How do you rate Manmohan Singh led UPA government and Why?

How do you rate Manmohan Singh's Government?


  • Total voters
    63
  • Poll closed .
VPSinghji maano koni aap bhi.....
dont know which kind of vision you are talking about
The vision i was talking about was making India a nuclear power, electing the APJ Kalam as president....
Recognising the need of strong defence sturcture..Moral of defense personnel is lowest under this government, taking in confidence neighbouring countires.. ULFA terrorist were executed in Bhutan while Naga rebels network was destroyed in Burma..Keeping in check foreign policies of SriLanka...Developing and Indian Airforce base in Tajikistan...
These are some of the steps taken by previous government in developing India as Superpower.



Aap ne ghana bera hoga aap government servant ho.... Mera analysis to yo hi ke Congress ne kewal kursi te matlab hai... chahey desh ka kimi hoo..
Atamjeet ji, the seed of nuclear plant was, perhaps, sown much before BJP Governments.
The iron lady Indira Gandhi was much more conscious about India's defence requirements. Our nuclear and other defence research programmes were very much in existence during her regime. It is a continued process and keeps going on with additions and extensions during all regimes irrespective of any political party. How could a country like ours be oblivious of the external threats after two full scale invasions by our neighbours (1962 China, 1971 Pakistan). Therefore, the genesis of our nuclear programme dates back to Congresss Era. The success cannot be attributed to Shri Kalam only. The decision to appoint him as President was, however, appreciable and I admire Shri Kalam's vision and contribution in extending the research programmes already in hand.

Defence Services being indispensable, it is every government's compulsion as well as moral duty to keep the morale of its defence personnel always high. That is what Congresss has also done by giving them some extra benefits in the last Pay Commission Report's Review.

As for keeping the neighbouring countries in confidence, it has always been part of our Foreign Policy which has been pursued continuially by all successive governments without any paradigm shift.

Frankly I have no idea how the foreign policies of Sri Lanka were kept in check. You may like to elaborate further.

Execution of ULFA Terrorists: Again, it was an extension of war already waged by the previous government. BJP, however, could not wipe out ULFA single-handedly. Credit goes to Bhutan also with whom good friendly relations were cultivated over decades by the previous governments. How far BJP succeeded in wiping out terrorism in Kashmir is a question mark. Even if you give full marks to BJP, you have to give full marks to Congress also for Opereration Blue Star and end of militancy in Punjab which was not a mean achievement of Indira Gandhi for which she had to sacrifice her life.

Tajikistan air base: Military cooperation with other countries and joint exercises are, again, continued processes which are kept out of public domain.

India as a super power: I have no reason to doubt the intention of the UPA Govt. to make India a Super Power. Let us see how far do they succeed.

Kursi for 'matlab' : In Indian politics, I see very few 'saints' with a mission of 'self-less service' of the country. Majority of politicians in all the parties (Congress included) are in politics with ulterior motives of personal gratification. Majority of them are corrupt and their mission is just to perpetuate their hegemony, acquire political influence, get high positions in government jobs for their relatives, and groom their sons/daughters to be future politicians. Most of them give a damn to the country/voters once they come to power and simply mint money, flaunt their influence, richness and muscle power while moving around in SUVs escorted by musclemen and the security staff.
 
Last edited:
VPSinghji I think we were discussing about MMS (weakest PM) not Indira Gandhi...

The discussion was not about Dr. Kalam either but you brought him into picture while listing achievements of BJP. Politics is a vast subject and if we are discussing it, it is impossible to avoid a reference to peripheral and interlinked issues and there cannot be a water tight boundary to restrict the discussion.
 
Dr. Kalam was appointed as President by BJP thats what i want to say not what he achieved as scientist. Dr. Kalam, a person loyal to country not to a family... the criteria used by present government while electing President.
 
Dr. Kalam was appointed as President by BJP thats what i want to say not what he achieved as scientist. Dr. Kalam, a person loyal to country not to a family... the criteria used by present government while electing President.

According to media reports, even Congress wanted Dr. Kalam to run for second term but the left group which was the biggest coalition partner was not supportive of Kalam's candidature. Therefore, Congress had to field a non-controversial and non-descript candidate. There is always a "kitchen cabinet" in all the parties/governments without exception. It is true that there was gossip about Pratibha Patil being loyal to Nehru family but she is equally loyal to the country also.
 
Last edited:
According to media reports, even Congress wanted Dr. Kalam to run for second term but the left group which was the biggest coalition partner was not supportive of Kalam's candidature. Therefore, Congress had to field a non-controversial and non-descript candidate. There is always a "kitchen cabinet" in all the parties/governments without exception. It is true that there was gossip about Pratibha Patil being loyal to Nehru family but she is equally loyal to the country also.

