unsc permanet seat

Status
Not open for further replies.
Dear Tavathia sahab,

I am really keen to carry this debate forward. Before I post my views any further, I would really appreciate if you can mention the name of a country or countries with whom the comparasion would be meaningful..Which ever countries you decide to take, let us keep 1947 as the sarting year..

Regards
Rajendra
 
Dear Anil,
I do agree with you, that we can't help ourselves no one else can. The question is how do we help ourselves. Whereas we would like to do so many things in our life, some times we are not able to do because of some compulsions. These compulsions become promienent as the organization grows. In our own life, we are the decision makers and yet at times we either take too long or some times even don't make decisions. Imagine how difficult it would be at the level where your one decision may cause so much to so many. And on top of that one might lose his/her job to the point of no return.

However, we really need to think deeply as to how to overcome these difficulties, for which I think a separate discussion would be more appropriate.




anil chaudhary (Sep 27, 2004 08:24 a.m.):
Col sahab, whatever u say is right. It may be our compulsion or policy, but to the world these are just excuses. Till we overcome these, the power that will decide the unsc seat will not take us seriously. To have a realistic shot at the permanent seat we have to change the perception of India to the world and bring our system to the top std. If we cannot help ourselves how can others be confident that we can take up issues of the other weaker countries.
 
Dear Rajendra Ji,

It looks to me that you are taking the discussion personally. I don't think that is the case. It would be very difficult to lay down similarities among various countries for the purpose of development.

If you really want to carry out the comparision, the only country that had the closest similarities with us in 1947 is Pakistan. I think we all know that we have done much better than them in last 57 years that we have been independent. I personally, feel that disucssion on development and political system in our country could go on a different thread.

I have given my views on the subject. Every one on site need not be in agreement with me and that is perfectly fair.

Rajendra Kumar Kalkhunde (Sep 27, 2004 08:30 a.m.):
Dear Tavathia sahab,

I am really keen to carry this debate forward. Before I post my views any further, I would really appreciate if you can mention the name of a country or countries with whom the comparasion would be meaningful..Which ever countries you decide to take, let us keep 1947 as the sarting year..

Regards
Rajendra
 
Col Virendra S Tavathia(Retd) (Sep 27, 2004 09:14 a.m.):
Dear Rajendra Ji,

It looks to me that you are taking the discussion personally. I don't think that is the case. It would be very difficult to lay down similarities among various countries for the purpose of development.

If you really want to carry out the comparision, the only country that had the closest similarities with us in 1947 is Pakistan. I think we all know that we have done much better than them in last 57 years that we have been independent. I personally, feel that disucssion on development and political system in our country could go on a different thread.

I have given my views on the subject. Every one on site need not be in agreement with me and that is perfectly fair.

Rajendra Kumar Kalkhunde (Sep 27, 2004 08:30 a.m.):
Dear Tavathia sahab,

I am really keen to carry this debate forward. Before I post my views any further, I would really appreciate if you can mention the name of a country or countries with whom the comparasion would be meaningful..Which ever countries you decide to take, let us keep 1947 as the sarting year..

Regards
Rajendra

Hhahaa...Ji Nahi..never personally. I still feel that Our leaders have fallen much shorter than what they should have been for the faith public posed in them...In my view the only country in the world we should compare is China, more so if this has to be next door neighbour only.

Regards
Rajendra
 
Some thoughts on Indian education system:
The Indian education system is good at teaching history. What they lack is encouragement for inovation and thinking outside the sylabus. The system makes Indian students very disciplined and hard working. When they go to foriegn univ. they have an edge bcos of this and that Indian family gives academic excellence 1st priority in life. US education system teaches us to think and create something new. They have ecellent resources to support it. If u fail u get a 2nd chance. With solid fundamentals and this new mindset Indians are able to propel further than others. This probabily is the reason why Indians do better in US than in India later in life. Its not to say that we follow the west completely, bcos there are things in western education system that sucks (like no discipline--they call it freedom of choice).
The same is true abt other things in India. We are seeing a few changes but still have a long road to travel before we can be equal partners in world power game.
We should be comparing ourselves other countries who are trying for a UNSC seat.
Japan, Germany and Australia has a more realistic shot at UNSC than India or Brazil.
The world will not give us a seat bcos we have the best sob story to tell.
 
