S
- Status
Please be specific 'what is not clear', question or the explanation? I have rephrased the question so it should be clear now. If explanation is not clear then you can spend some time and workout the possible scenario for the yes and no answers for the question that I have given.
If still not clear then have a look at the easier version of the same puzzle at
http://www.jatland.com/forums/showthread.php?t=11684 (as mentioned by Vijay earlier). The difference in your puzzle and Vijay's puzzle is that in Vijay's puzzle there are two people, one of them will lie and other will say truth.
Even after all this if it still not clear then mail me I will try to explain.
If still not clear then have a look at the easier version of the same puzzle at
http://www.jatland.com/forums/showthread.php?t=11684 (as mentioned by Vijay earlier). The difference in your puzzle and Vijay's puzzle is that in Vijay's puzzle there are two people, one of them will lie and other will say truth.
Even after all this if it still not clear then mail me I will try to explain.
Last edited:
Boss juss write ur ans... i mean question to be asked to the fruit seller.. dont give explanation ... still i cudn get what question u gonna ask that guy
I don't know how you have come to the conclusion that my answer is wrong if you have not understood it in first place.
Nope man still its not clear
Isn't anybody who read my previous post will know what is the question that needs to be asked to the fruit vendor? Try again and atleast read the letters in Bold.
Dev I doubt whether you have read any of my post. Because question that needs to be asked to the fruit vendor is mentioned in the first line it self. Now for your understanding I had also rephrased in my second post. Still you didn't get it. Then I wrote another post to explain it to you. But still no use. Please reread the posts may be you will get it right this time. Still if you don't get it then call me at 9845123042(its banglaore no so should be local for you) I will try to explain it.
Last edited:
jatriski99
New member
ladies and gentleman
well,
mere pass ek bahut mast answer hai, why u guys r wasting ur time in thinking.
there r two ways, right
ummmm.........
out of two ......okay... lets do head n tail.....
I do most of the time.
okyay yaar ............just chill.
praggya
Naughty guys are more creative and innovative. So, what do u say abt the solution. Show the naughtyness on that, dudeeeeeeeee
well,
mere pass ek bahut mast answer hai, why u guys r wasting ur time in thinking.
there r two ways, right
ummmm.........
out of two ......okay... lets do head n tail.....
I do most of the time.
okyay yaar ............just chill.
praggya
mukeshkumar007
Active member
Areee Kisi ne sanjeet mile to bataiyoo dekhe ek baar 
sanjeetsparp
New member
Areee Kisi ne sanjeet mile to bataiyoo dekhe ek baar
Haan agya beta ke kahwe tha .......................
manne bul ke kit bhaj gya ............ kade gaya .. saachi e james bong hai ....
Last edited:
mukeshkumar007
Active member
Haan agya beta ke kahwe tha .......................
kyo duki karrya ho janta ne.. bata do answer kite din hoge kati rolla macha rakhya hai..
chaapi hai puzzle... chakari chada rakhya hai sabne 3 din se sanjeetsparp
New member
kyo duki karrya ho janta ne.. bata do answer kite din hoge kati rolla macha rakhya hai..
Are main kit te betaaoon main logaan ka dimaag na lagwata ..... yo sanjeev dukhi ker reha hai ..... na answer betata ..... na hint batata ....... re kasaaai na batana te kam te kam 4 option te dede answer ke ..............
S
sanjeevtarar
Guest
le bhai sanjeet isse k baat ha ....
Hint : Mixture of positive and negative Question.
Hint : Mixture of positive and negative Question.
My answer is also based on +ve and -ve. It may not match word to word to the answer that you may have but core should be the same. May be you should reread my answer. If its wrong then tell me why its wrong.
Last edited:
jitendershooda
New member
Phogat bhai saab ... aap aale ne padhun tha mein ... sir mein khaj si hogi ... issa jib hoya kare jib chess mein haran ne hon er kime na soojhta ho ... ha ha ...
par bhai jo vijay aala thread tha ne usmein to we darban pakkam pakka ya to jhoot bole they er ya sach ... er hade aapne jo batai ... usmein us fruit aale ka nue to na bera ek wo sachi bole se ek jhoot ... baki ... himmat si karke kal pher kollam-kolla hona padega aapke explaination gail ... hope I may understand ... ho sake hai aap theek hon ... par madi samjhan mein jaddojehad ho rahi hai ...
Katti ghani saachi likh gya Jitender bhai ... mein bhi bass kemme issa hi likhhan aala tha
A simpler answer..
