Reality of FDI, beyond politics

kya comment karu??? tune to uski statement ko crucial bata diya!!! mugjhe vo sun-ne ke layak bhi nahi lagi, comment karna to door ki baat hai...

shoes and food... ye dono AC mall mai bhi bikte hain or sadak pe bhi, buyer class and good's cost change ho jati hai bas... isme crucial kya hai??? or comment kya karna hai???

Comment on what he said, not on my idol list which you know nothing of.
 
आज सपा और बसपा ने साबित कर दिया कि देश
की राजनीती कितनी गिरी हुई हैं। देश की जनता ने उनको वोट
दिया था संसद में अपनी बात रखने के लिए,
ना की कायरो की तरह संसद छोड़ कर भाग जाने के लिए।
अपना भाषण देते वक़्त तो मुलायम सिंह और मायावती ने
fdi के विरोध में बड़ी- बड़ी बाते कही पर जब वोट देने
की बारी आई तो ये कायरो की तरह संसद के बाहर भाग गए।
मुझे नहीं पता था की ये मतदान fdi बनाम cbi था।
अगर यहीं हालत रही तो भारतीय राजनीती हमेशा शर्मसार होती रहेगी।
नेता प्रतिपक्ष सुषमा स्वराज ने आज ये साबित
किया कि अगर वो अकेले इतना लड़ सकती हैं तो फिर उन्हें
पार्टी का सपोर्ट मिल जाता तो बात ही कुछ और थी।
सुषमा स्वराज ने लालू को भी नहीं बख्शा, लालू जिन्होंने
fdi की तुलना ट्वीटर से की थी उसके लिए सुषमा स्वराज
का यह शेर तो जबरदस्त था |
आपको गांठे खोलना नहीं आता,
और मस्करी के अलावा कुछ बोलना नहीं आता।
और अंत में सुषमा स्वराज के द्वारा संसद में कहा गया यह
शेर,
तारीखों के हालातो ने वो हाल भी देखा है,
गलती लम्हों ने की थी, सजा सदियों ने भोगा है।
 
What corporate sector did to US small family farmers and you claim FDI will help farmers, seriously doubt. Read this eye opening article
http://ww.tindu.opinicolumns/sainath/knowyour-onions-in-new-york/article4156928.ece
Good read but we would be mistaken to feel the will necessarily happen in India. The US doesnt have a govt procurement of foodgrains like we do, so things arw different. For one, the supply chain in India isnt so advanced to let corporates take over. The producers and the buyers are all scattered. So one cant simply waltz in and replace an existing model. The mandis abdand tge public procurement of grains is not going away. It's just the farmer will have a choice in whom he wants to sell..
 
Sushma Swaraj's false claims and reality of McD

[video]http://www.ndtv.com/video/player/news/video-story/257374?video-justadded[/video]
 
भारतीय बाजार में एंट्री के लिए लॉबीइंग करने के वॉलमार्ट के कबूलनामे के बाद विपक्ष के भारी हंगामे की वजह से राज्यसभा की कार्यवाही मंगलवार तक के लिए स्थगित कर दी गई। बीजेपी, लेफ्ट, तृणमूल कांग्रेस, अन्नाद्रमुक, जेडीयू, एजीपी, शिवसेना और सरकार को बाहर से समर्थन दे रही एसपी के सदस्यों ने इस मुद्दे पर प्रधानमंत्री से सफाई देने और एफडीआई पर रोक लगाने की मांग की।
मल्टि-ब्रैंड रीटेल में एफडीआई के लिए वॉलमार्ट के 125 करोड़ रुपये खर्च करने की खबर के बाद बीजेपी ने आज कहा कि सरकार एफडीआई के मुद्दे पर फंड मैनेजमेंट से जीती है और वह इसका सच बताए। मुख्य विपक्षी पार्टी ने कहा कि सरकार बताए कि इस प्रस्ताव को पास कराने के लिए मनी मैनेजमेंट में बिचौलिये की भूमिका किसने निभाई। बीजेपी नेता रविशंकर प्रसाद ने राज्यसभा में कहा कि लॉबीइंग के नाम पर रिश्वत दी गई है। सरकार बताए कि यह रिश्वत किसे दी गई।
फिलहाल सरकार ने इस मामले में कोई बयान नहीं दिया है। सरकार की तरफ से कार्मिक मंत्री नारायण सामी ने सिर्फ इतना कहा कि संबंधित मंत्री इस मुद्दे पर जवाब देंगे। वहीं विदेश मंत्री सलमान खुर्शीद ने कहा कि अमेरिका में कंपनियों को लॉबीइंग करने की छूट होती है।
उधर, समाजवादी पार्टी के सीनियर नेता और राज्यसभा सांसद मोहन सिंह ने विचित्र तर्क दिया है। उन्होंने कहा कि हमारी पार्टी के सांसदों ने लॉबीइंग की रकम नहीं ली है। ऐसा इसलिए कि हमारे किसी भी सांसद को अंग्रेजी नहीं आती है।
 