I think we all agree to one point:
India should have a UNSC permanent seat or if technically not possible should be equally powerfull as the current members.

Now, the Qs is: do we have a realistic shot at it now or do we need to do a lot more before we are considered a serious contender ?
What we as an individual and collectively as memebers of this forum can do to take India nearer to that goal (other than signing petitions) ?
 
Rajendra ji,

I am rather disappointed by your views. your views seem more emotional and rhetorical. Indeed the state of affairs in India is in pretty bad shape but the picture is not as bad as u paint it to be.

Education: India has 7 IITS, DCE, DIT, BITS, 25 NITs, TIFR, IISc, 6 IIMs. These are comparable to the world's best. ofcourse I am only talking about standard of education and not about luxuries. And what makes u say that they left with great universities..where did u get all that from..they made a mess of everything..

China War: The defeat in that was a result of unclear political will and ill conceived strategy...I agree with you..but let us not beat each other over the head with it..it was 40 yrs ago.

China prosperity: Their growth is fuelled by a "infinite" supply of cheap man power. They didnt do any mircale. The initiated reforms 10-15 yrs ahead of india. India is catching up.
Wait for another 10 yrs. Atleast we have democracy. Atleast we are not treated like an immigrant in our own country. India still has higher salaries than China in services sector. India had more RnD Centers than China. We will take the dragon by its tail..!!

Singapore vs banglore. Pls compare apples with apples.

South Korea. Good example..they are enjoying the fruits of sustained capitalism and american support.

Indian doctrine of no first attack. Tell me why, India with a growth rate of 7-8%, stable political environment, would sabotage its growth prospects, dent its reserves by getting into an armed conflict with the terrorist neighbour. Military is an instrument of diplomatic policy which should be used as the last resort. This is what exactly was done by previous government. Though they lacked vision and clear diplomatic goal but they did exert ample amount of pressure on pakistan. Even military superpower US is fighting against terrorism. The difference is that it is doing it far away from its borders. India cannot risk a conflict with a nuclear armed terrorist rogue state in its neighbourhood.

Rajendra Kumar Kalkhunde (Sep 26, 2004 05:46 a.m.):
Dear Tavathia Sahab,

I know the topic under discussion is highly a matter of indidual perception and views can be highly diversified. My personal belief is that Indian leaders have always fallen short of the faith public has posed in them. Public got divided in supporting them only when they failed even after getting huge majority. I wish to pose few questions which will clarify where we were and where we are as far as our share in world economy and education etc has changed with time.

1. British left some great universities in India. Have we been able to maintain their standards ? Is it not the people like Murli Manohar Joshi and Sahab Singh Verma who came from university backgrounds and are responsible for the state of affairs of our education system?

2. With his Hindi Chini bhai Bhai policy, Nehru apparantly was very close to Chinese leadership? Will any one excuse him for the humilating defeat India got because of intelligence failure ?

3. China was much poorer than India if one take 1947 as the starting year. Rest is a matter of public knowledge where China stands and where we stand..Didn't public give all the support of Indian leaders during the period when china was marching ahead of us on almost daily basis? China compted and got permanent membership of the UN security council.

4. First Singapore PM visited Bangalore in late fifties and was so impressed that he wanted Singapore to be like Bangalore..We all know where Singapore is today and where Bangalore is in relative terms..

5. South Corea was no where near India just 50 years back..now they are a larger economy than India

Somehow we Indians have developed the habit of being happy comparing ourselves with countries in Africa and Muslim world...To me its the leader who is responsible for where we are. Public is same almost all over the world...They follow anyone who promises them better future..

