहे कोई भी सरकार आए, उसको यह आर्थिक सुधार अपनाने ही होंगे, क्योंकि अभी ऐसी व्यवस्था स्थापित हो चुकी है। लेकिन अफसोस की बात यह है कि किसानों की स्थिति दिन प्रतिदिन बिगड़ती चली गई क्योंकि उसकी लागत बढ़ती रही और फसल की कीमतों में इजाफ नहीं हुआ। हमारा मुख्य विषय व चिंता हमारा ग्रामीण जाट किसान है, जो हमारे समाज की रीढ़ है और हमारी जड़ें भी। अभी मेरा यह सोचना है कि यदि एफडीआई लागू होती है तो शायद किसान को फायदा हो क्योंकि अभी तक मंडियों की मोनोपोली रही है, जहां किसान अपनी फसल बेचने के लिए मजबूर है। आज किसान मजदूर से भी ज्यादा शोषित समाज है, जिसकी आवाज उठाने वाला और कोई नहीं है। मेरा यह मानना है कि एफडीआई लागू होने से फसलों के खरीददार बढ़ेंगे और जितने भी खरीददार बढ़ेंगे, हमें उम्मीद है कि फसल के दाम भी बढ़ेंगे, जिससे जाट किसानों को राहत मिलने की आशा है। कृपया इस विषय पर आप अपने विचार एक सप्ताह में अवश्य स्पष्ट करें ताकि हम किसी नतीजे पर पहुंच सकें। आपका अपना हवासिंह सांगवान।

Sir,

Very valid issue for debate but before one could proceed further kindly let us know what has led you to think that it will benefit the Jat farmers.

Thanks
 
I'm waiting for the day when govt opens up FDI in Real Estate, Airlines, Train operations......baans raakhe saan in dessi/sarkari companies ne...
 
When government of in India appears too eager to throw open its retail sectors to multinational giants, American President Obama, tweeted in November, 2011 advising Americans to support small businesses in their community by shopping at their favorite local stores.

Newspapers are advertisements that it will create 10 million jobs in three years. But if you look at facts, Wal-Mart dominates big retail in USA with turnover of $400 billion, and employs 2.1 million people. Our Indian retail sector also has a turnover of $400 billion, but employs 44 million people. So, it is the Indian retail which is a much-bigger employer, and any effort to allow retail FDI may destroy millions of livelihoods.

In UK, Tesco and Sainsbury had committed to create 24,000 jobs between them, in the past two years. A British government enquiry found out that instead of creating any additional job, these two companies had actually thrown out 850 people from existing jobs. The big retail firms which failed to create jobs in their own countries cannot be expected to create additional employment in our country.

Other argument favouring of FDI in retail sector is that it will provide 30 per cent more income to farmers. In the US, if Wal-Mart was able to enhance farm incomes there was no reason why the America government would dole out a massive subsidy of $307 billion under the US Farm Bill 2008, which basically makes a budgetary subsidy provision for the next five years. Most of these subsidies are clubbed in the category of Green Box under the WTO. And as per an UNCTAD-India study, if the Green Box subsidies are withdrawn, American agriculture faces a collapse.

भारत सरकार किसानो नै कती बर्बाद करण पै तुल रही सै. डी.ए.पी. का कट्टा 3-4 साल पहले 465 रु. का आया करता वो पिछले साल 900 का कर दिया और इबके नै 1200 का यो हे हाल यूरिया का, बस कृषि सब्सिडी ख़त्म करनी जरूरी इनने, किसान मरो या जिओ
 
Dear All,

the discussion till now had been very enlightening. I am putting my views on the screen.

1. Well, Do we not have large stores/supermarkets..?? yes we do have ( of course all belonging to Indian capitalists).

2. Are these stores hampering the bread and butter of Kiryana store prople.
well , may be the big stores made an impact when first opened ,,but gradualy the local kiryana store people adapted and improvised themselves.

