unsc permanet seat

Status
Not open for further replies.

mukeshkumar007

Active member
the issue of permanet seat in uno security council is still important because it give a responsibility to a country to do better for peace and development in world. but i think now the method is change. there are five country have a permanent seat and they always use his right in own favour. they never think about the problem of world. they take unavoidable interest in internal affair of any country evenif they have no right to do so.
so i think it is need of time to reconstructed or reorganised the structure of security council and uno. we must need to redefine the peace in entire world. otherwise the moto of uno will become unuseful very soon.

now india is also put up his bid for unsc permanent seat. i think all powerfull country should support india bid because it cannot be ignored the view of 1.2 crore peoples. there are several reason behind india's bid. india is growing up in asia. india is an emerging power in asia. india economic is a world's 2 fastest growing economic. so unsc permanent seat should be given to india.
 
The idea behind the permanent seat was based on "responsible" criteria not economic or population. The members assumed that they where the most reponsible nations in the world and had the resources to keep UN on track and prevent mischief by other nations. This was the theory, pls do not go into the argument on what actually happened. Whats Indias score in this selection test? Does India have the military and economic power to change the course of future ? Has India demonstrated that it uses its power responsibly?
Idealy I would prefer to scrap the permanent seats altogether, but I dont see that happening in next 50 yrs.
 
In case of invasion in Iraq even permanent seat was of NO value..

Basic Logic ( Different saga of its VALUE in case of IRAQ ) jiski lathee usi ki bhains.
 
i agree with ur comments " jiski lathi uski baish.".
but i think it is the time to make balance in strength. otherwise the moto of peace will go else.
 
Look on the positive side:

This is step foreward. India must have achieved something that is why they are able to bid for one. It was not going to happen just like that.

Whats Indias score in this selection test?
Very good score :)

Does India have the military and economic power to change the course of future ?

Seems like that.. that is why they are talking about India.

Has India demonstrated that it uses its power responsibly? Yes It has.. Hasn't it?
 
A very interesting topic, thanks Mukesh.
There are three questions raised by Anil. Let me address them one by one.

Firstly: Does India has military power to change the course of world. The answer is Yes. India has one of the largest military in the world and has the resources to enhance it in case of need. To enhance the military power, two things are important, money and men. How many countries in world have both? Even with all the bad things we hear about the corruption in military, and other places, let us not ignore the fact that we still have one of the best military a nation can have.

The second question raised is "Does India has the economy to change the course of world?" The answer is yes. I am not an economist, but fundamentally there are two things needed for economy to grow and one of them is the market. Probably India has one of the biggest consumer market in the world. With advancement made in the field of technology, we should be looking for a brighter future, only if we can manage our internal affairs well. I know that is a tall order, but which country does not have these problems.

The third question raised by Anil is "Has India used its powers responsibly?" The answer is again "Yes". We have never attacked any other country. We have resorted to use of force only once the diplomatic channels had been permanently closed. See the effort made by us prior to 1971 war to diffuse the tension and exert the diplomatic pressure on Pakistan to prevent the influx of refugees from earstwhile East Pakistan. And if you had followed that war, the first shot was still fired by our neighbor.

While permanent seat in the security counsil may not bring drastic changes in the functioning of the UN, we still deserve it and must bid for it and try to get it.

I agree with the members that a balance of power in the world is essential and international community need to work for it. The UN need to be strengthened. It has worked fairly well till now and all effort must be made to improve it. It is also right that the countries funding will and should always have a better say in it.
 
Ur inputs are great and I have more Qs based on it:

1) Agreed we have a good military, which gives us the foundation. But have we used it effectively to further our strategic goals? Do our leaders who control the military have the will/guts to use it to further Indias goal?

2) We are the market and labor supplier to the world. With this type of economy, can we use it as weapon in world poltics ? Do our leaders know how to use it at all?

3) Its true that we have never attacked any other country. Doing nothing does not show we are responsible. We have to use the resources we have to do something good, that shows responsibility.