Indian doctrine of no first attack is again because of our weakness and not because of any maturity or international standing. Pakistan has been bleeding us in Kashmir everyday and we are talking of no first use...this is sheer hypocracy..Fact of the matter is that we are not sure if we will ever be able to win the next war and how long our amunition supply will last without paying high price....Whole India was behind Atal bihari when we massed our troops last time on boarder...Under international pressure he developed cold feet...In last 1000 years have we ever been able to convince the muslim invadors of peaceful coexistense??? Have our atom bombs been able to deter the terrorists in Kashmir?

Rajendra
 
I dont think we are discussing here if we are better than pakistan or 100 other countries. What the focus should be are we as good as the current 5 unsc permanent members? Does the top 5 think of us as equal?
On a political front, getting UNSC seat may be difficult bcos of China. China will never accept a next door neigbour, a rival and competitor to be sitting on UNSC seat as equal. Though India helped China get into UN and WTO, China will not make the mistake of pulling up India.
 
Mandeep Bamal (Sep 27, 2004 11:09 a.m.):

Education: India has 7 IITS, DCE, DIT, BITS, 25 NITs, TIFR, IISc, 6 IIMs. These are comparable to the world's best. ofcourse I am only talking about standard of education and not about luxuries. And what makes u say that they left with great universities..where did u get all that from..they made a mess of everything..

Answer: Please read my post. I talk of Universities and you talk of everythingelse other than universities..Universities are the backbone of education and not the institutions mentioned by you..Just google and find out the ratings of Indian Universties, subjest wise..You will know where we stand..Name me one Indian university if it figures in the world merit list..

China War: The defeat in that was a result of unclear political will and ill conceived strategy...I agree with you..but let us not beat each other over the head with it..it was 40 yrs ago.

Answer: Its not beating each other at all. Its purely a case study and there is no way India can walk away without being compared with China.

China prosperity: Their growth is fuelled by a "infinite" supply of cheap man power. They didnt do any mircale. The initiated reforms 10-15 yrs ahead of india. India is catching up.
Wait for another 10 yrs. Atleast we have democracy. Atleast we are not treated like an immigrant in our own country. India still has higher salaries than China in services sector. India had more RnD Centers than China. We will take the dragon by its tail..!!

Answer: Please take this out of mind that I am trying to downplay our achievements. However, I can not be blind to naked truths..If their numbers are infinite, we are not lagging far behind in cheap labour. You might say that you are not treated like immigrants in your own country, but truth is not so..Tell me if Indian states accept people from other states in their services? if not, then is that not like immigration restriction of a sort?

Singapore vs banglore. Pls compare apples with apples.

Answer: City verses city is very much apple for apple...All major US, canadian or Japanese cities would compare with Singapore for that matter...Mind you Singapore was also a British colony like we were...

South Korea. Good example..they are enjoying the fruits of sustained capitalism and american support.

Answer: If they are enjoying, then what stops us??

Indian doctrine of no first attack. Tell me why, India with a growth rate of 7-8%, stable political environment, would sabotage its growth prospects, dent its reserves by getting into an armed conflict with the terrorist neighbour. Military is an instrument of diplomatic policy which should be used as the last resort. This is what exactly was done by previous government. Though they lacked vision and clear diplomatic goal but they did exert ample amount of pressure on pakistan. Even military superpower US is fighting against terrorism. The difference is that it is doing it far away from its borders. India cannot risk a conflict with a nuclear armed terrorist rogue state in its neighbourhood.

Answer: No comments as its a matter of one's perception. We all are bound to have differing views on such issues...

Rajendra Kumar Kalkhunde (Sep 26, 2004 05:46 a.m.):
 
Dear Anil,

The comparision to Pakistan was only because Shri Rajendra Singh ji asked for it. I agree with you about the focus we need to make. The fact that China accepts us as a threat itslef speaks of the progress the country has made during past few decades. I am not saying that we have achieved perfection. We still have a long way to go, but at the same time we can't discount the progress the country has made thus far. It might have been painfully slow, but atleast it is steady and most importantly is in a democratic society. Probably if we had better law enforcement system, and an efficient Judicial system (deciding cases fast), then we would have had less corruption than what we have today. A little regulated political system (considering the level and percentage of education among our majority population) would have given us the opportunity to elect the best to the top jobs.

