SHRIKRISHNA – The Greatest Yogi Of All Times

Status
Not open for further replies.
Vijay Jee Dhanyawad,

Bhai Vijay je or Sh. Deshwal Jee,

meinney aap say nivedan kiya tha kee kirpya Shree Krishan key Janm say prarambh karkey short mein kewal itna bata dein kee jo unkey janm kee katha hum padhtey hain wo sahi hai kya? unka janm Karagar mein hua tha kya, unkey mata Kans kee bahan thee kya ? Maha bharat satya hai kya ? or sabsay jyada utsukta ka visay eak sadharn insaan mein itney assadhran gun kesay aaye.

Aapney Krishanavtar book key vishay mein likha hai wo bhee main avashay padhunga parantoo aabhee key liyea kirpya itna bata dain.

Aapkey utter kee pratiksha main.
Karmveer


करमवीर भाई साहब,

मुझे पता नहीं आपने कहाँ कहाँ श्रीकृष्ण के बारे में पढ़ा है ! उनके बारे में हजारों पुस्तके लिखी गई है कुछ इतिहास को आधार मान कर और शेष उन्हें एक काल्पनिक व्यक्तितव समझ कर ( या यूं कहिये भगवान् मानकर ) ! कथाकारों को उनका व्यक्तितव हमेशा से ही आकर्षित करता रहा है और उनके जीवन के विभिन्न प्रसंगों को हमेशा अपने अपने ढंग से प्रस्तुत करते रहे हैं .... लेकिन हम इसे सच नहीं मान सकते ! सच वही है जो महाभारत जैसे ग्रंथो में लिखा है या जिन लोगो ने उन पर शोधकार्य करके लिखा है नाकि काव्यात्मक कवितायें या उनका भगवान् की तरह गुणगान !

एक साधारण इंसान थे जिनमे असाधारण गुण थे ! उनके मित्र एवं रिश्तेदार उन्हें एक समझदार और सूझबूझ वाला इंसान मानते थे नाकि भगवान् का एक अवतार ! पांडव भी उन्हें भाई की तरह मानते और संबोधित करते थे ! उम्र में वो युधिष्ठर और भीम से छोटे थे और अर्जुन, नकुल और सहदेव से बडे ! पांडव ये मानते थे की श्री कृष्ण बहुत चतुर और गुणी इंसान है इसीलिए हमेशा उनकी बात मानते थे और उनसे सहायता की अपेक्षा रखते थे !

(अगर आप श्री कृष्ण के बारे में और ज्यादा जानना कहते हैं तो में आपको एक पुस्तक पढने की सलाह दूंगा
कृष्णावतार - खंड १ से ७
लेखक - कन्हैयालाल माणिकलाल मुंशी
इस पुस्तक में आपको ऐसी छोटी छोटी जानकारी मिलेगी जो अपने शायद कहीं नहीं पढी होगी )

योगी लोगो को बहुत बार घटनाओं का पूर्वाभास हो जाता है ! क्या कई बार हमें नहीं होता ! क्या हमें कई बार ये महसूस नहीं होता की आज कुछ ग़लत होने वाला है या फ़िर कुछ अच्छा होने वाला है ! योगियों को हमसे ज्यादा पूर्वाभास होता है !

बात रही युद्ध में हारने की .. तो में ये कहूँगा कि बहुत बार हारने वाले को पक्का पता होता है कि युद्ध में हार होने वाली है लेकिन फ़िर भी मान मर्यादा या मजबूरी में लड़ना पड़ता है !

उनका लक्ष्य बुराई को समाप्त करना था किसी भी तरीके से ! जब श्री कृष्ण जरासंध को युद्ध में नहीं हरा सके तो उनके चतुराई से काम लिया ! भीम, अर्जुन और स्वयं श्री कृष्ण जरासंध की नगरी में गए और मल्लयुद्ध के लिए ललकारा ! यहाँ भी उन्होंने चतुराई दिखाई ... उन्होंने कहा "ऐ जरासंध, या तो अपनी हार मान ले या फ़िर हम तीनो में से किसी एक के साथ मल्लयुद्ध कर". वो ये जानते थे कि जरासंध घमंडी है और दंभ के कारण सबसे बलशाली भीम को ही मल्लयुद्ध के लिए चुनेगा ! ऐसा ही हुआ और भीम ने उसे मौत के घाट उतार दिया ! इस तरह एक पापी का अंत हुआ !

अब उनके अंत के बारे में !
जैसा कि पहले बताया वो एक साधारण इंसान थे ! असाधारण शक्तियां होते हुए भी उन्होंने साधारण इंसान की तरह ज़िंदगी को जिया ! उन्होंने अपने जीवन के लक्ष्य पूरे कर लिए थे और सिर्फ़ साधना में लीन रहते थे ! और एक साधारण इंसान की तरह उनका अंत हुआ !
 
