Mr Deswal
With respect
You are taking a very simplistic approach, by asking “ should one hate Islam” or “ not”?
Having done that, the people who have pointed out their difficulties with Islam, its followers, and their acts, have been bracketed as ‘ being those who hate Islam’
The members here are sensible , normal people, who do not hate anyone or anything.
They all know that ‘hate’ by itself it self destructive, and destroys ( eventually)the one who is the ‘hater’.
They certainly disagree with the teachings of Islam, and object to what the followers of Islam are doing.
They are more concerned with, what should be done about that, and how to get the followers of Islam to stop doing acts that cause others to ‘ hate’ them.
My abiding interest, as some know, is History!
History shows us, that wherever Islam has become dominant,( or even where it has become a significant minority), it has shown its intolerance of other faiths, and has successfully obliterated those other faiths, and those who followed those faiths- Buddhism/ Hinduism/ Zoroastrianism/Sikhism from what is now Syria, Arabia, Iraq, Iran Afghanistan, Pakistan, Bangladesh, Indonesia, Central Asia, and the parts of India..
That mindset, that cases those acts, can only be changed by those who follow Islam, by its leaders, its mullahs.
It cannot be changed by outsiders, arguing among themselves, whether they should ‘hate’ Islam or not?
Your discussion should be with them on their forums.
Ravi Chaudhary