3. Are new stores from Indian player not coming up. ??
yes, Many ,,each year there are bigger plans. so can we say that these are Indian WAL-MARTS.
Again they will have little impact in the area of opening and later the others will improvise.
This is COMPETITION, the one who is better wins.

4. Will every one go to the HYPERMARKETS.
NO, because a person who has to buys a kilo of sugar or 50 gms of jeera or 100 gms of haldi will never go to big places ( many reasons...distance one of them). or the ones who buy for day to day needs like 1/2 kg aata, 250gm dal and 1 shampoo pouch etc.

5. Should 51% FDI be allowed in Retail.
NO, A BIG NO. we should have decision making power in our hands , FDI can be allowed up to roughly about 33%, which means we can get the so called ''expertise'' and some funds which will some help the Indian counterparts.

6. What about Indian Manufacturers than..????
Well as of now , i believe ( don't have exact data) most of the big player have some of their own brands in clothing or some other items, which they manufacture at their own uints. and some of the things are purchased from China too.

Well, there should be a strict low-import policy for these big player or they may be allowed to import for the first five years so that they can have a good cash flow to start manufacturing in India ,which will help boost both Indian industry and generate employment. And we all know that when produced in bulk goods get cheap automatically.

7. IMPACT ON CONDITIONS OF FARMERS.
If there are good contract farming agreements ( with government as mediator and facilitator) than definatley it can help the condition of farmers and also can help tackle inflation as these big players will be having capability to process and store certain tangible farm produces,, like the ''POTATO'' which is generally thrown every year after a bumper crop or wheat/paddy getting rotten in mandis.

.... will be continued later.
 
Last edited:
र यु सारा रोला "काला धन " धोला कर के उलटा ल्यावन का स | ना ते कददे हो इनके पिस्स्याँ ने अमरीका ,इंग्लेंड चुय्स ज्यांगे |ज्युकर ओड़डा ले के ने कुवेत ,ईराक अर लीबिया का च्युस गे | ये नेता किहे के भी कोणी (चाहे किहे भी दल के हों ),इन् ने बस पिस्से चाहियें ,चाहे देश की माँ-भाण हो जा |
 
I would try my level best to keep it healthy discussion .

Also, 49% of the market is still controlled by Indian players

Dear Vikas----Still 51% would under the control Foreign Investors , they will the BOSSES on my LAND

airline industry
I agree with this--however please understand there is a Xillion Light years difference between 1 air ticket and 1 kg of sugar .......

Now my problem is ---------I can be convinced if it is for any good to agriculture and our respected farmers . My problem is WHATS THE ASSURANCE WALMART WOULD BE BUYING FROM OUR FARMERS .

Just FYI.......dear------kahin padha tha Lays n some foreign chips making company refused to use Potatoes cultivated in India by saying they are of Poor Quality .

McDonald- Pizza Hut- Dominos- KFC-----they all get stuff from outside saying our products are of Poor Quality--------soooooooooooooooooo

Now u understand my problem-----I Hope Wish that u and all u folks are right and I would be damn wrong .

What if me and people like me are right----then we are gone for toss .
Things are not good--still we are sailing ---what if they would go WORSE ..........bahut bada RISK hai n we must not take it ------







Not at all, infact I trust them so much and I am sure they tested the markets long time before and that is why are not coming into it. Aditya Birla and Reliance had already tried their hands and failed. Bharti has been gathering expertise in a tie up with Walmart.

We must understand that retailing is not as simple as it sounds, technical capabilities and know-how is what we aim to achieve through those who have been big worldwide. Also, 49% of the market is still controlled by Indian players and no one still still stopping them if they want to go solo.

To give you another example, look at our airline industry which has been bleeding because govt was late to allow foreign investments by global players who have been managing better airlines. Due to the delay in implementing the policy a lot of our airlines(Kingfisher for one) have been bleeding money and Air India is nothing more than a money sucking parasite. Having said that, Indigo is the only profitable player and that is because of their know-how and business acumen which is separate from rest of them all.

