Reality of FDI, beyond politics

Don't you know that currency trading allows in India???

You can purchase the future and options of currency and big traders always manipulate it.

No matter how many investment comes in India now...the USD value won't go below Rs 50 now. It will keep continue to fluctuate between Rs 50-58

OK.. what sort of trading?? Can you plz enlighten me?
 
What sort of big traders are you talking about? Rakesh Jhunjhunwala type??

If I say that our Oil companies make payment by dollar, will rupee rise or fall?? If the value of Dollar falls against Euro, will rupee rise or fall??

I am no expert in economics, but generalization never gives correct picture. Yes, Demand and Supply rules the rise and fall of rupee or any other currency, but saying "only traders" is not correct. What is driving the selling or buying of Dollar is important. Merely saying that trading is solely responsible leads to ambiguous perceptions.
 
Yes Kind of Jhunjhunwala. Though Jhunjhunwala is not a trader, he is an investor. The actual currency conversion doesn't make much difference. The big oil companies or many other companies who deal in foreign currency hedge their position that certainly make difference.

I'm not generalizing. But it's fact the currency ups and down more or less depends on news flow now and some what on trading, because this is the source of earning of traders. The actual currency conversion doesn't make any impact now.

What sort of big traders are you talking about? Rakesh Jhunjhunwala type??

If I say that our Oil companies make payment by dollar, will rupee rise or fall?? If the value of Dollar falls against Euro, will rupee rise or fall??

I am no expert in economics, but generalization never gives correct picture. Yes, Demand and Supply rules the rise and fall of rupee or any other currency, but saying "only traders" is not correct. What is driving the selling or buying of Dollar is important. Merely saying that trading is solely responsible leads to ambiguous perceptions.
 
Yes Kind of Jhunjhunwala. Though Jhunjhunwala is not a trader, he is an investor. The actual currency conversion doesn't make much difference. The big oil companies or many other companies who deal in foreign currency hedge their position that certainly make difference.

I'm not generalizing. But it's fact the currency ups and down more or less depends on news flow now and some what on trading, because this is the source of earning of traders. The actual currency conversion doesn't make any impact now.


mere trading to some what trading.. :)
 
Not just traders, govt and RBI manipulates it even more. China's undervaluation of currency is hurting US the most and is a big topic in elections.

Don't you know that currency trading allows in India???

You can purchase the future and options of currency and big traders always manipulate it.

No matter how many investment comes in India now...the USD value won't go below Rs 50 now. It will keep continue to fluctuate between Rs 50-58
 
They get subsidy for different reasons, one of which is to motivate then to do farming because costs are high due to high labor rate.


Ok I understand now your logics more clearly after reading this piece of news. The important piece in this new is if things go wrong you have Govt to make the policies to protect farmers. To me this is bit contradictory. Are you favouring FDI because the current Govt policies are against Farmers? And in future you are expecting Govt to come to your rescue?


I dont think it is goiing to help our small farmers. We indians (including me) just believe in everything what we hear.



I dont understand this. Are you saying farming cost in UK, US is dearer because of subsidy or you saying they dont get subsidy that is why farming cost is high? You saying in india farming is cheap? but the selling price is even cheaper?- not quite clear what is being conveyed here.
 
To add, I think people are losing cite of the fact that private players buying directly from farmers will not replace the government procurement of foodgrains. The private system will supplement the govt. one. As noted in one of your previous posts, if the farmer doesnt get a good price from Wal-Mart etc., he can go to the mandi and sell at or above MSP.

The whole premise by which big retailers make money is that there are inefficiencies in the system. Right from guiding the farmer to transporting and selling the end-product, there are a lot of middle-men, delays and wastages that increase costs. Removing these can benefit all parties if done well.

Big retailers certainly makes the "process" more efficient and that's good for everyone.

With big retail chains, the fruits are shiny and the crop is good. However, are the roots getting the right manure?


