Bhai TOI mein to na hai editor? Faltoo ki post ke saath bhadakti hui photo lagane ka andaaz to waise hi laga. Baaki, photo ke saath yeh line bhi bahut "attractive aur interesting" thi- Legalisation of prostitution promotes illegal prostitution. Nice!
Should Prostitution be Legalised?
- Thread starter akshaymalik84
- Start date
Bhai TOI mein to na hai editor? Faltoo ki post ke saath bhadakti hui photo lagane ka andaaz to waise hi laga. Baaki, photo ke saath yeh line bhi bahut "attractive aur interesting" thi- Legalisation of prostitution promotes illegal prostitution. Nice!
akshaymalik84
Active member
Legalisation is not about promoting Prostitution by any mean. Its about controlling it and taking women out of it who dont want to do it. Making their social and economical condition better. Legalisation does not mean that a prostitute will open its office in your neighbourhood and spoil Indian culture(which is touching its new lows everyday and night anyway). A cultured man always know that equality is ethical. As far as i understand culture is all about equal development of human being on all fronts regardless of cast and gender. But where is the equality when one expects one class of society to prosper while the other to distress.
Those girls who do it by choice will do it whether you legalise it or not. But legalisation can certainly help forced women. Yes, there could be some negetive effects of legalisation considering imbalance in our society and system. Per Mare piche e swarg dikhya kare.
Last edited:
singhabhimanyu
New member
rajkphogat
Banned
Filmi batey hain Anjoo,
Aaj ki date aadmi ke apney liye time nahi hai to wo doosro k barey me kya aur kaise jaanega??
& here what u want 2 say that An sex worker is born to b n sex worker & she can't left this profession so she shuld not try.
Asli baat ye hai ki 8 ghantey sir pe topri dhon me hanga laggey and this giv easy money.
Last edited:
rajkphogat
Banned
Aki tell me a thing how legalisation help women to get out of this now dont tell me It will give recongnition to them "padh padh k thak chuka hoon" Istey nyara koye reason ho te samjhiye.
akshaymalik84
Active member
First understand the meaning of legalisation. It should be, to criminalizes the buying of sex and decriminalizes the selling of sex. There would be certain guidlines to discourage forced prostitution. And most of the women in this profession are forced one not volunteer.
Aaj kii date mein bhi kuch "aadmiyon" ke paas time hai doosro ke baare mein sochne ka.....aur phir apni jaankari ko auro mein phelane ka......
Whether it is easy money or not, that's for that woman to decide as she is the one "living" that life.
Please refer to my posts again to see what I have written.
Thanks
Whether it is easy money or not, that's for that woman to decide as she is the one "living" that life.
Please refer to my posts again to see what I have written.
Thanks
upendersingh
New member
Na bhai Kapil, TOI mein na hoon. "Leaglization of prostitution promots illegal prostitution" ka matlab yo tha ki issmein 14-15 saal ki ladkiyon ko bhi dhakel diya jayega unhe jyada umar ki dikhakar aur gharo ke aas-paas, paarko vagarah mein bhi prostitutes clients set karti nazar aayengi jo filhaal nazar nahi aati hai. Prostitution ke legalization ka yo matlab naa hai ki innke liye kuchh kayde-kanoon rah hi nahi jayenge.
Don't talk from your imagination. Legalization doesn't mean that it becomes a free for all. Take the precedent of any law in any country on this subject. Part of making the law is to protect the minors that are forced into it. And to clearly restrict the areas of operations.
upendersingh
New member
Actually my 'imagination' has logics and only logics can prove it a false imagination. You are talking about the countries where you are in these days, but I am talking about the country I am in. Residential areas are not for selling liquors, but in Delhi it is common in each nook and corner. I couldn't get the link but in cricket world cup 2003 in South Africa, there were the herds of prostitutes around stadiums seeking for the clients. Such scenes don't give a good impression of any country. In India leaglization of prostitution will mean much more than the law book.
And you just picked up a single word there 'illegal' from my earlier post, but why didn't you pick up these points;
-Legalization of prostitution doesn't control the sex industry. It expands it.
-Legaliztion of prostitution increases the demand for prostitution. It boosts the motivation of men to buy women for sex in a much wider and more permissible range of socially acceptable settings.
