Reality of FDI, beyond politics

Yes and that is point of contention. They always import and Indian doesn't import. So not at all a level playing field and we are putting the livelihood of more then 20 crore people on stake by allowing FDI in retail.

I've already mentioned they even sell medicine and what not. They will easily attract the consumer when consumer will get from A-Z item under one roof. and consequently the the local retailers will get die after some times.

The purpose is to show you that Agricultre produce is not everything they sell and thus 30% sourcing debate isnt even worthy. Most of what they sell is already being imported from China from local distributors.

BTW open the link, they do sell pharmacy and grocery online too. Dont be in a haste to reply, check that.
 
Contract is always linked with quality. They can reject the item at any time if the product won't meet their standard.
Though I don't have any direct reference related with WalMart.

But this the fact that Punjab farmer has thrown potatoes on the road even after the contract farming exist in Punjab irrespective of any company. So contract farming is also not a solution.

Yes but does it say that those farmers who protested were in contract with Walmart.

Understand contract- An assurance to buy.

Since you cant produce a direct proof, allow me: http://economictimes.indiatimes.com...benefits-punjab-farmers/videoshow/4842437.cms
 
bhai jayada virodh to is "contract farming" ke karan hi ho ruha hai... indian ka judicial system kaisa hai ye to yahan batane ki jarurat nahi hai... ek saal kisi chotte kisan ke aalu nahi kharide kisi retailer ne to vo kya apni kheti chood ke, us contract ko le ke court mai khada ho jayega... or maan lo khada bhi ho gaya to kitne din mai insaaf/compensation milega??? or vo insaaf/compensation lene ke liye usko kya pay karna pad jayega... ye court uska sab kuch bikwa ke usko karje mai la dange...

sarkar... beshak retail mai bhi FDI le aaye... but aisa kuch karne se pehle us-se related issues(contracts, imports & judiciary etc...) to resolve kar le...

Contract is always linked with quality. They can reject the item at any time if the product won't meet their standard.
Though I don't have any direct reference related with WalMart.

But this the fact that Punjab farmer has thrown potatoes on the road even after the contract farming exist in Punjab irrespective of any company. So contract farming is also not a solution.
 
Last edited:
bilkul sahi...jo main problem hia govt usko to sahi kar nahi rahi...bas public ko ek gaddhay sai nikal kar dusray gadhhay mai fake rahi hia...or dhika aise rahi jaise India ki sari problem solve ho jayda FDI in retail sai..

bhai jayada virodh to is "contract farming" ke karan hi ho ruha hai... indian ka judicial system kaisa hai ye to yahan batane ki jarurat nahi hai... ek saal kisi chotte kisan ke aalu nahi kharide kisi retailer ne to vo kya us contract ko le ke court mai khada ho jayega... or maan lo khada bhi ho gaya to kitne din mai insaaf/compensation milega??? or vo insaaf/compensation lene ke liye usko kya pay karna pad jayega... ye court uska sab kuch bikwa ke usko karje mai la dange...

sarkar... beshak retail mai bhi FDI le aaye... but aisa kuch karne se pehle us-se related issues(contracts, imports & judiciary etc...) to resolve kar le...
 
PAFC is not against contract farming, is it? Is is saying anything against private players?

Before your next post please get a proof about potatoes being wasted due to contract farming, else please dont mix 2 different issues without proof.

Govt enforce farmer what to produce and what to not in Punjab???:nonchalance:
 
This is from the website of Bharti WalMart:

[h=2]Benefits to farmers[/h]
  • 7-10% higher price to farmers than what they get from Mandi

http://www.bharti-walmart.in/BenefitToFarmers.aspx

From the above reference. It's clear that Bharti WalMart is also deciding the price based on Mandi rate and just giving a panny amount higher then the Mandi price.

So If Ludhina farmer were getting Rs 1/Kg from Market at the same time Bharti WalMart purchasing potato approximately at the same rate and was just 10 paise more.

Is it the so called Benefit to farmers?

PAFC is not against contract farming, is it? Is is saying anything against private players?