Same way, Walmart, Tesco have their expertise which can put us on an rampant growth without waiting for another decade to build capacities.
 
Just FYI.......dear------kahin padha tha Lays n some foreign chips making company refused to use Potatoes cultivated in India by saying they are of Poor Quality .

------

I think Pepsico is still buying potatoes in Bengal for American chip making companies. It is all double speak by those political parties who are opposed to it. The Governments of Bihar, MP and Orissa have signed contracts with the companies like Earnest & Young for investment in their specialized areas for creating infrastructure. Whereas the parties ruling in these states are opposing FDI in retail proposed by central government. The Indian politics is too complex to be deciphered by a common man. A common man has nothing substantial to loose and the middlemen, brokers, retailers and the black-marketeers have already accumulated enough wealth to survive. So, nothing to worry. India should let the FDI in retail in without thinking twice.
 
Last edited:
Just checked :

http://pepsicoindia.co.in/purpose/environmental-sustainability/partnership-with-farmers.html

So u were right however could not find anything regarding Earnest & Young deal------as I said earlier if it would be doing any good to our agriculture , I m in .

Okay---ek aur cheez yad aayee - Green Revolution has increased our yield with exponential rate--we did awesome good

But in long run---disastrous now we are so dependent on Chemicals n all that stuff, so many disease n all that-----again same thing repeating

Game woh khelo , jis mei Winning is assured -else you must have capacity to bear the defeat .

Again- I have negative thoughts---kahin in contracts se aisa toh nahi hoga--that our farmers would loose their free will to sell to whom n what price .
( Sorry I look at risks first )

I think Pepsico is still buying potatoes in Bengal for American chip making companies. It is all double speak by those political parties who are opposed to it. The Governments of Bihar, MP and Orissa have signed contracts with the companies like Earnest & Young to procure agriculture produce from farmers on contract basis. Whereas the parties ruling in these states are opposing FDI in retail proposed by central government. The Indian politics is too complex to be deciphered by a common man. A common man has nothing substantial to loose and the middlemen, brokers, retailers and the black-marketeers have already accumulated enough wealth to survive. So, nothing to worry. India should let the FDI in retail in without thinking twice.
 
Again- I have negative thoughts---kahin in contracts se aisa toh nahi hoga--that our farmers would loose their free will to sell to whom n what price .
( Sorry I look at risks first )

What about risk management? :)

Anyways, baniyo ne bhtera khoon choos liya mhaara.. ab in Walmart, Tesco ne bhi test kar ke dekh lyo.. Aisa kuch nahi hai ki Walmart ke aane se mandiya band ho jayengi.. wo tab bhi rahengi.. jisko jaha apni fasal bechni hai wo wha bech sakta hai.. Bangalore me Madiwala naam ki jagah hai. wha sabji mandi hai aur uske bilkul pass TOTAL mall hai.. sabjiya dono jagah milti hai, mandi me bhi aur mall me bi. mauka lage to jra ek bar mandi ka najara lena subah.. najafgarh ke jhadodha stand jisa haal ho jaya kare!


And I was surprised to notice that nobody except Atish pointed at infrastructure benefits that will come due to this FDI.. Aadhi fasal to bina storage ke barbaad ho jati hai kisaan ki..:)
 
Last edited:
you have answered your own question. If you read my very first post, the letter it says no one will go to buy a bottle of coke, or a pinch of salt to these big stores. They are meant for bulk sales and considering Indians lack cars to some extent will be the reason why these stores will survive too.

The appetite is different, thus room for everyone.

These Big stores are getting thousand of customers on daily basis and Kirana store losing the customer on other side.

The comparison of Dhaba and McDee is absurd because the food menu of both is different. The person who like to eat roti will still visit the Dhaba. A burger can't become the alternative of Roti in Indian context.
 
Am a little curious about sources.

Indians still get majority of produce from any cheap source, China or where ever and there is no regulation to stop them. Atleast 30% rule is there now to protect the interest.