In a few isolated cases we have used our resources well like Rajiv Gandhi did in Mauritias and Sri Lanka, or the economic blocked of Nepal. But we as nation never seen a strategic consistant world policy. Apart from Rajiv Gandhi and to a small lenght some of the BJP leaders, all our political leaders do not think outside of winning the next election.
UN is a political forum of the world. First and formost the political leaders should have the ability and resposibility to think global. Then they must learn the craft of using the countries military and economic power for benefit of India and the world.
 
Dear Anil,
Your questions are genuine. It is the question of our perception. In a democracy, the elected govt needs to take the decision on behalf of people. If we elect a weak govt it is our fault.
Now the answer to your questions.
What strategic use of military you see in our scenario. Our first and foremost enemy is at our home with in our borders and not outside it. I identiy it as population explosion and poverty. These are the two issues any leader has to address first. Off course while doing so, he needs to protect his job as well.
Having a strong military does not mean its use any where and every where. We have contributed to all UN missions and our troops have done exceptionally well on all occassions. Indian troops are the most preferred one in UN. That speaks for the professionalism of our military.
Further, we have enough things at our hand within our own country to handle, in terms of insurgency in various parts of our country. Let me assure, you our military leaders are fully competent in use of our military power.

You have raised the question of furthering Indian goals I guess by military means. What are those goals that you anticipate. The best solution to any disupte is always the diplomatic solution. A full fledged war with Pakistan may not be in interest of either country. It is not only the war, but aftermath of the war that needs to be planned.

Now the question of using our market as a weapon. Surely if we need to. But we have to think that once we use it as a weapon, and the world finds another alternative (for example China) we will be left alone. So we have to be really judicious in our dealing with such things. Surely we can argue and use it as a strenght if not weapon.

Thirdly your question of doing nothing does not make our responsible. There are two type of situation. One is when you don't have the means to do any thing and you don't do any thing, that is weakness. The second situation is that you have means to do a thing and you don't do it because you can better do it by diplomatic means, that is strength.

Our foreign policy had been of Non alignment and peaceful coexistence and the leaders work according to that. Who made this policy and why we still follow it and why don't we change it, is a separte topic by itself. Surely, it has worked for our country so far. Some times we do feel disgusted, by govt not taking punitive actions against terrorist attacks, but that should be understandable. It is very easy to start a war, it is very difficult to conclude it. You can see the examples of American involvement in Vietnam and now in Iraq. Iran-Iraq war lasted for almost a decade and so was Soviet involvement in Afghanistan.

International relations is a complex issue and we all have different opinions on it.

I have tried my best to answer the questions raised by you. I only hope they are to some level of your satisfaction.

anil chaudhary (Sep 23, 2004 10:13 a.m.):
Ur inputs are great and I have more Qs based on it:

1) Agreed we have a good military, which gives us the foundation. But have we used it effectively to further our strategic goals? Do our leaders who control the military have the will/guts to use it to further Indias goal?

2) We are the market and labor supplier to the world. With this type of economy, can we use it as weapon in world poltics ? Do our leaders know how to use it at all?

3) Its true that we have never attacked any other country. Doing nothing does not show we are responsible. We have to use the resources we have to do something good, that shows responsibility.

In a few isolated cases we have used our resources well like Rajiv Gandhi did in Mauritias and Sri Lanka, or the economic blocked of Nepal. But we as nation never seen a strategic consistant world policy. Apart from Rajiv Gandhi and to a small lenght some of the BJP leaders, all our political leaders do not think outside of winning the next election.
UN is a political forum of the world. First and formost the political leaders should have the ability and resposibility to think global. Then they must learn the craft of using the countries military and economic power for benefit of India and the world.
 
Thanks Col Saheb for ur detailed ans. Its not me u have to convince, its India who has to convince the current 5 permanent members. U and me can only spread the good word and I think we are on the right path.
 