मल्टि-ब्रैंड रीटेल में एफडीआई के लिए वॉलमार्ट के 125 करोड़ रुपये खर्च करने की खबर के बाद बीजेपी ने आज कहा कि सरकार एफडीआई के मुद्दे पर फंड मैनेजमेंट से जीती है और वह इसका सच बताए।

Lobbying is not giving money or corruption please get that notion clear first. Every company hires lobbyists across the world to get an access to government resources. A lobbying in simple words can be known as a communicator.

Also, the amount mentioned is spent worldwide so do not mislead.
 
Lobbying is not giving money or corruption please get that notion clear first. Every company hires lobbyists across the world to get an access to government resources. A lobbying in simple words can be known as a communicator.

Also, the amount mentioned is spent worldwide so do not mislead.



I do favor FDI but to your point Lobbying is legal in US but not India so if you are doing it in india it is corruption and illegal..Lobbying and communicator are two separate things, dont mislead people by giving wrong information this or terming lobbying and communicator as one In simple word it is not known as communicator but dalal. Do you really think that you need 125 crore if it is simple communication. This 125 crore is in walmart disclosure and it is for India. giving one more link for your reference.One can very easily comprehend that amount that is not accounted. It is not rocket engineering that it takes time to understand where this amount is spent.


http://in.news.yahoo.com/walmart-lobbying-report-kicks-up-a-storm-122454463.html

One more point to other, it is futile to talk on this now. If BJP really thinks it is so bad they should go to people and tell the other aspect of it. They should seek mandate and when they comes to power they can revert this bill rather than cribbing on this now.
 
I do favor FDI but to your point Lobbying is legal in US but not India so if you are doing it in india it is corruption and illegal..Lobbying and communicator are two separate things, dont mislead people by giving wrong information this or terming lobbying and communicator as one In simple word it is not known as communicator but dalal. Do you really think that you need 125 crore if it is simple communication. This 125 crore is in walmart disclosure and it is for India. giving one more link for your reference.One can very easily comprehend that amount that is not accounted. It is not rocket engineering that it takes time to understand where this amount is spent.


http://in.news.yahoo.com/walmart-lobbying-report-kicks-up-a-storm-122454463.html

One more point to other, it is futile to talk on this now. If BJP really thinks it is so bad they should go to people and tell the other aspect of it. They should seek mandate and when they comes to power they can revert this bill rather than cribbing on this now.

Rinku, actually the article you posted is a little confusing and both supports and refutes your points.

Note the word including below. It means that $25Mn was spent on a host of lobbying activities and not just on its India entry. But then in the very next para, the article states that the money was spent exclusively for India. So its a little confusing. Personally, I'd say the $25Mn figure is the overall lobbying figure and not just the India figure. The reason I say this is because, companies usually avoid giving details and break-up information as much as possible for such expenses. It creates problems like the ones we saw yesterday in the RS or trade analysts pick up these nuggets and spread misinformation.
A disclosure report filed by Walmart with the United States Senate that says that the world's largest retailer spent $25 million (about Rs 125 crore) since 2008 on its lobbying activities, including on efforts related to gaining entry into India. Lobbying is legal in the United States, but not in India.

The report says that Walmart spent $25 million for 'enhanced market access for
investment in India'.

Note that the organizations it lobbied with were all US and none were Indian, which is perfectly legal and normal in the US.
The company lobbied for better access to India with the US Senate, the US House of Representatives, the US Trade Representative, and the US Department of State.

And I agree, its futile to discuss this now when the bill has passed both houses. And I am sure BJP is not going to reverse the law when it comes to power. For one we all know, BJP like others is playing the role of the opposition and just opposing for the sake of it. Second, there will be too much at stake in 2 years to reverse laws. Investments would have been made, Infra would have been set up, deals and MoUs would have been signed. You reverse that decision and risk losing not only jobs and money in India, but your global business perception suffers.
 