Now about the UN. Essentially, apart from the majority support to pass a resolution, UN needs, money and manpower to implement its policies. While we may not be contributing financially, we definitely have the human resources, more than most countries. Further our armed forces have been rated one of the best in UN and they have actually done very well in almost all the peace keeping missions that they had been employed. This is the factor that needs to be played at diplomatic level to get us a permanent seat. How best our diplomats can do that only future will tell us. Be assured, there is going to be a lot of lobbying and power play, but that is part of the international politics.

All countries will be looking for their own interests and we have to accept this reality. At this time we can only wait and watch.

Regardless what China and Pakistan or for that matter Islamic countries do, we need to make our case and lobby for majority support. May be Russia and France could be a good partner based on the stand our Govt had taken for our participation in Iraq.

anil chaudhary (Sep 27, 2004 11:48 a.m.):
I dont think we are discussing here if we are better than pakistan or 100 other countries. What the focus should be are we as good as the current 5 unsc permanent members? Does the top 5 think of us as equal?
On a political front, getting UNSC seat may be difficult bcos of China. China will never accept a next door neigbour, a rival and competitor to be sitting on UNSC seat as equal. Though India helped China get into UN and WTO, China will not make the mistake of pulling up India.
 
Dear All,

Sorry for being away for a while!!! Gaam gaya hua tha.

The first question, and the most important one at that is, as to why should India be made a permanent member (PM) of UNSC? This question is more important than whether India, with its size, population, vision for 2020, chaos, communal harmony/disharmony etc etc deserves to be made a PM of UNSC. Like always I look at the whole thing differently.

I am not at all impressed by the 'Military Might' of the Indian Nation. What use is this so called might when India can't even keep its small neighbours 'In Line'? Thank God we fought with China in 1962 and not in 2002. And also thank the British for leaving behind a highly regimented Army, an Army that had the inner resolve to do whatever it has done so far. I am not very hopeful about the future though. Why? This is another topic altogether and should not get mixed up with the present thread. What military might are we talking about when our Defence Minister on an official visit is strip searched in USA. Brazil has more B**** and it treats visiting US Citizens in exactly the same manner as Brazilians are treated on US airports.

A word about 1971 war and the impression that it was started by Pakistan. Please go through the book 'White House Years' by Kissinger and various discussion records of UN and you will get the answer. Mrs Gandhi, and rightly so, was bent upon dismembering Pakistan. Though her long term vision was mixed up and now we have two Pakistans to trouble us, one of them is called Bangladesh though.

My view is that till the world considers India a strong nation we will not be given the PM of UNSC. I am afraid even small African countries, that used to stand behind India in all international forums, today don't consider India as a nation that matters. And we ditched the Palestinians long time back.

My view is that Non Aligned Movement should be revived and let the proud nations of Asia, Africa and South Amarica come together, withdraw from UN, form their own organisation and solve issues themselves. It is only then the proud people of countries like Brazil, Indonesia, Argentina, Egypt, India, South Africa and China will have a say in world affairs. And as long as that happens we would remain a nation that supplies cheap labor or produces stuff at a much cheaper rate than the West. Basically slaves, but with a different name.

Do I see any hope? I want to say yes, trying really hard to say YES, but can't. Not with the kind of politicians we have today. A vicious circle really. And I see no light at the end of the tunnel. And even if I see some light, it is the speeding train coming from the other end...

Regards,

JS Malik
 
Dear All,

I am personally, for the UN to continue. Having a separate International Organization as a substitute of UN may not be in the best interest of the world community or for that matter our own nation. It sounds to me some thing that happens in our country almost every day, i.e. if I am not made a minister, I will form another party and we call them "Like minded parties".