Thankyou Col Shab.
For ur answer to anil. and i am also thankful to anil that who raised many question.

col shab now i feel that india will get permanent seat in Uno after listen the speech of Dr. Man Mohan singh at uno in last night.
He putup india's bid in very strong manner.
so maie baghwan se parthna karta hoo ki 100 karor hindustanio ko unka hak mil jayega. agar aisa hota hai to man mahonji thanks ke patra hai.
 
Dear Friends,

My views are somewhat different on the topic;

1. India may have a large army, but India rarely had the will to use its army effectively, except in 1971. India still does not convey the image of a nation who can persue any diplomacy effectively.

2. Indian goverments of all shades lack foresight. There is rarely a debate in Indian parliament or for that matter on any other forum as to where they will like to see the India and how to reach there.

3. Indian success story is always the saga of few scattered people or groups and rarely an organised event.

4. Whatever we may wish or talk, the seat in UNSC will ultimately be decided by vote and I can almost write down here, how the votes will be caste by different nations and blocks. Muslim countries will not vote for India. Africans will vote for Japan who will almost buy their votes. USA, UK etc will keep playing their dirty politics and will do only what will suit them. As of now the UNSC seat is like a carrot which they will keep hanging ...and won't let anyone eat......

Rajendra
 
Dear Rajendra Ji,
Thanks for your views. Diversity of views create healty disucssions. I have a few points to make.

Your first question: India does not have a will to use its military power. I am wondering as to when we lacked in it. In 1962 we did not have a military power, so we could not have used it. In 1965 we did well as we did in 1971. Since 1971 I guess we had been doing well. Having a strong military does not mean we keep using it whether or not we need it. As I had said in my earlier posts, the best channel to solve is diplomatic channel. War should always be the last means. We did use our military in Kargil. The use of military flows from the national doctorin. Our policy is not of the first use of force. Our actions in international relations and politics have to be seen in this context.

The strength of a political leader outside the country is also seen by the world in relation to the political support he enjoys at home. Unfortunately, after Mr. Rajiv Gandhi, we did not have a govt which had a overwhelming majority in parliament. None the less, our leaders have done fairly well considering the thin edge at which their govts had been run. It is a difficult task in a democracy to run a strong govt with razor thin majority and some time with a bid and indiffirant coilation.

Meaningful debate in parliament depends upon the type of representatives we elect for it. Unfortunately, we have seen tainted leaders being elected and even been made ministers in Cabinet. But then that the way democracy works.

It is easy to critisize our leaders, but inspite of their problems most of them have done farily well at internaitonal level. I can only count two of them who in my opinion fell short of expectations. Firstly it was Mr. Chandrashekhar, who showed cold feet during the first Gulf War. As a nation, we were found wanting at international level. But then he had only about 30 odd MP's of his own, and was more busy in saving his own job. The second leader I feel was Mr. Devegowda. Apart from these, I guess most others have done well.

While your assessment may be true regarding as to who would get the UNSC seat, I would not comment on that. We really have too little knowledge about what is really happening behind the screen at UN. I would rather wait and watch and hope for the best.

While it is good to critisize and find out our weaknesses, I guess, we sould also see the possible compulsions and the pressures under which these leaders may be functioning.



Rajendra Kumar Kalkhunde (Sep 24, 2004 09:23 a.m.):
Dear Friends,

My views are somewhat different on the topic;

1. India may have a large army, but India rarely had the will to use its army effectively, except in 1971. India still does not convey the image of a nation who can persue any diplomacy effectively.

2. Indian goverments of all shades lack foresight. There is rarely a debate in Indian parliament or for that matter on any other forum as to where they will like to see the India and how to reach there.

3. Indian success story is always the saga of few scattered people or groups and rarely an organised event.

4. Whatever we may wish or talk, the seat in UNSC will ultimately be decided by vote and I can almost write down here, how the votes will be caste by different nations and blocks. Muslim countries will not vote for India. Africans will vote for Japan who will almost buy their votes. USA, UK etc will keep playing their dirty politics and will do only what will suit them. As of now the UNSC seat is like a carrot which they will keep hanging ...and won't let anyone eat......