I have been a regular visitor to these big retailers for my day-to-day grocery shopping. The things that I have noticed are:

1 - I feel that big retailers have some sort of random testing of goods that they sell, so they are less likely to have dangerous levels of adulteration than the ordinary shops.
2 - I do get vegetables and some other day-to-day grocery at discounted prices.
3 - They do provide multiple brands which I can inspect at my leisure and make a choice from.
4 - I feel that I am not getting cheated on the weight or volume of the product.
5 - They do provide better ambiance and shopping experience.
6 - The wastage of food and vegetables is much higher than the ordinary shops.

On the other side of the story, the impacts I have noticed to the farmer community are:
1 - A few people in our village have diversified into contract farming of fruits.
2 - Few have diversified into vegetable cultivation, earlier they used to saw vegetables only for their own family.
3 - A lot of them have now got suck into the churning wheels of capitalism and so keep very little produce for their own consumption. This has taken a heavy toll on their health. In my village, I have heard that in many families, all most all the milk is now sold to Relience and other dairies keeping very little for the children.

I am not sure if this is a direct or indirect consequence of the emergence of big retail chains but most of the money that is earned is getting spend on the alcohol.

I often ponder over these changes and thinking if they are any better. I end up debating with my self, given a choice, would I trade my health with all the benefits (1-6 & 1-2) listed above?

FDI or without FDI, the meaning of Haryana is getting lost. "देसों मैं देस हरयाणा जहाँ धुध दही का खाना" बड़ी बड़ी दुकानों और छोटे छोटे पैसों के बिच कहीं धुलमिल हो गया है|
 
Big retailers certainly makes the "process" more efficient and that's good for everyone.

With big retail chains, the fruits are shiny and the crop is good. However, are the roots getting the right manure?


I have been a regular visitor to these big retailers for my day-to-day grocery shopping. The things that I have noticed are:

1 - I feel that big retailers have some sort of random testing of goods that they sell, so they are less likely to have dangerous levels of adulteration than the ordinary shops.
2 - I do get vegetables and some other day-to-day grocery at discounted prices.
3 - They do provide multiple brands which I can inspect at my leisure and make a choice from.
4 - I feel that I am not getting cheated on the weight or volume of the product.
5 - They do provide better ambiance and shopping experience.
6 - The wastage of food and vegetables is much higher than the ordinary shops.

On the other side of the story, the impacts I have noticed to the farmer community are:
1 - A few people in our village have diversified into contract farming of fruits.
2 - Few have diversified into vegetable cultivation, earlier they used to saw vegetables only for their own family.
3 - A lot of them have now got suck into the churning wheels of capitalism and so keep very little produce for their own consumption. This has taken a heavy toll on their health. In my village, I have heard that in many families, all most all the milk is now sold to Relience and other dairies keeping very little for the children.

I am not sure if this is a direct or indirect consequence of the emergence of big retail chains but most of the money that is earned is getting spend on the alcohol.

I often ponder over these changes and thinking if they are any better. I end up debating with my self, given a choice, would I trade my health with all the benefits (1-6 & 1-2) listed above?

FDI or without FDI, the meaning of Haryana is getting lost. "देसों मैं देस हरयाणा जहाँ धुध दही का खाना" बड़ी बड़ी दुकानों और छोटे छोटे पैसों के बिच कहीं धुलमिल हो गया है|

The end use of money or rather the wastage of it is something we have seen before. The green revolution made middle and big farmers rich and I am not sure if everyone used that money efficiently. Still we cant resent the opportunity for them to make money.
 