Ram Ram Bhai Jee

I appreciate your dedication to a political party, if Congress wanted they would have elected him easily without the support of left group. All said let me remind you BJP + Shiv + JDU suggested the candidature of Dr. Kalam.

As far as Smt. Pratibha Patil candidature is concerned she is no match to the person like Dr. Kalam even TN Seshan. She is equally loyal to the country ...Yes she may be "How come her husband is not even touched after so many threats to the farmer" I 100% doubt she was selected on the basis of eligibility than closeness to Sonia Gandhi.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Ram Ram Bhai Jee

I appreciate your dedication to a political party, if Congress wanted they would have elected him easily without the support of left group. All said let me remind you BJP + Shiv + JDU suggested the candidature of Dr. Kalam.

As far as Smt. Pratibha Patil candidature is concerned she is no match to the person like Dr. Kalam even TN Shesion. She is equally loyal to the country ...Yes she may be "How come his husband is not even touched after so many threats to the farmer" I 100% doubt she was selected on the basis of eligibility than closeness to Sonia Gandhi.
I am sure you can never guess anyone's political affiliation simply going by few lines randomly scribbled here on this forum and it is not very significant too. One has to be apolitical while in discussion on a public forum. Hardly makes any difference whether you and me are BJP wala, Congress wala or anything else.

Coming to topic, nepotism is nothing new to Indian polity. It is rampant in every party and loyalty gets rewarded everywhere.

In our system how significant the post of President is, we all know. So it hardly matters who is President. You mentioned about Seshan. When he was a bureaucrat, he always remained a docile government servant remaining part and parcel of the corrupt system as a mute spectator. Anyway, let us not drag him here.

I have already agreed on certain points highlighted by some friends regarding UPA's underperformance. One has to suggest a solution and a viable alternative while criticizing any party/government.
 
Last edited:
Courtesan electronic media houses lack the courage to make something like this below attached work in the form of video in our sub-contitent. It is not anyway directly related with present discussion but indirectly it punches a lot of blows on our sab chalta hai yaar unquestioning slave mentality. If you watch it you will come out , atleast, with new questions and paradigms and if you don't then it doesn't matter to me, at last. Your choice.



To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.





Now, come back here again dear readers after an international stimulation!

I am immensely pleased with the sane [sometime firey, no issues] and grand discussion by all members. Many would object with practicality hammer that it is of no use *just* talking here about politics, development etc but unless you not don't discuss, you keep on believing [ and actually later doing ] onto projected and crafted myths about governance and voting certain leadersand parties. It is like if you tell a lie 99 times it would become a holy truth 100th times. Firstly, idea is to avoid listening but can't help much because that is so widespread and common in this techonoligical era. Secondaly, anyhow, if one learned that pretty lie , such involving discussions may be helpful to see things from another angel and that 99 times things,fortunately, would work for truth as well.

Detractors[most significant people] ,supporters and maximum of rest lazy readers{Swadu type} with popcorn or a cup of tea in hand , it is not a Criticism discussion as it appears apparently in your peripheral vision, it is more of introspectory, retrospectory and awareness based discussion. Demanding or projecting [ It is a PS for quirky Mr VP Singh and alike posters ] present discussion as useless and further over emphasis onto providing political alternatives may left readers in a confused state which obstrcuts the genuine questioning which is the inherent motive of this discussion.

I have already agreed on certain points highlighted by some friends regarding UPA's underperformance. One has to suggest a solution and a viable alternative while criticizing any party/government.

Okay, tell me, why it is convincingly useless?

It itself was a major point when original post was posted that Does the lack of alternative for current regime can be taken as its success or does it immune to rate anyway? Lets see what do you say of it? Fingers crossed!


Thanks to all who vote and post and shame to rest who don't and pass this indifferently.
{ Okie Okie last line was in your lighter vain, don't write back that you don't 've one }
 
Last edited:
Ram Ram Bhai Jee

I appreciate your dedication to a political party, if Congress wanted they would have elected him easily without the support of left group. All said let me remind you BJP + Shiv + JDU suggested the candidature of Dr. Kalam.

As far as Smt. Pratibha Patil candidature is concerned she is no match to the person like Dr. Kalam even TN Seshan. She is equally loyal to the country ...Yes she may be "How come her husband is not even touched after so many threats to the farmer" I 100% doubt she was selected on the basis of eligibility than closeness to Sonia Gandhi.

partibha patil doomed one co.op.bank,she was chairperson of this bank,she and her relatives goluped 100 of acre of collage and school land ileagely ,there are murder cases against her and her brother,and there are many more which is not allowed to come out by sonia and chamcha party.
 