Before your next post please get a proof about potatoes being wasted due to contract farming, else please dont mix 2 different issues without proof.
 
Ask yourself, would you rather buy 7-10% higher or not?

This is from the website of Bharti WalMart:

[h=2]Benefits to farmers[/h]
  • 7-10% higher price to farmers than what they get from Mandi

http://www.bharti-walmart.in/BenefitToFarmers.aspx

From the above reference. It's clear that Bharti WalMart is also deciding the price based on Mandi rate and just giving a panny amount higher then the Mandi price.

So If Ludhina farmer were getting Rs 1/Kg from Market at the same time Bharti WalMart purchasing potato approximately at the same rate and was just 10 paise more.

Is it the so called Benefit to farmers?
 
Only time will throw light on the benefits or shortcomings of having FDI in retail, but one thing is for sure, this govt. acts as COMMISSION AGENTS. Show them the money and they can go to any length to pass any Act/legislation, be it Nuclear energy, FDI, etc. etc.

Their development model starts with the snatching of Roti from the plate of the aam admi. Their Economists in the Prestigious (:)) Planning Commission say that people who earn more than Rs. 28 a day are not poor. Great irony - People still buy the story of development and reforms spread by this CORRUPT CONGRESS.
 
Really???:nonchalance: The potato farmer getting Rs 1/kg and if they get Rs 1.07/kg then it will becomes a big deal?? wow...amazing

farmers sold their products in munn and quintals not in kg sirji:)
 
For farmers, or for anyone Penny Penny Makes Many and potato is not the only product produced, is it?

Also, should you not ignore the know-how, expertise and technology provided. Also, an assurance of purchase even before the crop is harvested takes away those tension lines from the heads of farmers.

I hope you have some understanding of the elementary level mathematics. You can figure out the price per munn or qunital.

But that's whats the cost farmer getting on per kg basis.
 
For farmers, or for anyone Penny Penny Makes Many and potato is not the only product produced, is it?

Also, should you not ignore the know-how, expertise and technology provided. Also, an assurance of purchase even before the crop is harvested takes away those tension lines from the heads of farmers.

I hope you have some understanding of the elementary level mathematics. You can figure out the price per munn or qunital.

But that's whats the cost farmer getting on per kg basis.
 
I'm not against contract farming per say!

I'm against FDI in retail or if I specifically say the foreign retail chain like Walmart etc.

For farmers, or for anyone Penny Penny Makes Many and potato is not the only product produced, is it?

Also, should you not ignore the know-how, expertise and technology provided. Also, an assurance of purchase even before the crop is harvested takes away those tension lines from the heads of farmers.
 
Last edited:
I hope you have some understanding of the elementary level mathematics. You can figure out the price per munn or qunital.

But that's whats the cost farmer getting on per kg basis.

figure out karn ki jarrut koni sirji tips pe se sare ankde.....kyki 20 killay ka jamidara khod karta hu............jis ko app 7 paisa kahte ho....bilkul tradational farming may
wo 8000 per acre padta hai....ye do fasli chakkar wheat or dhan/jeeri ki baat kar raha hu...........no doubt ye big deal h farmers kay liye.
 
When the Input cost is Rs 4/Kg and you'll get Rs 1/Kg or Rs 2/Kg...then it's not a big deal...and if somebody consider it as a big deal then I would say "dil ko behlanay kai liye galib khyal accha hia"

ar bees killay ka jaimndara hia to kheti kai sarvgayata na ho gaye aap jatto mai kellay...saray jattu ka background hi kheti tai related hia...kisi baniya kai aagay aise baat kartay to bhi aise gud ghutti wo hajam kar lete...yahan ek tai ek choudhary baathhay...:cool:

figure out karn ki jarrut koni sirji tips pe se sare ankde.....kyki 20 killay ka jamidara khod karta hu............jis ko app 7 paisa kahte ho....bilkul tradational farming may
wo 8000 per acre padta hai....ye do fasli chakkar wheat or dhan/jeeri ki baat kar raha hu...........no doubt ye big deal h farmers kay liye.
 
Back
Top