भिखारियों को भीख मिलती है और दुत्कार उनसे कोई चौड़ी छाती करने की उम्मीद नहीं करता ! एक और तो हम भीख मांग रहे हैं और दूसरी और हम बात करते हैं अपने आपको सुपर पॉवर कहलवाने की ! इनसे कोई पूछे तेरे देश में करोड़ो लोग भूखे मर रहे हैं और तू बात करता है सबसे तेज कंप्यूटर बनाने की ("India is planning to build a computer that is going to be at least 61 times faster than the current fastest super computer, IBM Sequoia. Right now the most powerful supercomputer in India is 58th in the list of top 100 supercomputers. From the article: 'Telecom and IT Minister Kapil Sibal is understood to have written to Prime Minister Manmohan Singh sharing the roadmap to develop "petaflop and exaflop range of supercomputers" at an estimated cost of Rs 4,700 crore over 5 years.'") इसको खाने पीने का जुगाड़ नहीं तो और क्या कहेंगे ?जिस देश की आबादी १२० करोड़ से ज्यादा है और बासठ प्रतिशत दो डॉलर से कम कमाते हैं वहां ऐसी चीजो पे पैसे उड़ना कहाँ की सभ्यता है ? जिस देश की पहली कार सन २००० में बनी है (आजादी के ५० साल से भी ज्यादा के बाद ) जिस देश में आई टी की सबसे ज्यादा कंपनी हैं और खुद का एक भी ब्रांड नहीं ! जो देश भीख के हथियारों पे अपनी ताकत का दंभ भरता है ! जहाँ कट्टे के अलावा कुछ बना नहीं वहां ऐसी बातें एक मजाक लगती हैं! अमरीका कल भी पापा था आज भी पापा और कांग्रेस का राज आता रहा तो आगे भी पापा ही रहेगा ! उसने अपनी ताकत का एक हल्का सा नमूना दिखाया था जब इस देश वालो ने पहले तो उसके जहाज नहीं ख़रीदे और फिर ऍफ़ डी आई से भी कदम खिंच लिए ! कहाँ की डिमांड सप्लाई इरान का हाल देख लो ! एक चीज जो सिर्फ मेरे नियंत्रण में है और जिसे कोई दूसरा नहीं दे या बना सकता तो उसका दाम वो होगा जो में तय करूँगा ! रही बात चीन की तो वो हैं श्याने उनका दाम फिक्स है उन ने डॉलर कमाने के अलावा खरीद खरीद धर लिए और अपने आप को आत्मनिर्भर और शशक्त बना लिया ! वहां हर चीज की नक़ल बनाई अपने हथियार बनाये ! वो हर चीज जो अमरीका बनाता था उसकी नक़ल से बाजार भर दिया और उसके दम से दस गुना सस्ते में !अमेरिका ने मजबूरी में या मौकापरस्ती कहो की ये लुट रहा है तो लूटो के चक्कर में वहीँ से सब बनवाना शुरू कर दिया !चीन ने इतना सस्ता बेचा की लोग अपने यहाँ किसी हाल में न बना सकें उस से उसके उद्योगों को मजबूती और डॉलर मिले !आज अमेरिका के मैनुफक्चुरिंग सेक्टर का भठा बैठ गया और बेरोजगारी ने पा पसारे तो अमेरिका कुकावे है!
कंपनी अपने बाप की भी सगी न होती जिसका उदहारण आज चीन है वही मुंजाल जिसने अपने रिश्तेदारों की कंपनी खुलवाई थी (जब हीरो मोटर्स हीरो हौंडा होती थी) आज अपने धंधे का बीस प्रतिशत सामान चीन से बनवा रहा है ! कोई वालमार्ट यहाँ के भिखारियों को दान देने नहीं आ रही ना ही वो यहाँ की सप्लाई चैन सही करने आ रही वो आयेगी सिर्फ और सिर्फ मुनाफा कमाने !इस देश के किसानो उसके कोई सगे नहीं हैं जिन्हें वो मुह मांगे दाम देगी ! ईस्ट इंडिया कंपनी की याद १९९१ तक ताजा थी तो लोगो ने विदेशी कंपनियों को इस देश में नहीं घुसने दिए और आज का ना कुछ करने वाला मनमोहन और पटवारी बंगाली इनको फिर से बुला लाये !
किसान को सब्सिडी के नाम पे सरकार भीख नहीं देती बल्कि इस खुद भीख मांगती है क्योंकि ऐसे करने से वो किसान का अधिकार छीन लेती है! अधिकार अपनी फसल के दाम तय करने का !ले लो सारी सब्सिडी वापस और होने दो गेहूं १०० रुपये किलो फिर ये गोदामों में सड़ने वाला गेहू म्यूजियम में धरा जागा ! सरकार कहती है ये सप्लाई चैन सही करेंगे ! इस देश में सबसे ज्यादा सब्जियां और दुसरे नंबर पे फल पैदा होते हैं उन्हें कहाँ रखोगे ? ऐसे ही गोदामों में जहाँ ये गेहूं रखा है ? अगर ऐसा हुआ तो वो सरदार के पाले हुवे कुत्ते और चूहे ( दलाल और बिचोलिये ) भूखे मर जायेंगे ! और फिर पैसे के बदले वोट खरीदने वाले पैसे पैसे के लिए मोहताज हो जायेंगे !