You seriously think Indian companies are so ethical that that they will be so committed to India?

Indeed Indian companies will also go for profit. But you are missing the base difference.

All Indian companies are sourcing their 70% product line from India itself. Which help manufacturing industries to grow more and consequently it create more employment.

On the other hand Govt has just put a restriction on foreign retailers to source 30% of product from India. They are free to outsource 70% product from outside of India. They will import the item in bulk from China, Chile or any other country from where they will get the item at lowest price.

Consequently, Indian manufacturing industry will also impact and along side the local store unable to compete with such low price who source their product from India only mostly.
 
Rekha ji hum itne hypocrite kyu ho jate hai?

Jab hmare Tata bahar ja ke Land Rover kharidte hai ya Infosys ja ke Americans ki jobs lete hai tab to hum bade khush hote hai par jab hum apne yaha hissedari mein, Indians ka interest save karte hue paisa invest karate hai to hum unhe boss banate hai... not a fair attitude :redface:

I would try my level best to keep it healthy discussion .

Also, 49% of the market is still controlled by Indian players

Dear Vikas----Still 51% would under the control Foreign Investors , they will the BOSSES on my LAND
 
Rekha ji hum itne hypocrite kyu ho jate ha

Sahi kaha----we are may be

Vikas ---only issue is --this is not some IT job or Fancy German cars we are talking about ----we are talking about basic amenities for common people .

I m not worried about people like me--who spends money on shopping n all those useless pleasure of so called modern life

I m only worried about people ------who earn bread butter by selling vegies n stuff on redhis or small kiryana store

---------But shayd aap sahi hai n mei galat -----------
 
Sir,

This all hue and cry over FDI in retail by opposition parties is to gain political advantage. Nothing else. Leaders like Mamta Banarzee do not even allow Indian companies to work in W.Bengal. Forget about foreign companies. The dire situation in W. Bengal is quite evident. Other party is Samajwaadi Party. I think political system in India is worse.

I think Pepsico is still buying potatoes in Bengal for American chip making companies. It is all double speak by those political parties who are opposed to it. The Governments of Bihar, MP and Orissa have signed contracts with the companies like Earnest & Young to procure agriculture produce from farmers on contract basis. Whereas the parties ruling in these states are opposing FDI in retail proposed by central government. The Indian politics is too complex to be deciphered by a common man. A common man has nothing substantial to loose and the middlemen, brokers, retailers and the black-marketeers have already accumulated enough wealth to survive. So, nothing to worry. India should let the FDI in retail in without thinking twice.
 
Last edited:
Came across wonderful article by Chetan Bhagat on FDI :

[h=1]No trick, FDI is a treat[/h]
http://blogs.timesofindia.indiatimes.com/The-underage-optimist/entry/no-trick-fdi-is-a-treat

Battered by the coal scam, the government has pushed through some long-overdue reforms in the last fortnight. These include allowing higher FDI equity in multi-brand retail and aviation. FDI creates extreme reactions in the country, and it might as well stand for 'Forever Debating Indians'.

Two kinds of polarized reactions emerged, both overdone. The first group had gushing praise. Newspaper headlines screamed on how the PM now meant business, and everything is going to be just fine on the policy front. Some even said that the PM could not be bogged down by those whining about the coal scam, thus implying now that he had finally done his job, it absolves him of the charge of mismanaging the country's natural resources. So low are our expectations from our PM, some feel he almost deserves a standing ovation every time he signs a file.

Anyhow, it's a good decision, if not monumental or heroic. Having a global mindset is beneficial for the country. We have seen the benefits of the 1991 reforms. The cellphones we carry, TV channels we watch, vehicles we drive, the appliances we use - are all a result of the liberalisation that were initiated two decades ago. Before that, the government felt it was perfectly fine for people to wait years for a landline phone and watch one government-run TV channel. With such a transformation as seen by the middle class, one wonders if there is still need to convince people on the benefits of reforms.