We need a forum to air our views in world, and for that NAM and SAARC are enough. We are also member of Commonwealth. We have EU for Europeon countries but these organizations are not substitute for UN.

I had said earlier, that it was good that we were attacked in 1962 by China otherwise we would not have been militarily as stronger as we had been since then. Being happy or unhappy from our own military strength is an individual perception. It is a relative term and has to be seen in that context.

As far as origin of 1971 war is concerned, people have different views on it. I would rather believe our own leaders than Dr. Henry Kissinger. This may be called blindly following /towing a line of our own leaders, but that is fine. We as a nation needs to remain united on international issues.

The fact is that India is considered the best place to find service industry. We can call it brain bank or cheap labor or slaves, that is again our own individual perception. I try to see the bright side of the situation.

I am not saying that every thing is fine and there is no need for improvement. Actually, we have a long way to go to make our strenght felt at international level, but let us not discount what we already have.

I personally feel, we need to address in our country following issues very aggressively and honestly:
Population control.
Education
Corruption
Law Enforcement.

If we can improve in these areas, otherthings will also start improving. The question is how to do that. We need some really practical and simple ideas on these issues.
 
No one salute you until you show that you have the POWER.

Missiles are meant for deployment not for storage – Abdul Kalam.

Huge population can be an asset if you use them as a well planned workforce.
 
Dear Mr, Uday,

You said it absolutely right. That is the way it should be. Remember President only says upto diployment and not the first use. The fear of unknown is much more than the fear of known. The strategic deterrance is more important than actual use of force. I am not saying that we should never use it. The use of force should always be the last means.

Actually an all out war may not be in interest of any country. But we surely should take isolated local punitive actions now and then to keep the adverseries alert, that their actions will be replied adequately. It is at this level we come a little short of National expectations.
 
No one takes our nation seriously. When we ourselves don't take it seriously how does one expect others to do so? I am neither a born pessimist nor blindly optimist, merely a realist.

We are like Delhi Police. 'Security has been tightened'. This is what I have been hearing since last 30 years whenever an incident takes place in Delhi. Delhi police may have tightened security about few thousand times till now and the law and order situation detiorates each hour. I don't know how tight it is now!!!

In the same manner when spineless political leadership declares to the world "Hamari sahan shakti khatam ho rahi hai or hum munh tod jawab dene ke liye taiyar hain" and "Aar par ki ladai" after each terrorist act by Pakistan and do nothing. Kamal hai, aisee APRAMPAR SAHAN SHAKTI BHAGWAN SAB KO DE.

Musharraf says once in six months "we will use our strategic assets, let there be no doubt on that" and the Indian Army under the able guidance of these 'Dhotiwalas' rushes troops to the border to do what Delhi Police has been doing, "Security is further tightened" (And I am not comparing Army to Delhi Police please). What military might!!!

What punitive action have we taken so far against Bangladesh, forget Pakistan? Now the Maoists from Nepal will become a pain in the neck for Uttranchal, UP and Bihar. Our leaders will sleep till there are blasts all over, then rush the Army to yet another front. More funds will be released for 'Tightening Security' and everyone will benefit from the fund inflow and subsequent misuse. But the problem will remain.

Now the UN. Which problem has the UN solved so far? Sending aid, that too selective, to few countries is no achievement. The number of resolutions adopted, passed and 'not implemented' are indicative of its effectiveness. Palestine, Korea, Kashmir (Due to foolishness of Nehru), Cyprus and now Afghanistan, Iraq. Whatever problem has been solved has been done so by NATO for its self interest, because they care two hoots for the UN. Bosnia is an example. The UN is silent on Darfur. Why? Because Uncle SAM is not interested. Simple. Sab log elections tak chup raho. Bush Bhai saheb busy hain.

Which Indian Historian has written records about the wars that we fought? 'War Despatches', a very authentic account of 1965 War by Gen Gurbachan or Gurcharan Singh was banned by the 'enlightened Generalship' and orders were given 'down the line' that it will not form part of formation/unit libraries. For everyones knowledge and infornmation, even official records of 1948 war with Pakistan have not been made public so far.