Ask the fruit vendor this question “ IF I would have asked you the question that ‘does the left road goes to Delhi’, then in your current state of mind(about saying truth or lying) would you have said YES”
If the fruit vendor says “YES” then the left road goes to Delhi irrespective of whether he is lying or not.
If the fruit vendor says “NO” then the right road goes to Delhi irrespective of whether he is lying or not.
Ask the fruit vendor this question “ IF I would have asked you the question that ‘does the left road goes to Delhi’, then in your current state of mind(about saying truth or lying) would you have said YES”
If the fruit vendor says “YES” then the left road goes to Delhi irrespective of whether he is lying or not.
If the fruit vendor says “NO” then the right road goes to Delhi irrespective of whether he is lying or not.
S
sanjeevtarar
Guest
Why you are not considering the truth or lie of fruit-seller....??
I have considered the truth or lie of the fruit vendor.
The question has two parts and fruit vendor and has to show consistency in answering both as he has to answer both using his current state of mind (for telling tie or truth). (This is the case if fruit vendor is simply telling truth or lie and not trying to trick you; which I have assumed is true otherwise I think it is impossible to get the way using a single question.)
If he is saying truth then +ve and +ve for two parts will result in +ve.
If he is lying then -ve and -ve for two parts will result +ve.
This way we have made the final answer independent of whether fruit vendor is telling truth or lie.
S
sanjeevtarar
Guest
Vikram i just got your point. but can you explain one more thing :
If he is saying truth then +ve and +ve for two parts will result in +ve.
If he is lying then -ve and -ve for two parts will result +ve.
Here when he is saying truth then both question will become in +ve state and if he speaks lie then both question will become in -ve state.....??
Bhai eb yo explain karna kasoota kham sia. Kudh tai dekh le to bhadeya rehga yaar.
Chal mie ‘C’ style maie answer daen kie try karo so
If (left road goes to delhi == yes)
{
If( current sate of mind == truth)
{
Else /* ( current sate of mind == Lie)*/
{
/* So irrespective of state of mind, answer is always ‘Yes’ if the left road does go to delhi */
}{
Answer for first part (‘does the left road goes to Delhi’) = yes;
Final answer = yes; /*As state is truth so answer for first part and second part will be same */
}Final answer = yes; /*As state is truth so answer for first part and second part will be same */
Else /* ( current sate of mind == Lie)*/
{
Answer for first part (‘does the left road goes to Delhi’) = no; /*as state == lie */
Final answer = yes; /*As state is lie so the answer for second part will be inverse of answer for the first part. He can not say ‘no’ because in that case final answer is true i.e. he agrees that he would have said ‘no’ for the question ‘does the left road goes to Delhi’ which is contradictory to his state of mind which is of saying lie */
}Final answer = yes; /*As state is lie so the answer for second part will be inverse of answer for the first part. He can not say ‘no’ because in that case final answer is true i.e. he agrees that he would have said ‘no’ for the question ‘does the left road goes to Delhi’ which is contradictory to his state of mind which is of saying lie */
/* So irrespective of state of mind, answer is always ‘Yes’ if the left road does go to delhi */
Else /*(left road goes to delhi == no)*/
{
If( current sate of mind == truth)
{
Else /* ( current sate of mind == Lie)*/
{
{
Answer for first part (‘does the left road goes to Delhi’) = no;
Final answer = no; /*as state is truth so answer for first part and second part will be same */
}Final answer = no; /*as state is truth so answer for first part and second part will be same */
Else /* ( current sate of mind == Lie)*/
{
Answer for first part (‘does the left road goes to Delhi’) = yes; /*as state == lie*/
Final answer = no; /*As state is lie so answer for second part will be inverse of answer for the first part. He can not say ‘yes’ because in that case final answer is true i.e. he agrees that he would have said ‘yes’ for the question ‘does the left road goes to Delhi’ which is contradictory to his state of mind which is of saying lie.
Final answer = no; /*As state is lie so answer for second part will be inverse of answer for the first part. He can not say ‘yes’ because in that case final answer is true i.e. he agrees that he would have said ‘yes’ for the question ‘does the left road goes to Delhi’ which is contradictory to his state of mind which is of saying lie.
}
// So irrespective of state of mind, answer is always ‘No’ if the left road does no go to delhi
}// So irrespective of state of mind, answer is always ‘No’ if the left road does no go to delhi
Please forgive me, I can not give any simpler explanation L.
- Status