Lobbying is not giving money or corruption please get that notion clear first. Every company hires lobbyists across the world to get an access to government resources. A lobbying in simple words can be known as a communicator.

Also, the amount mentioned is spent worldwide so do not mislead.

भाई मैंने ये नहीं लिखा की सरे पैसे भारत में खर्च हुए है |मगर भारत में लॉबिंग अवैध है. ये एक किस्म की रिश्वत है. अगर वॉलमार्ट कहता है कि उसने ये पैसे (या कुछ पैसे) भारत में ख़र्चे तो ये घूस है. रिंकू ओर सिवाच भाई ने ठीक कहा के अब इसको उठाने का फायदा नहीं है पर अगर ऐसा हुया है तो भी तो गलत है |
 
मगर भारत में लॉबिंग अवैध है. ये एक किस्म की रिश्वत है. अगर वॉलमार्ट कहता है कि उसने ये पैसे (या कुछ पैसे) भारत में ख़र्चे तो ये घूस है.

Sandeep bhai- Lobbying in India is not illegal and nothing new. Infact if you have heard of Dilip Cherian, Suhel Seth- they are famous lobbyists in India. Lobbying is not just working with government but there are a lot of other aspects to it like PR, marketing, media management etc etc and it is perfectly legal.

Read this:http://www.nytimes.com/2006/05/18/b.../18iht-lobby.1778893.html?pagewanted=all&_r=0
 
For claims of 125 crores spent in India, please read this: http://economictimes.indiatimes.com...uckus-in-rajya-sabha/articleshow/17565498.cms and http://www.thehindu.com/news/international/us-defends-walmart-lobbying/article4186996.ece

'BJP tried to kick up a row in Parliament on Monday, after media reports said that Walmart spent $25 million, since 2008, lobbying with US lawmakers, which included trying for "enhanced market access for investment in India".'

Money was spent in US and only a part of it was used for India. I am still trying to make sense why is BJP again going for an anti-congress decisive politics which it has suffered for past 8 years. It is time to do some constructive politics instead of misleading the country saying entire money was spent on India.
 
परमिट देकर होस्ट बन गया अपने देस का शासन,
दूर देस का कोई बनिया बेचेगा अब रासन,
मैं कहता हूँ छोटे बनियों तलवारे बनवा लो,
गलवाकर के अपने घर के सारे खाली बासन
!!
 
Rinku, actually the article you posted is a little confusing and both supports and refutes your points.

Note the word including below. It means that $25Mn was spent on a host of lobbying activities and not just on its India entry. But then in the very next para, the article states that the money was spent exclusively for India. So its a little confusing. Personally, I'd say the $25Mn figure is the overall lobbying figure and not just the India figure. The reason I say this is because, companies usually avoid giving details and break-up information as much as possible for such expenses. It creates problems like the ones we saw yesterday in the RS or trade analysts pick up these nuggets and spread misinformation.


Note that the organizations it lobbied with were all US and none were Indian, which is perfectly legal and normal in the US.


And I agree, its futile to discuss this now when the bill has passed both houses. And I am sure BJP is not going to reverse the law when it comes to power. For one we all know, BJP like others is playing the role of the opposition and just opposing for the sake of it. Second, there will be too much at stake in 2 years to reverse laws. Investments would have been made, Infra would have been set up, deals and MoUs would have been signed. You reverse that decision and risk losing not only jobs and money in India, but your global business perception suffers.

Swaich you dint get the gist of the thing I was stating here.I don’t want to go off topic and as I said FDI bill is already passed in both the houses and it is futile to talk on that. My point was you mentioned lobbyist as a communicator in simple words but they are way different and if it is done in india it is illegal and motivating corruption.
I agree that company don’t divulge much detail on figures like this and even if they do it is tip of iceberg. So to your point suppose if it is not 25 and say it is 10m dollar, don’t you think that is corruption and wrong???
Let us not have horse views of things, when they do these activities even in US to impact decision in Indiaan legislator then also it is wrong be it done by during UPA for that matter during NDA. When dawood Ibrahim sitting in Pakistan influence people here and indulge them in terrorist activities, don’t you think that is wrong even though he is outside nation?
 
