Mandeep Bamal (Sep 27, 2004 11:09 a.m.):
Education: India has 7 IITS, DCE, DIT, BITS, 25 NITs, TIFR, IISc, 6 IIMs. These are comparable to the world's best. ofcourse I am only talking about standard of education and not about luxuries. And what makes u say that they left with great universities..where did u get all that from..they made a mess of everything..
Answer: Please read my post. I talk of Universities and you talk of everythingelse other than universities..Universities are the backbone of education and not the institutions mentioned by you..Just google and find out the ratings of Indian Universties, subjest wise..You will know where we stand..Name me one Indian university if it figures in the world merit list..
China War: The defeat in that was a result of unclear political will and ill conceived strategy...I agree with you..but let us not beat each other over the head with it..it was 40 yrs ago.
Answer: Its not beating each other at all. Its purely a case study and there is no way India can walk away without being compared with China.
China prosperity: Their growth is fuelled by a "infinite" supply of cheap man power. They didnt do any mircale. The initiated reforms 10-15 yrs ahead of india. India is catching up.
Wait for another 10 yrs. Atleast we have democracy. Atleast we are not treated like an immigrant in our own country. India still has higher salaries than China in services sector. India had more RnD Centers than China. We will take the dragon by its tail..!!
Answer: Please take this out of mind that I am trying to downplay our achievements. However, I can not be blind to naked truths..If their numbers are infinite, we are not lagging far behind in cheap labour. You might say that you are not treated like immigrants in your own country, but truth is not so..Tell me if Indian states accept people from other states in their services? if not, then is that not like immigration restriction of a sort?
Singapore vs banglore. Pls compare apples with apples.
Answer: City verses city is very much apple for apple...All major US, canadian or Japanese cities would compare with Singapore for that matter...Mind you Singapore was also a British colony like we were...
South Korea. Good example..they are enjoying the fruits of sustained capitalism and american support.
Answer: If they are enjoying, then what stops us??
Indian doctrine of no first attack. Tell me why, India with a growth rate of 7-8%, stable political environment, would sabotage its growth prospects, dent its reserves by getting into an armed conflict with the terrorist neighbour. Military is an instrument of diplomatic policy which should be used as the last resort. This is what exactly was done by previous government. Though they lacked vision and clear diplomatic goal but they did exert ample amount of pressure on pakistan. Even military superpower US is fighting against terrorism. The difference is that it is doing it far away from its borders. India cannot risk a conflict with a nuclear armed terrorist rogue state in its neighbourhood.
Answer: No comments as its a matter of one's perception. We all are bound to have differing views on such issues...
Rajendra Kumar Kalkhunde (Sep 26, 2004 05:46 a.m.):