Rajendra
 
Dear Tavathia Sahab,

I know the topic under discussion is highly a matter of indidual perception and views can be highly diversified. My personal belief is that Indian leaders have always fallen short of the faith public has posed in them. Public got divided in supporting them only when they failed even after getting huge majority. I wish to pose few questions which will clarify where we were and where we are as far as our share in world economy and education etc has changed with time.

1. British left some great universities in India. Have we been able to maintain their standards ? Is it not the people like Murli Manohar Joshi and Sahab Singh Verma who came from university backgrounds and are responsible for the state of affairs of our education system?

2. With his Hindi Chini bhai Bhai policy, Nehru apparantly was very close to Chinese leadership? Will any one excuse him for the humilating defeat India got because of intelligence failure ?

3. China was much poorer than India if one take 1947 as the starting year. Rest is a matter of public knowledge where China stands and where we stand..Didn't public give all the support of Indian leaders during the period when china was marching ahead of us on almost daily basis? China compted and got permanent membership of the UN security council.

4. First Singapore PM visited Bangalore in late fifties and was so impressed that he wanted Singapore to be like Bangalore..We all know where Singapore is today and where Bangalore is in relative terms..

5. South Corea was no where near India just 50 years back..now they are a larger economy than India

Somehow we Indians have developed the habit of being happy comparing ourselves with countries in Africa and Muslim world...To me its the leader who is responsible for where we are. Public is same almost all over the world...They follow anyone who promises them better future..

Indian doctrine of no first attack is again because of our weakness and not because of any maturity or international standing. Pakistan has been bleeding us in Kashmir everyday and we are talking of no first use...this is sheer hypocracy..Fact of the matter is that we are not sure if we will ever be able to win the next war and how long our amunition supply will last without paying high price....Whole India was behind Atal bihari when we massed our troops last time on boarder...Under international pressure he developed cold feet...In last 1000 years have we ever been able to convince the muslim invadors of peaceful coexistense??? Have our atom bombs been able to deter the terrorists in Kashmir?

Rajendra
 
Laton ke bhoot baton se nahi mante...so u have to use military pwr even when u r not attacked first. Except for the bangladesh war, we did not fight responsibly. China was a disastor even before it began. Nehru assumed that Indian army is the british army and walk over the chinese anytime.
 
Dear Rajendra Ji,

Thanks for your post. I understand the stand you are taking. Probably that is the view of most people who have not served in Indian armed forces.

Let me give you my reasons, of why the govt acts in a way that it has been acting. And if you have followed successive govts, on foreign policy most of them have had a very little or no variation. UNSC is a foreign relation issue and that is where this tread was started. Any way I will still try by best to answer the very important questions that you have raised.

The first question you have raised about the standard of Indian Universities. What is wrong with them. They are still one of the best in the world. Most of our average students in our universities, do extremely well when they go abroad for studies. If our education system was not good enough you yourself would not have been sitting in UK unless off course you studied outside India. So let us not condemn ourself on every issue that we raise. Nothing is perfect and there is alway a room for improvement. I also agree as to how many of our universities are in world class category, but we need to see the resources we have the burden of over population that our country is taking. Entire world, appreciates the Indian brain power and that is why India is number one in world today as far as service industry goes. If our universities were not good enough, it would not have been possible to achieve. Our IITs are still the best in the world. Our medical progessionals graduated from indian medical colleges are all doing well in other countries, and that shows the strength of our professional institutions.

Your next question is about failure against China in 1962. But if you have read my earlier posts, I have specifically mentioned that India did not have a strong military in 1962. Actually, we need to thank China for attacking us in 1962, otherwise we would have faced a more humiliating defeat in 1965. Why Mr. Nehru and congress still won in 1965 elections, is again a matter of political choice people make in a democracy. Probably the opposition was not strong enough to meet the challange of Congress.