Hare Krishna Shrimaan Ji..Hare Krishna

Hare Krishna Shrimaan Ji..Hare Krishna

Bye the way...there is lot fo periodical difference between Sri Ram & Sri Krishna.

Almost 17Lkh or 1.7Lkh saal ka.

Sri Krishna ji ka time to almost 5000 yrs back ka hai....so we use to get so many evidences which empower our devoteeship.

Anyway
Geeta me Sri krishna Ji ne kaha hai
"..Karm karte jaao phal ki ichchha mat karo..."

So just doing that.
 
Hare Krishna Shrimaan Ji..Hare Krishna

Bye the way...there is lot fo periodical difference between Sri Ram & Sri Krishna.

Almost 17Lkh or 1.7Lkh saal ka. ???????????????????????????????????????

Sri Krishna ji ka time to almost 5000 yrs back ka hai....so we use to get so many evidences which empower our devoteeship.

Anyway
Geeta me Sri krishna Ji ne kaha hai
"..Karm karte jaao phal ki ichchha mat karo..."

So just doing that.
................hmmmmmmmmmmmmmm
 
Karamveer ji,

If you are really "utsuk" knowing about Srikrishna, please study Mahabharat(Bhagwad Gita is a part of Mahabharat). Since you said you are really interested in knowing about Srikrishna, I am sure you will have time to read it.

Shri Krishna took birth from Devaki. He studied Vedas along-with Sudama in the ashram of Rishi Sandeepan. The great saints like Shri Ram, Shri Krishna, Swami Dayanand etc., are remembered only for their greatest deeds which they did for themselves as well as for public to maintain peace, to unite nation, to kill the sorrows of the public etc. They gave a lot of spiritual as well as knowledge of worldly pious duties etc. We remember them to follow their preach.

It is not important to know how Srikrishna was born and which school did he go to, as it is not going to serve any purpose. and there is no way to prove it. What is important is to try to follow his preach if one can.
 
Bhai Vijay je or Sh. Deshwal Jee,

meinney aap say nivedan kiya tha kee kirpya Shree Krishan key Janm say prarambh karkey short mein kewal itna bata dein kee jo unkey janm kee katha hum padhtey hain wo sahi hai kya? unka janm Karagar mein hua tha kya, unkey mata Kans kee bahan thee kya ? Maha bharat satya hai kya ? or sabsay jyada utsukta ka visay eak sadharn insaan mein itney assadhran gun kesay aaye.

Aapney Krishanavtar book key vishay mein likha hai wo bhee main avashay padhunga parantoo aabhee key liyea kirpya itna bata dain.

Aapkey utter kee pratiksha main.
Karmveer

Karamveer bhai,

Yes, he was born in jail. His mother Devki was sister of Kamsa. Kamsa prisoned his father Ugrasen and declared himself King of Mathura. Pandva's mother Kunti was sister ( not real ) of Krishna'a father Vasudeva. Kunti was adopted by King Kuntibhoj and hence she was named Kunti otherwise her real name was Pritha. Later Krishna's real sister Subhadra was married to Arjuna.

Monuments of Mahabharta periods are almost everywhere in India. Dwarka founded by Krishna ( when he had to shift from Mathura ) was in Gujrat. Remains of the Dwarka city/town were found in Arabian sea near Gujrat few years ago. Carbon dating proves that they are approx 5000 years old ( exact time when Mahabharata and Krishan were supposed to be there )

Rest is on you ..... do some home work ..... analyze and conclude. :)
 
Scientific findings

.
As Vijay has written above, scientific research is pointing to the correct time of Mahabharata period. On Shrikrishna’s birth, many stories erupted later on – such as prediction revealed to Kansa that Devki’s eighth son will cause his death, etc. etc. This does not match with original Mahabharat written by Vedvyas.

All over the world, scientific researches are going on about historical entities. German Scholar Holger Kersten has written that ‘original Jesus’ was a Buddhist and has little relation to Judaism. In 1983, Kersten wrote a book which became so popular that its English translation was published simultaneously in Britain, USA and Australia. It was translated in 15 more languages. Kersten did not write this book ‘Jesus in India’ overnight. From 1973 to 1983, he traveled extensively in India, Israel and Greece. He writes that Roman Catholic Church later made him a ‘Gospel of God’ in the same way as India’s Brahmins portrayed their own myths about ancient great men of India. See some links below:

http://www.tombofjesus.com/core/majorplayers/kersten.html

http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/ISBN=1852305509/insearcoftheloviA/

In 2003, American writer Dan Brown wrote a novel called “The Vinci Code’ – later a feature film also appeared with the same name. Brown says "almost everything our fathers taught us about Christ is false." He writes that Jesus married Mary Magdalene and had a son. All these scientifically proven facts do not match with Christian missionaries’ preaching and the Holy Bible.

http://www.christianitytoday.com/history/newsletter/2003/nov7.html

Are the incidents of Christ’s “reincarnation”, his taking birth from a ‘virgin mother’, his sainthood and unmarried life etc. true?