What answers do you have for these points?
Your answers will just be logicless, because you just want to see India follow the western mode of life. Nothing else.
You yourself are countering your arguments. What you are saying is that even now when it is banned the solicitation happens. Legalization does not meant that it will be allowed in open places like Parks etc. That would still be illegal as it is now.
Do you think there are no prostitutes in India. Here are the nos and I quote
"In 2007, the Ministry of Women and Child Development reported presence of 2.8 million sex workers in India, with 35.47 percent of them entering the trade before the age of 18 years [1][2]. The number of prostitutes has also doubled in the recent decade [3]."
This is from http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prostitution_in_India.
And you think 2.8 million is a small no?? It is more than the population of several countries on this planet. Also 35% of these are under 18.
If legalized, then atlease govt can regulate it better. NGO's can be more helpful, there could be better education for their kids, their health etc. That;s what SC is trying to convey - Either you control it or legalize it. If there are more than a million under age gals in this then that does mean something - It is going on with the help of Police, Mafia nexus.
I dont think SC is happy in recommending legalization but that seems to be out of the frustration in law machinery.
I dont think your thinking that it is going to create a demand for prostitution. Sex is already available everywhere. It is there in terms of ads for massages, in red light areas, in escort services etc. Anyone who need it just have to spend 5-10 mins looking for it whether in news papers or on Internet. Those who are not that tech savvy or paper readers can go to red light areas like GB road in Delhi.
Do you think there are no prostitutes in India. Here are the nos and I quote
"In 2007, the Ministry of Women and Child Development reported presence of 2.8 million sex workers in India, with 35.47 percent of them entering the trade before the age of 18 years [1][2]. The number of prostitutes has also doubled in the recent decade [3]."
This is from http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prostitution_in_India.
And you think 2.8 million is a small no?? It is more than the population of several countries on this planet. Also 35% of these are under 18.
If legalized, then atlease govt can regulate it better. NGO's can be more helpful, there could be better education for their kids, their health etc. That;s what SC is trying to convey - Either you control it or legalize it. If there are more than a million under age gals in this then that does mean something - It is going on with the help of Police, Mafia nexus.
I dont think SC is happy in recommending legalization but that seems to be out of the frustration in law machinery.
I dont think your thinking that it is going to create a demand for prostitution. Sex is already available everywhere. It is there in terms of ads for massages, in red light areas, in escort services etc. Anyone who need it just have to spend 5-10 mins looking for it whether in news papers or on Internet. Those who are not that tech savvy or paper readers can go to red light areas like GB road in Delhi.
upendersingh
New member
It is illegal then so much prostitutes are in India. If it is legalized, then it can be only imagined what will happen.
Some years back when lottery was allowed in Delhi there are lot of lottery buffs in Delhi, losing their hard earned money on mostly occasions, but when it is banned now there can hardly be found any lottery players.
Government should take some very stern steps to control prostitution. Discourage it, don't encourage.
And my friend some people still hesitate to go to the prostitutes because there may be a danger of police, even on GB road too. If some of your friends has experience of there he will tell you that there is always a fear of police raid, as I have heard.
Some years back when lottery was allowed in Delhi there are lot of lottery buffs in Delhi, losing their hard earned money on mostly occasions, but when it is banned now there can hardly be found any lottery players.
Government should take some very stern steps to control prostitution. Discourage it, don't encourage.
And my friend some people still hesitate to go to the prostitutes because there may be a danger of police, even on GB road too. If some of your friends has experience of there he will tell you that there is always a fear of police raid, as I have heard.
Last edited:
rajkphogat
Banned
Last edited:
rajkphogat
Banned
Aki Bhai yo sweden na se
Like Indian culture can't b adopted by any other country same way this type of things don't work in India because of social difference between two countries.
Hum Purab Hai Wo paschim hain Dono ka mel na milta hai
Ugta hai jo suraj Purab se Paschim me jake Dhalta hai.
:rock:rock:rock
rajkphogat
Banned
Simple Points to be consider...............
Some of my freinds are of opinion that :
Legalisation will give recognition to sex workers
What Recognisition means here : 1. They will b stamped as an prostitutes, seperate areas for them where no good person wants to go, like heep of dump outside the city, Same is already there but how will it help them ????