Last edited:
Vikas you dint get the gist of the thing I was stating here.I don’t want to go off topic and as I said FDI bill is already passed in both the houses and it is futile to talk on that. My point was you mentioned lobbyist as a communicator in simple words but they are way different and if it is done in india it is illegal and motivating corruption.
I agree that company don’t divulge much detail on figures like this and even if they do it is tip of iceberg. So to your point suppose if it is not 25 and say it is 10m dollar, don’t you think that is corruption and wrong???
Let us not have horse views of things, when they do these activities even in US to impact decision in Indiaan legislator then also it is wrong be it done by during UPA for that matter during NDA. When dawood Ibrahim sitting in Pakistan influence people here and indulge them in terrorist activities, don’t you think that is wrong even though he is outside nation?

Rinku, I did get your drift. And I agreed with you previously too. Its slightly off topic since the bill has been passed, but lets continue the discussion since it is an interesting one and brings out previously unheard aspects like lobbying.

A lobbyist can be called a communicator (a good one I guess, since that what he's hired for), if he indulges in communication only. But unfortunately, even in developed nations, lobbying happens simply as exchange of favors. These favors take monetary form in developing nations and can also be called as bribes. If a bribe is proved, its corruption for sure.

Now about the figure. $25mn or $10mn, if it happened in the US, where it is legal, then it is not wrong. We shouldn't forget, the ones being lobbied were US Senators, Congressmen and trade committee folks. So as long as people directly linked with decision making in India weren't involved, its not corruption.

And I dont know if you know, but Indian govt. has been employing lobbying firms in DC to influence its case on various issues that come up in US house for discussion. These are trade, foreign policy etc etc. This was much more evident 10 years or so earlier when Kashmir and Nuclear blasts related issues were coming up in the Senate and India wanted to avoid sanctions or simply push back Pakistani lobby keen on bringing up the Kashmir issue. In fact the Pressler Amendment that restricted US arms sale to Pakistan was brought about intense lobbying of Senators by India backed groups. So its not new. In fact I remember reading about India hiring the biggest lobbying firm during the late 90s.

About Dawood Ibrahim. He's a man with known terrorist links which are detrimental to India. Wal-mart or others dont have known links to people or groups that are detrimental to India (at least not proved yet).
 
Last edited:
A lobbyist can be called a communicator (a good one I guess, since that what he's hired for), if he indulges in communication only. But unfortunately, even in developed nations, lobbying happens simply as exchange of favors. These favors take monetary form in developing nations and can also be called as bribes. If a bribe is proved, its corruption for sure.

Now about the figure. $25mn or $10mn, if it happened in the US, where it is legal, then it is not wrong. We shouldn't forget, the ones being lobbied were US Senators, Congressmen and trade committee folks. So as long as people directly linked with decision making in India weren't involved, its not corruption.

And I dont know if you know, but Indian govt. has been employing lobbying firms in DC to influence its case on various issues that come up in US house for discussion. These are trade, foreign policy etc etc. This was much more evident 10 years or so earlier when Kashmir and Nuclear blasts related issues were coming up in the Senate and India wanted to avoid sanctions or simply push back Pakistani lobby keen on bringing up the Kashmir issue. In fact the Pressler Amendment that restricted US arms sale to Pakistan was brought about intense lobbying of Senators by India backed groups. So its not new. In fact I remember reading about India hiring the biggest lobbying firm during the late 90s.

About Dawood Ibrahim. He's a man with known terrorist links which are detrimental to India. Wal-mart or others dont have known links to people or groups that are detrimental to India (at least not proved yet).

Swaich, as i said earlier lobbyist and communicator are lot different. Job of lobbyist is not to communicate rather to influence politicians in there favor and that can never be done with plain communication. A lobbyist can never and in fact should not be called a simple communicator. A communicator just share and exchange information,lobbyist job comes after this exchange is done.

This is how Oxford define lobbyist:-'a group of people seeking to influence politicians or public officials on a particular issue'

Coming to second point, i also said 'let us assume it happened in US' and you also saying 'if it happened in US'.I also know it is legal in US but my point is it is wrong if some outside India are element are doing something wrong to influence our politicians be it from within country or outside. i'm also not too sure and it might have happened in india as well and that is why we witnessed another hue and cry in parliament by BJP to find where and how and by whom.

India doing it in US is fine because it is legal in US but not other way round it is wrong

A policemen slapping a person and mother slapping her child are not exactly same even though they both a doing same thing.

As i said i have my own views on FDI.We both in fact whole worlds knows about Dawood .I was trying to explain a point with that there which you have already got.
 
Back
Top