Dear Anil,
Your questions are genuine. It is the question of our perception. In a democracy, the elected govt needs to take the decision on behalf of people. If we elect a weak govt it is our fault.
Now the answer to your questions.
What strategic use of military you see in our scenario. Our first and foremost enemy is at our home with in our borders and not outside it. I identiy it as population explosion and poverty. These are the two issues any leader has to address first. Off course while doing so, he needs to protect his job as well.
Having a strong military does not mean its use any where and every where. We have contributed to all UN missions and our troops have done exceptionally well on all occassions. Indian troops are the most preferred one in UN. That speaks for the professionalism of our military.
Further, we have enough things at our hand within our own country to handle, in terms of insurgency in various parts of our country. Let me assure, you our military leaders are fully competent in use of our military power.
You have raised the question of furthering Indian goals I guess by military means. What are those goals that you anticipate. The best solution to any disupte is always the diplomatic solution. A full fledged war with Pakistan may not be in interest of either country. It is not only the war, but aftermath of the war that needs to be planned.
Now the question of using our market as a weapon. Surely if we need to. But we have to think that once we use it as a weapon, and the world finds another alternative (for example China) we will be left alone. So we have to be really judicious in our dealing with such things. Surely we can argue and use it as a strenght if not weapon.
Thirdly your question of doing nothing does not make our responsible. There are two type of situation. One is when you don't have the means to do any thing and you don't do any thing, that is weakness. The second situation is that you have means to do a thing and you don't do it because you can better do it by diplomatic means, that is strength.
Our foreign policy had been of Non alignment and peaceful coexistence and the leaders work according to that. Who made this policy and why we still follow it and why don't we change it, is a separte topic by itself. Surely, it has worked for our country so far. Some times we do feel disgusted, by govt not taking punitive actions against terrorist attacks, but that should be understandable. It is very easy to start a war, it is very difficult to conclude it. You can see the examples of American involvement in Vietnam and now in Iraq. Iran-Iraq war lasted for almost a decade and so was Soviet involvement in Afghanistan.
International relations is a complex issue and we all have different opinions on it.
I have tried my best to answer the questions raised by you. I only hope they are to some level of your satisfaction.
anil chaudhary (Sep 23, 2004 10:13 a.m.):
Ur inputs are great and I have more Qs based on it:
1) Agreed we have a good military, which gives us the foundation. But have we used it effectively to further our strategic goals? Do our leaders who control the military have the will/guts to use it to further Indias goal?
2) We are the market and labor supplier to the world. With this type of economy, can we use it as weapon in world poltics ? Do our leaders know how to use it at all?
3) Its true that we have never attacked any other country. Doing nothing does not show we are responsible. We have to use the resources we have to do something good, that shows responsibility.
In a few isolated cases we have used our resources well like Rajiv Gandhi did in Mauritias and Sri Lanka, or the economic blocked of Nepal. But we as nation never seen a strategic consistant world policy. Apart from Rajiv Gandhi and to a small lenght some of the BJP leaders, all our political leaders do not think outside of winning the next election.
UN is a political forum of the world. First and formost the political leaders should have the ability and resposibility to think global. Then they must learn the craft of using the countries military and economic power for benefit of India and the world.