No underage girl will push into this.
This is an debatable issue No one can say this for sure. how can we say after legalisation nexus between Mafia pimps etc. and Police will break ????????
Sex workers will get more money & saved from harrasment from police.
In today's date every business hav to pay bribe to govt babus & Police, If u are in Producton u hav to pay bribe to excise deptt to get ur material out of factory, if in sales you hav to bribe sales tax tax deptt to file ur return, & aall hav to pay bribe to PF, ESI deptt to take their blesses, Even rikshaw walas, poor road vendors(rehdi waley) in markets hav to bribe policemens. In that scenario of legal buiseness how can we say prostitutes will b saved from Harrasmnt from police????????
Surely they get more money as they will include taxes paid to govt., in charges for their services.
Some of my freinds are of opinion that :
Legalisation will give recognition to sex workers
What Recognisition means here : 1. They will b stamped as an prostitutes, seperate areas for them where no good person wants to go, like heep of dump outside the city, Same is already there but how will it help them ????
No underage girl will push into this.
This is an debatable issue No one can say this for sure. how can we say after legalisation nexus between Mafia pimps etc. and Police will break ????????
Sex workers will get more money & saved from harrasment from police.
In today's date every business hav to pay bribe to govt babus & Police, If u are in Producton u hav to pay bribe to excise deptt to get ur material out of factory, if in sales you hav to bribe sales tax tax deptt to file ur return, & aall hav to pay bribe to PF, ESI deptt to take their blesses, Even rikshaw walas, poor road vendors(rehdi waley) in markets hav to bribe policemens. In that scenario of legal buiseness how can we say prostitutes will b saved from Harrasmnt from police????????
Surely they get more money as they will include taxes paid to govt., in charges for their services.
The need is to view it in different light. The thing is that those who are already in the profession can have better lives with legalization. The escort girls or the high end call gals are anyway not getting impacted by this. It is for the upliftment of those who are in poor conditions in the red light areas.
If you take the example of Lottery then I remember it still being legal in several states and I dont think there is such a hue and cry on that. Going by this logic even liquor should be banned. Ban is not an answer to everything. The prostitution problem is everywhere in the world and there are only a few countries which have this legalized. Take for instance USA, there it is illegal but still they are available easily as in our country. The difference being that they are all kind of call girls / escorts and not exploited by police /mafia. They thrive because law agencies dont that resources to go after them. They spend them in other crimes that people are concerned most. Same is the case in our country. You think policing can eradicate them? No, police dont have even time to solve more serious crimes like theft, how can they take the load of these immoral activity cases? On the other hand they collect big money from these brothel owners and pimps which is easier then raiding them and collecting the evidence / witnesses.
If you take the example of Lottery then I remember it still being legal in several states and I dont think there is such a hue and cry on that. Going by this logic even liquor should be banned. Ban is not an answer to everything. The prostitution problem is everywhere in the world and there are only a few countries which have this legalized. Take for instance USA, there it is illegal but still they are available easily as in our country. The difference being that they are all kind of call girls / escorts and not exploited by police /mafia. They thrive because law agencies dont that resources to go after them. They spend them in other crimes that people are concerned most. Same is the case in our country. You think policing can eradicate them? No, police dont have even time to solve more serious crimes like theft, how can they take the load of these immoral activity cases? On the other hand they collect big money from these brothel owners and pimps which is easier then raiding them and collecting the evidence / witnesses.
rajkphogat
Banned
Nahi-2 point samaj me nahi aaya anjoo wo to aise hi likh diya tha
Your most welcome Madam
anjoo No.- 96 padh
Last edited:
rajkphogat
Banned
Fer te chori chakari bhi legal kar deni chahiye police ka kaam aur kam hojaga
Bhai yo amrica na se tham kyoo hod karo so
Matlab we reh us dhandey me bus unhe thoda aaram mil jaye.
jakharanil
New member
Prostitution Legalised krne ke essa kya rhe ga jo ilegal bachega... some says ki mugal saasan me ye legal tha....
but now time changing>>> our ethics n culture not allows it....
sab @ kuch ganda h par DHANDA h YEeeeeeee
but now time changing>>> our ethics n culture not allows it....
sab @ kuch ganda h par DHANDA h YEeeeeeee