Your third question is about comparision of progress China has made vs. India. Well, they have done better because they have a different political system. They are larger than us in size and if you compare the population density per square mile, they probably have more resources per individual. We have enjoyed freedom that democracy provides and I guess you need to pay price for it. But that does not mean the system is not working. The problem with our democracy is the basic understanding of the political system by our voters and for that we can't blame our leaders that they did not teach them. That could have been done by people like me and you. How many of us did actually did that. You came to UK and I came to USA for whatever reasons. China today has the biggest manufacturing infrastructure and thus number one in that sector, but they still are second to India as far as service industry goes. The last year US survey showed that while 50% of US investors want to invest in China, 27% want to invest in India. That could also be because of the fact that China has a more stable national government than India and that is purely because of two different political systems.

The third question is of comparing Singapore with Banglore. It is some thing comparing a family of 100 children with the family of one child. So, I would not even compare that. Singapore is a free port while Bangalore is part of a big nation which had prevented the foreign investments till 1991, to keep the indigeneous industry growing and protecting it from outside competetion. (I essentially don't agree with this policy that our govts had followed though, but that is how it was).

As far as South Korea goes, it had been funded by worlds best economy for past 60 years. So, even that comparision is not apples with apples. The question again comes to that why did not we followed the policies of South Korea if that is beneficial to a country. The answer is the political doctorine our elected govt followed over the period. We probably have our own better identity at international level than South Korea I guess.

Now your question of comparing ourselves to Muslim or South African countries. We had been the pioneer of Non align movement, and most of these countries are part of it. We have never towed the line of any super power in cold war era or after that on any international issue and have maintained our own policy of non alignment. Respecting the UN law is not a sign of weakness, but strength.

As far as remaining aligned to muslim world, there are two reasons for that. The firstly the huge political vote bank at home and second our dependence on foreign oil. So, whether we like it or not, it is going to remain same. In some form or other all political parties have tried to follow the policy of apeasement toward muslim population as well as toward the reserved classes. I guess that should be easy to understand.

The simple fact is these leaders need to protect their job first to do any thing worthwhile for the country. Me and you could not have been posting our views if we did not have access to internet, it is as simple as that.

Now, cold feet that Mr. Vajpayee showed after the mobilisation of troops. To fight a long war, you need a lot of oil reserve. Probably, that could be the reason. Don't you feel that our successive govts have still done well to keep the oil flow from Islamic countries in spite of Pakistan being a favored nation with them and our relation with Pakistan.

I agree with you that there is a lot that needs to be done, but every thing is not bad.

I have tried my best to answer your questions, I only hope they are to some level of your satisfaction.
 
Respected col shab
first of all i am thankful to you for giving a appropritate answer of rajendr's question.

colji in my views the best solution of all problem are following :-

1. elect capable and honest leader in election.
2. We always think negative about anything it is not good and progressive so we should improve our thinking (think positive.) because there are a two part of a coin. so we should consider all the part.
3. Every indians should try to improve the status of brotherhood.
4. every body criticized to corruption but nobody do any thing to solve this problem.In india every body corrupted whenever any person find any chance to get something through illegal he will get. so we must need to change this situation.

col shab i am really impressed with u to know your views about internal and external policiy of india.
but one place i am agree with rajendrji. that atal bihari vajpayee should not call back our troop after sending on border. because it give a wrong sign in entire world. now every country think that india dare not attack on pakistan.
this action is not gone in favour of india.
It publish india as week country. so we have must need to understand the motive of pakistan.

by the way ur suggestion is very affective. thankyour col shab.
 
Col sahab, whatever u say is right. It may be our compulsion or policy, but to the world these are just excuses. Till we overcome these, the power that will decide the unsc seat will not take us seriously. To have a realistic shot at the permanent seat we have to change the perception of India to the world and bring our system to the top std. If we cannot help ourselves how can others be confident that we can take up issues of the other weaker countries.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top