@Samar: Samar, it was not at all a useless thread. You are conveniently ignoring my argument that unless we are able to suggest some solution or alternative, the discussion will remain unfruitful or useless so to speak. It was a very serious thread and I appreciate your initiative. I do sincerely hope that you will continue to bring such valuable topics in future also.
 
Last edited:
श्री मनमोहन सिंह एक इमानदार शख्शियत है ! आज के युग में एक इमानदार राजनीतिज्ञ का होना नामुकिन ही नहीं एक अजूबे से कम नहीं !
अगर इस दृष्टिकोण से देखे, तब वह बहुत ही उपयुक्त व्यक्ति हैं इस पद के लिए ! हमें एक बात नहीं भूलनी चाहिए कि एक ईमानदार व्यक्ति भ्रष्ट राजनेताओं के लिए ज्यादा खतरनाक साबित हो सकता है, इसलिए थोडा बहुत खोफ भी रहेगा और ज्यादा ज्यादा प्रभावी भी होगा! वे एक मृदुभाषी व्यक्ति है पर वो उनकी कमजोरी कदापि नहीं कही जा सकती ! उनके विरुद्ध केवल उनकी उम्र है !
तदापि उनका विकल्प ही कहाँ है कांग्रेस के पास ? अतः में उन्हें ८/१० अंक देता हूँ !
 
He is a good man. But to allow corruption to the tune of thousand of crores during CWG. A new city with an international airport, with all stadiums and residential area could have been made in the desert of Rajasthan with 75000 Crores.
Shameful ?
 
Lakra saheb

It is true that there was corruption of highest magnitude in the development of facilities and management of CWG but how we have arrived to this figure of 75000 cores attached to the commonwealth Games. Large portion of this money has been spent on city's basic infrastructure. Those flyovers, up gradation of roads and sanitation etc. were overdue. Delhi's population deserved those facilities, whether CWG were held in Delhi or elsewhere. Development of any other venue also would have attracted corruption. The corrupt agencies like MCD, CPWD CWG management committee and the politicians would have shared the loot, even if the CWG were held else where.
Also, corruption is inherent in our system or rather i would say, it has become integral part of our public life. But I still believe that Mr. Manmohan Singh wouldn't shield these corrupt people if and when found guilty.
 
But I still believe that Mr. Manmohan Singh wouldn't shield these corrupt people if and when found guilty.

Think Again Deshwal ji. CAG reports clearly indicated this Lungi Walla Mantri has caused a loss of One Lakh 76 Thousand Crore rupess in 2G telecommunication spectrum deal. PM , who is at seven sky aftar Obama visit , is silent. This scam seems like father of CWG. Irony is mantri himself is denying even after his CAG and his own secretary has clearly indicated his role..
 
After CAG report, D. Raja should have resigned on moral grounds which he doesn't seem to do. He must be sacked by the PM. Not taking any action against the tinted Minister will certainly sully PM's image putting a big question mark on his strength.
 
After CAG report, D. Raja should have resigned on moral grounds which he doesn't seem to do. He must be sacked by the PM. Not taking any action against the tinted Minister will certainly sully PM's image putting a big question mark on his strength.

Few questions to all.

Isn't this resignation drama enough to convenience public that corrupts are being bought to book and justice is being done?

If your answer is yes, then answer these:

Does the law of the land annuls a crime if a prominent person resigns from the post he/she was holding?
Would this resignation, bring back billions of rupees that have been looted from public?
Why is no one talking about bringing back the looted money to public? For someone it could be the money for the day's meal.
Would the looted money ever come back to public? Has it ever came back before?


... This is how the illusion plays. Publics perception is modified by playing some drama or other and thus hiding the actual issue.
 
Last edited:
Few questions to all.

Isn't this resignation drama enough to convenience public that corrupts are being bought to book and justice is being done?

If your answer is yes, then answer these:

Does the law of the land annuls a crime if a prominent person resigns from the post he/she was holding?
Would this resignation, bring back billions of rupees that have been looted from public?
Why is no one talking about bringing back the looted money to public? For someone it could be the money for the day's meal.
Would the looted money ever come back to public? Has it ever came back before?


... This is how the illusion plays. Publics perception is modified by playing some drama or other and thus hiding the actual issue.

The answer to your first query is a big NO. Resignation is not enough. Money should be brought back. Criminal case should be lodged. Stern punishment should be handed down by the appropriate authority to the guilty irrespective of his/her status. Hope things will move in right direction in due course.
 
This UPA govt is total failure!!!!!

‎Manmohan Singh has absolute accountability but not absolute power, Sonia Gandhi has absolute power but not absolute accountability.
 
Back
Top