Baki desh to chal he raha hai. Sab mauj mein hain. Simple sa 'Funda' hai aajkal. Ek jindagi hai, jitna kha sako khao, kama sako kamao (by whatever means), loot sako to looto, after all DESH TO APNA HI HAI.

Asha Ram bapu ki tarah mein bhi baat kar sakta hoon. Sab mangalmaye ho, sukh shanti ho, sundar jiwan, vagera vagera. But what is true is indeed true.

RAM RAM

Reagrds,

JS Malik
 
Dear Col shab, Malik shab, Anilji, & Rajendrji

I don’t know more then all of u. But as far I know India’s bid for Permanent Seat in UNO still strong due to several reasons. That was already explained by Col shab.
Problem is not a special thing for India. Every country has many problems and she is continuo fight with them.
Lack of responsibility and lack of unity is the biggest and major problem with us. We never will unite on national issue as well as international issue. It gives a wrong signal or wrong picture to International community about us. We always abuse to each other. Every person try to prove himself better and big then other. We can criticize the problem but never try to do any thing for find a better solution. For example when the matter of corruption everybody criticizes it that corruption is wrong and says that government machinery or government machinery is corrupted. In all of this we think ourselves as a responsible person. But one thing we forget meanwhile to criticize corruption that we are also include in this evil. We are also responsible to given a major space for it.
So first of all we must need to know our responsibility to country and fulfill to these responsibility on our part. Then I am sure that every problem of our country will automatically remove or improve.
So I think all of these we required an individual revolution. We cannot improve current on the basis of organized revolution. If a person will change then he can improve other person and in this way all society will change.
We cannot get a permanent seat in UNO unless we will not be uniting on International Issue. We have to show our unity on International level. If we will unite no anybody can stop us to get VITO power.
 
Dears all,

Let us not be optimistic about the UNSC seat.
The proposal that Japan, India, Germany and Brazil become permanent members of the United Nations Security Council is almost certain to fail.

As soon as India, Japan, Germany and Brazil presented their joint bid in New York on Sept. 22, asserting "they are legitimate candidates for permanent membership in an expanded Security Council", opposition was immediate. China, South Korea and North Korea objected to Japan's bid. Italy opposed Germany in general and expansion of the veto in particular. Spanish-speaking Mexico, Argentina, and Chile opposed Portuguese-speaking Brazil. Moreover, Egypt, Nigeria, and South Africa each said it should be a permanent member. Other Africans argued for more representation, as did Arabs, Asians, and Latin Americans.

Pakistan, with support from China, opposed India. China will never tolerate a neighbour with equal status in UN and to torpedo India's chance it can always count on Pakistan and other neighbours of India including Nepal repeat Nepal, Bangladesh and Sri Lanka may side with China keeping in view its increasing clout. Anything is possible in politics ? Moreover, hardly any Muslim country would support India's bid as they are definitely under Pakistani influence.

Hence, I am of the view that for the next 10-15 years no positive outcome is expected.

I am also of the view that if at all some changes are to be made, the status of the present permanent members should also be reviewed. England and France are no more the powers they were in 1945 and they should no more be enjoying this status.
 
This whole business of UNSC seat is nothing more than carrot in front of a goat. India should focus on becoming military and economic power at a much faster pace. It won't really matter even if we don't get UNSC seat...If we are powerful, we can always take direct actions without ever bothering about UN..If one wants to become powerful, best way is to prepare to challenge the most powerful....If we are powerful and have the will to act, no force on the Earth can ignore more than 2 billion hands..

Rajendra
 
You are right Rajendraji, without being strong back home, there is no use of being a member of international fora. Without the resolution of domestic problems like infrastructure, poverty etc. permanent membership will be of no use.
 
you are right Rajendrji, i am agree with u. But to stable as a strong nation on International platform UNSC permanent is important.

by the way ur point is too much noticable and appreciable.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top