For apart from the praise, there was backlash too. The BJP denounced the new policies, presumably to please the trader community that supports it. The Trinamool Congress is screaming hoarse about the anti-people nature of such reforms. Mamata Banerjee is hoping to target the poor who have not benefited much from the reforms.

Other naysayers are arguing how this will destroy the kirana shops. These people presume Wal-Mart, with its 51% highly-regulated equity in a Indian venture, will be able to do what Reliance Fresh and Big Bazaar could not. The corporate Indian retail stores have been around for years. And yet, kirana shops flourish across the country. When asked how exactly could Wal-Mart do what Indian chains could not, the naysayers have no answer. When asked why Indians don't deserve the best value and retail shopping experience, they stay silent.

China, Malaysia, Thailand, Philippines are just a few examples of emerging economies that have allowed multi-brand retail and have had no major upheavals or large-scale unemployment.

At one level, this isn't only about multi-brand retail, which forms just one aspect of the widespread economic reforms required in the country. Are we going to start a polarized debate for every reform?

Can we not have some ground rules when looking at reforms? Can the government, the allies and the opposition have just this one area of consensus -the country must bring in economic reforms if we want to create wealth. Can we accept that reforms do ultimately benefit people?

The opposition has played a major role in this term to bring out various scams and keep the pressure on the government. However, to oppose everything, and for the sake of obstruction and not much else is not right either. The fear of foreigners is an outdated worldview that we should have abandoned in the eighties. Today, India needs to open up for business. India also needs to be able to learn how to compete with world-class competition. For every Costa Coffee that comes to India, we need to be able to create a Cafe Coffee Day and Barista that can hold their own. Not letting foreigners come and do business along with us is a sign of weakness. It is like hosting the Olympics and not allowing the best countries to compete.

The argument that Indian industry needs to be ready for competition is outdated. We have been getting ready for 20 years, if not longer. Let's have the confidence that kirana shops will reform too, so they can take on any new competition.

However, the support for FDI and some of the PM's policies in no way implies that the government is off the hook on the various scams. Until now, the government hasn't demonstrated seriousness about taking the right action on graft. In fact, it denies the scams even occurred. Liberalization is not only about better economic policies, but also about better moral values. Widespread corruption will hurt us much more than a few stores of Wal-Mart ever will. So if we have to debate forever, let us at least do it on the right issues. FDI and Wal-Mart, welcome to India!
 
Prove it with references.

Visit in Reliance Mart store and try to find out how many items are not Made in India.

At present 70% of their sourcing is Made in India which consequently help the Manufacturing industry of India.

But It won't be case with foreign retail chain.

Am a little curious about sources.

Indians still get majority of produce from any cheap source, China or where ever and there is no regulation to stop them. Atleast 30% rule is there now to protect the interest.

You seriously think Indian companies are so ethical that that they will be so committed to India?
 
These stores are coming in cities. In cities now a days everybody owns a car or two wheeler. So it's not a big deal for consumer to visit these stores.

At present people are buying from local store as well as Indian retail chain like Big Bajar and Reliance mart equally because there is not much price difference between two. But It won't be case when foreign retail chain will enter into the retail market as their whole modus operandi is totally different.

Indeed no one go to buy a bottle of coke, or a pinch of salt to these big stores but Is it possible to survive for these local store by just sailing a bottle of coke, or a pinch of salt?? No It's not, If consumer can save substantial amount then they will definitely visit the big stores and that's the point of contention. Here we generating the employment by killing the employment of others. In all other sector where FDI allowed is not the same case.

And Govt without addressing the concern of this large section just singing on the tune of foreign masters.

you have answered your own question. If you read my very first post, the letter it says no one will go to buy a bottle of coke, or a pinch of salt to these big stores. They are meant for bulk sales and considering Indians lack cars to some extent will be the reason why these stores will survive too.

The appetite is different, thus room for everyone.
 
Back
Top