जज्बात बहुत हैं पर सारे बोर हो जाओगे कदे टेम काढ के फुर्सत तें बैठांगे !
 
जज्बात बहुत हैं पर सारे बोर हो जाओगे कदे टेम काढ के फुर्सत तें बैठांगे !

Rakesh, Kadh de bihtar ka sara, bore koni howaann, Jatland ki soon !!!:singing:
 
Last edited:
The end use of money or rather the wastage of it is something we have seen before. The green revolution made middle and big farmers rich and I am not sure if everyone used that money efficiently. Still we cant resent the opportunity for them to make money.

Yes, looking from a logical viewpoint things look brighter. It's good that they are getting better opportunities of making money. Also, retail chain isn't forcing them to sell that "family's" share of milk.

However, the realistic viewpoint depicts a different picture, pointing to obvious gaps.
 
Last edited:
Copied from Facebook with thanks from status of a jatand member and my friend Vikas Sindhu
छोटा सा गाम मेरा पुरा बिग् बाजार था
एक नाई, एक खाती ,एक काला लुहार था ।
छोटे घर थे ,हर आदमी बङा दिलदार था
छोटा सा गाम मेरा पुरा बिग् बाजार था ।


कितै रोटी खां लेतै ,हर घर मे भोजऩ तैयार था,
छोटा सा गाम मेरा पुरा बिग् बाजार था ।
बिटोङे पे घिया तौरी हो जाती
जिसके आगे शाही पनीर बेकार था,
छोटा सा गाम मेरा पुरा बिग् बाजार था ।

दो मिऩट की मैगी ना ,झटपट दलिया तैयार था,
छोटा सा गाम मेरा पुरा बिग् बाजार था ।
नीम की निबॊँली और शहतुत सदाबहार था,
छोटा सा गाम मेरा पुरा बिग् बाजार था
अपणा घङवा कस बजा लेते “
तिलक गिरावङ “पुरा संगीतकार था
छोटा सा गाम मेरा पुरा बिग् बाजार था
 
The other way to look at it are

a) Indian consumers will get fine products
b) Farmers, like in Punjab and Gujrat will produce fine produce with technological know-how
c) Even if such a scenario happens, the parallel system is not going anywhere

Lalu said a very crucial statement: 'We buy shoes from AC malls but food from roadside open stalls..... '

What corporate sector did to US small family farmers and you claim FDI will help farmers, seriously doubt. Read this eye opening article!

http://www.thehindu.com/opinion/columns/sainath/knowing-your-onions-in-new-york/article4156928.ece
 
ha ha ha ha chlo koi to lalu ka fan hai...

The other way to look at it are

a) Indian consumers will get fine products
b) Farmers, like in Punjab and Gujrat will produce fine produce with technological know-how
c) Even if such a scenario happens, the parallel system is not going anywhere

Lalu said a very crucial statement: 'We buy shoes from AC malls but food from roadside open stalls..... '
 
Back
Top