Let us also accept the fact that Shri Krishna was a real human being, a great man and not a mythical or Godly figure as portrayed in subsequent literature written by greedy Brahmins.

.
 
Mere ko to lagta hai kee Dayanand Deswal Ji khud hee bhagwaan hai. Because he is renouncing everything with conviction after reading few books. And that is the problem today.

I would put these authers way-way below than Shri Krishnan Ji. And if that is the case why beleive anybody else. We better belive in the Lord who himself has recited Shri Gita to Arjuna. Why do we need anybody's clarification. And why do we need to compare west analogy with our way of leaving. I am been in the west for 15 years and they are still confused even after claiming they live in developed world. They have good system though which attracts people. They are still learning from Asia when comes to food and vegetables etc.

Back in old day we used have saying -

Daal Roti Khao, Prabhu ke Gun gao.

Aaj kal Daal=Butter Chicken Roti=Naan, Prabhu is Politician.

Everything is measured by bank balance. There is only one factor today to measur the success and that is bank balance and result is visible today. Execetptions are there. People do B.E., F.R.C.S., M.B.B.S etc and read lots of books because they are educated and reading becomes there interest. They only like which satisfy there material need. We have to understand the Shastras As It Is. No concession in understanding. I wish I can find somebody who can make me educate in these. Shri Bhagvat Gita was meant for Kali-Yuga where people will not have time read Ved etc. But it is visible that people want even Shri Gita on the Go.

Guru biana Gyan Nahi. Shatras are very complex.

ekam sastram Devaki-Putra-Gitam
eko devo Devaki-Putra eva

Nothing above Gita (abstract of Vedas, Puranas, Upnishad's) and will not accept anything below. Please do not ask for proof that Gita is not a abstract of Ved, Puran, Upnishad as I do not have.

Brahmins are not by cast or by birth, which I think you consider and that is why you have issues. The one who knows the absolute truth of Vedas is real Brahmin. They are not greedy. Finding them may be difficult if not impossible.

And if we beleive, for the God sake, in Bhagvat Gita or Mahabharat then Shri Krishanji himself said that -

Vasudev mAm iTi! He also said that surrender to me.
He says with conviction.

One has to surrender. If not now then in form of death. We must learn -
The Art of Dying (Hari ka Smaran) not The Art of leaving (Sansarik Bhog).

No author above Shastras.

SSC.
 
Mere ko to lagta hai kee Dayanand Deswal Ji khud hee bhagwaan hai. Because he is renouncing everything with conviction after reading few books. And that is the problem today.

I would put these authers way-way below than Shri Krishnan Ji. And if that is the case why beleive anybody else. We better belive in the Lord who himself has recited Shri Gita to Arjuna. Why do we need anybody's clarification.
Back in old day we used have saying -

Daal Roti Khao, Prabhu ke Gun gao.

Aaj kal Daal=Butter Chicken Roti=Naan, Prabhu is Politician.

I wish I can find somebody who can make me educate in these. Shri Bhagvat Gita was meant for Kali-Yuga where people will not have time read Ved etc. But it is visible that people want even Shri Gita on the Go.

Guru biana Gyan Nahi. Shatras are very complex.

ekam sastram Devaki-Putra-Gitam
eko devo Devaki-Putra eva

Nothing above Gita (abstract of Vedas, Puranas, Upnishad's) and will not accept anything below. Please do not ask for proof that Gita is not a abstract of Ved, Puran, Upnishad as I do not have.

Brahmins are not by cast or by birth, which I think you consider and that is why you have issues. The one who knows the absolute truth of Vedas is real Brahmin. They are not greedy. Finding them may be difficult if not impossible.

And if we beleive, for the God sake, in Bhagvat Gita or Mahabharat then Shri Krishanji himself said that -

No author above Shastras.

SSC.

I find so many contradictions in this long post and do not feel to detail all these here. Shrikrishna did not have a voice-recorder or a video-camera or some reporter noting down all that in a notebook - that too in the battlefield. Gita is a short chapter of Mahabharata. Naturally, the author of Gita is VedVyas.

And there are many things above "Shastras". Logic is the key-word and any book or Shastra should face the test of logic - no blind-faith !
.
 
I find so many contradictions in this long post and do not feel to detail all these here. Shrikrishna did not have a voice-recorder or a video-camera or some reporter noting down all that in a notebook - that too in the battlefield. Gita is a short chapter of Mahabharata. Naturally, the author of Gita is VedVyas.

And there are many things above "Shastras". Logic is the key-word and any book or Shastra should face the test of logic - no blind-faith !
.

but deshwalji logic and wisdom are not the same I hope you will agree with me on that.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top